I'm quite sure I got Marina as a first villaged once but I really can't confirm this. She probably moved in soon after I made the town. And yes, I had Yuka as one of my first villagers like twice. I don't remember who my first villagers were this time.
My original five in my main town where, Tutu, Bertha, Olivia, Gruff, and Mac. They're all gone now. The original five in my second town where Margie, Boone, Papi, Gloria, and Penelope. I wanted to keep Margie and Papi but they moved without telling me.
First town: Nana, Coach, Annalise, Barold, Camofrog (Nana stayed the longest, all of them were gone by the time I reset)
Main town: Poppy, Flora, Biff, Broccolo, Chow (Poppy is the only one who's still here)
I forgot for the rest of my towns whoops
First town (Westerly): Bertha, Bree, Coach, Elvis, Flora
Second town (Granada): Anchovy, Becky, Boone, Cookie, Sydney
Third town (New York): Beau, Butch, Caroline, Diana, Peck
Fourth town (London): Becky, Lobo, Margie, Sly, Twiggy