pirate theme or mermaid theme?

I like both themes, honestly. I'm planning to decorate some parts of my beach with both pirate and mermaid furniture. But if I had to choose only one I would...pick mermaid, I guess?? Mostly because I didn't get any pirate furniture from Gullivarr's first visit :C
 
Pirate.

I was hoping the mermaid set was customizable. If I could get deep purples, like an Ursala aesthetic. That would be great.

Ohhh a deep purple would have been so neat. That would go really well with the purple version of the shell furniture.

The mermaid isn't really my style but I love it because it's a classic. I think pirate as an island theme is super cool so I'm sad Gullivarrr doesn't give as many furniture pieces for it compared to the mermaid series.
 
I used to not like pirate themed anything since back in high school all that pirate of the caribbean hype drove me crazy. But, two years or so ago, I got into One Piece and now I have to say I’d go with a pirate theme :P. I love that series so much and I really like the new furniture.

I’m also not a fan of furniture/clothes with a lot of pink; there are some exceptions though. so no mermaid theme for me.
 
I really love both! I'm using the pirate furniture on my hidden beach to create a "smuggler's cove," and some of the more subtle mermaid furniture in my bathroom (like the rug, table, etc.) I would never use the full set though, and it gets too same-y and too cutesy. I prefer using the mermaid furniture as supplements/accent pieces.

I don't know if I could choose just one... I guess if I *had* to pick, I would pick the pirate set, but both of them are among my favorites in the game.

I don't like the clothing for either set, though, TBH.
 
Both are good, but I prefer the Pirate items. I especially like the Pirate clothing, particularly the Boots, Dress, Treasure Crown and Treasure Robe.
 
omg both for sure. I'll probably put the pirate-themed items outside around my beaches and by the spot where Redd's Treasure Trawler shows up, and I'll do a mermaid-themed room inside my house.
 
Pirate theme, no contest. I cannot fit anything from the mermaid theme into any of my indoor/outdoor plans, whereas I need a few cannons from the pirate set (don’t ask why)
 
I love both, but since I used the mermaid theme a lot in new leaf, I'd go with the pirate theme now for something different! plus my island theme matches the pirate furniture better this time :)
 
If I had to choose one it would be the pirate theme! The pirate items seem more interesting and new compared to the mermaid series. I arrready have tons of pirate clothes and furniture to make a themed set. I'm hoping to get more than 1 pirate treasure chest so I hope Gullivarrr isn't a July-only special character
 
Back
Top