Roscoe or Wolfgang?

[salem_]

Okay I'm currently evaluating if I should keep Wolfgang or try Roscoe. Would be a cranky for a cranky. Since I already have Lobo as a wolfie I was thinking of getting another specie. Also who would fit better a spooky island?

 

[shayminskyforme88]

Personally I like Wolfgang better and actually have him as well. However, if you want to diversify specie and stick with your theme. I think Roscoe would be a better fit. He looks spookier than Wolfgang. So I voted for Roscoe in the poll.

 

[Sweetley]

I would say Roscoe, especially since his design fits better to a spooky themed island.

 

[Marta]

I've never had either of them, but I really like Roscoe's design and it goes really well with a spooky island theme

 

[coffee biscuit]

I'm definitely choosing Roscoe. He's a black horse, he has big angry red eyes (and his sclera turns yellow when he angry emotes) so he definitely fits the spooky theme much more than Wolfgang.

Also, Roscoe is less popular than Wolfgang so it'd be nice to give him some love.

 

[Manon_Despoina]

Roscoe! Love my demon horse (still need to find him in NH though) I would say he fits the spooky theme the best

 

[brockbrock]

I definitely prefer Wolfgang out of those two, but since you have Lobo I would for sure go with Roscoe. He fits the theme of your island better, in my opinion!

 

[Potcha]

Roscoe is spookier looking and also because he is one of my favourite villagers. His house is also spooky outside and dark decor inside.

 

[salem_]

Thanks all! I'm gonna give a chance to Roscoe!

 

[petrichr]

I have Wolfgang atm and love him but Roscoe suits your island theme better and their personality is the same so dialogue wise it's quite similar. Also you already have one wolf (I can't talk I have 3).

 

[daisyy]

think roscoe wins on both counts for a different species and a spooky island. i have in on my island and he's definitely one of my favorite villagers! (and not at all cranky once you get to know him)

 

[Rosewater]

Roscoe would fit better for a spooky island. Wolfgang is a total cutie but definitely go with Roscoe.