Rank My Villagers!

[hibiskuuss]

I saw someone do this yesterday and I really wanted to jump on the bandwagon because I usually go by the popularity list here on Belltree to figure out which of my villagers is most popular among the community however, many of my personal favorites in my town are really low on the list. I don't believe everyone in the community goes by their favorites based on the tier list all the time so I'm really curious how people view who I have in my town compared to my own personal opinion. (And yes I don't really like Marshal haha there's a reason for that lmao)

Sherb, Marshal, Dobie, Judy, Kyle, Audie, Shep, Raymond, Skye, Sylvana

Spoiler: Pictures of the Villagers!

My ranking would be:

10. Judy
9. Sherb
8. Marshal
7. Dobie
6. Audie
5. Raymond
4. Sylvana
3. Shep
2. Skye
1. Kyle​

 

[Jam86]

aww your villagers are so cute
i'd rank them:
10: sylvana
9: dobie
8: kyle
7: skye
6: judy
5: audie
4: raymond
3: sherb
2: shep
1: marshal

sylvana is adorable but this is actually the first time i've seen her lol

 

[hibiskuuss]

aww your villagers are so cute
i'd rank them:
10: sylvana
9: dobie
8: kyle
7: skye
6: judy
5: audie
4: raymond
3: sherb
2: shep
1: marshal

sylvana is adorable but this is actually the first time i've seen her lol

I kind of expect a lot of people to put marshal as #1 haha xD

 

[Daisies]

This is an interesting idea! I’d rank them
10. Dobie
9. Judy
8. Shep
7. Audie
6. Sylvana
5. Raymond
4. Kyle
3. Sherb
2. Marshall
1. Skye

you have some really cute villagers!

 

[hibiskuuss]

This is an interesting idea! I’d rank them
10. Dobie
9. Judy
8. Shep
7. Audie
6. Sylvana
5. Raymond
4. Kyle
3. Sherb
2. Marshall
1. Skye

you have some really cute villagers!

Aww thank you, and yes since I saw skye in NL I have loved her ever since <3 I always can't decide between kyle or skye for my #1 spot

 

[Xara]

these are fun! based on my personal preference:

10. kyle
9. shep
8. sylvana
7. judy
6. raymond
5. marshal
4. sherb
3. skye
2. dobie
1. audie

 

[hibiskuuss]

these are fun! based on my personal preference:

10. kyle
9. shep
8. sylvana
7. judy
6. raymond
5. marshal
4. sherb
3. skye
2. dobie
1. audie

Yeah I kind of figured Kyle and Shep would be placed lower for a lot of people, I love seeing everyone's opinions :"D

 

[Lovi]

10. Judy
9. Sylvanna
8. Skye
7. Marshal
6. Shep
5. Kyle
4. Audie
3. Raymond
2. Dobie
1. Sherb

I may be just a taaaad biased.

 

[BluebearL]

Another really hard one!
My ranking from 1 (favourite)- 10 (least favourite) is:

1.Judy
2.Sherb
3.Raymond
4. Shep
5.Dobie
6. Kyle
7.Sylvana
8.Marshal
9. Skye
10.Audie

I really love every single one of them so if I could they would all be on one. This ranking would probably change if you asked me on a different dayThat being said there aren't many villagers I don't like so that doesn't help me

 

[magicaldonkey2]

my thoughts:

10. judy
9. skye
8. audie
7. dobie
6. shep
5. sylvanna
4. marshal
3. sherb
2. raymond
1. kyle (favourite heh)

 

[wolfie1]

10. Dobie
9. Judy
8. Shep
7. Skye
6. Sherb
5. Raymond
4. Kyle
3. Marshal
2. Audie
1. Sylvana

Numbers 7 to 1 were super difficult to rank lol. I really like these 7, but my girl Sylvana had to be number 1, of course. I don't like numbers 10 to 8, so it was easy to rank them.

 

[hibiskuuss]

my thoughts:

10. judy
9. skye
8. audie
7. dobie
6. shep
5. sylvanna
4. marshal
3. sherb
2. raymond
1. kyle (favourite heh)

Kyle is my favorite too, he's such a bean baby.

Post automatically merged: May 2, 2020

10. Dobie
9. Judy
8. Shep
7. Skye
6. Sherb
5. Raymond
4. Kyle
3. Marshal
2. Audie
1. Sylvana

Numbers 7 to 1 were super difficult to rank lol. I really like these 7, but my girl Sylvana had to be number 1, of course. I don't like numbers 10 to 8, so it was easy to rank them.

I never saw Sylvana until this game since I didn't play NL when they re-released her and I fell in love with her so understandable :'D

 

[Rosewater]

10. Raymond
9. Judy
8. Kyle
7. Shep
6. Skye
5. Sherb
4. Dobie
3. Sylvana
2. Marshal
1. Audie

 

[Alyx]

Alright first of all I love how you have so many of the new villagers. Here's my ranking, on a scale of 1-10, 1 being the cutest, 10 being the most "meh" in my opinion.

1) Raymond (he's my sweet business cat that has a cute catchphrase lol - I have him too!)
2) Audie (she's named after a grandma that plays ACNL - she's so cute and reminds me of Leni Loud from The Loud House)
3) Skye (she's a pretty blue color and is so cute!)
4) Sherb (I have Sherb too, he's really cute and I think the lazy personality fits him perfectly)
5) Marshal (I had Marshal in my ACNL town Eureka, and he's really adorable, but not my favorite Smug)
6) Judy (gosh those sparkly eyes!)
7) Dobie (wise old grandpa wolf)
8) Sylvana (this is the first time I've heard of Sylvana, she's kinda cute I suppose)
9) Shep (Shep was one of my first villagers in my first ACNL town, he's kinda cute and I like his shaggy look)
10) Kyle (I'm not really a fan of Kyle's color scheme)

 

[Shinjukuwu]

10. Marshal
9. Raymond
8. Shep
7. Sherb
6. Dobie
5. Kyle
4. Sylvana
3. Judy
2. Audie
1. Skye

 

[jokk]

1. marshal
2. dobie
3. sherb
4. sylvana
5. audie
6. skye
7. kyle
8. shep
9. raymond
10. judy

 

[LunarMako]

1. Judy
2. Raymond
3. Sherb
4. Marshall
5. Audie
6. Skye
7. Sylvana
8. Dobie
9. Shep
10. Kyle

 

[hibiskuuss]

10. Raymond
9. Judy
8. Kyle
7. Shep
6. Skye
5. Sherb
4. Dobie
3. Sylvana
2. Marshal
1. Audie

Oh wow I would have never guessed someone putting Raymond in 10the place haha xD

Post automatically merged: May 2, 2020

Alright first of all I love how you have so many of the new villagers. Here's my ranking, on a scale of 1-10, 1 being the cutest, 10 being the most "meh" in my opinion.

1) Raymond (he's my sweet business cat that has a cute catchphrase lol - I have him too!)
2) Audie (she's named after a grandma that plays ACNL - she's so cute and reminds me of Leni Loud from The Loud House)
3) Skye (she's a pretty blue color and is so cute!)
4) Sherb (I have Sherb too, he's really cute and I think the lazy personality fits him perfectly)
5) Marshal (I had Marshal in my ACNL town Eureka, and he's really adorable, but not my favorite Smug)
6) Judy (gosh those sparkly eyes!)
7) Dobie (wise old grandpa wolf)
8) Sylvana (this is the first time I've heard of Sylvana, she's kinda cute I suppose)
9) Shep (Shep was one of my first villagers in my first ACNL town, he's kinda cute and I like his shaggy look)
10) Kyle (I'm not really a fan of Kyle's color scheme)

I gotta say, I love my grandpa wolf, the wisest in the island :')

Post automatically merged: May 2, 2020

10. Marshal
9. Raymond
8. Shep
7. Sherb
6. Dobie
5. Kyle
4. Sylvana
3. Judy
2. Audie
1. Skye

I like that someone agrees with me that Marshal isn't all that xD

Post automatically merged: May 2, 2020

1. Judy
2. Raymond
3. Sherb
4. Marshall
5. Audie
6. Skye
7. Sylvana
8. Dobie
9. Shep
10. Kyle

Poor Kyle xD

 

[LunarMako]

I like that someone agrees with me that Marshal isn't all that xD

Post automatically merged: May 2, 2020

Poor Kyle xD

Hahaha. I just think he is least cute of all. But I have never had most of these villagers. If I knew them all, my list might change. But I am purely going on looks. Kyle may be hella cool though. I thought my villager Clyde was one of the ugliest I see at first, but I actually like him and having a hard time letting him go. Haha. Not sure if he is a dreamier. But I really like him. 10 villagers are not enough. HAHA.

 

[hibiskuuss]

Hahaha. I just think he is least cute of all. But I have never had most of these villagers. If I knew them all, my list might change. But I am purely going on looks. Kyle may be hella cool though. I thought my villager Clyde was one of the ugliest I see at first, but I actually like him and having a hard time letting him go. Haha. Not sure if he is a dreamier. But I really like him. 10 villagers are not enough. HAHA.

I totally agree there can never be enough. Ive loved Kyle since I saw him in my campsite for the first time in NL and I was obsessed. He's been in every restart of of my 1,000 towns in NL and I love how he's a smug. Can't get enough of this guy ❤❤