Peppy Villager Tier List

[patchworkbunny]

Bunnie for life!

 

[Duu]

wowee im such a contrarian

 

[Yujian]

 

[Serabee]

Here's mine! Though I don't tend to like themed villagers, I just have a soft spot for Tangy. She's SO weird and cute I can't not love her In general, I really like peppy cats...

...with the big exception of Tabby. Seriously... her face. It's just not right

 

[Halloqueen]

S Tier: Love all these wonderful ladies. The top three was a really difficult choice; I was really tempted to put Audie first, but ended up going with Flora because of her unique flamingo design and put Sprinkle in second because I really love penguins in real life and Sprinkle is precious. Then there's Bella my wonderful metal mouse and Ruby, whose albinism gives her a real distinct look and whose moon rabbit inspiration is really nice.

A Tier: All very solid.

B Tier: Basically a mix of villagers who I've had as residents before and enjoyed well enough (Peanut, Carmen, Bunnie, Cookie, Rosie, Anicotti, Pinky) and those whose designs I like fairly well, just not as much as A Tier.

C Tier: All right, I guess.

D Tier: Bottom of the barrel for me.

 

[basicbobagirl1130]

Here’s my tier list! Kinda sad that Epona wasn’t an option, I would’ve made a S+ tier list solely just for her! ^^

 

[Velvet_nosebleed]

Apple is best peppy and I have some personal beef with Twiggy

 

[Alienfish]

 

[SirOctopie]

 

[jyrilian]

tangy will never not be my #1 favorite

 

[nightglow]

I think

 

[Uffe]

This was more difficult than I expected it to be.

 

[Jassiii]

Audie n Cookie are on my island rn actually so <3 hearts to them

 

[cornimer]

Most of the peppies are just meh to me it turns out, but love my S and A girls

Peanut is a D solely because I'm allergic to peanuts FYI

 

[Your Local Wild Child]

There’s actually quite a few really good peppies out here! Too bad there aren’t any peppy deer, tho...

 

[mogyay]

bunnies and cats really saving the day for peppy!

 

[VexTheHex]

I don't have a solid Peppy pick for my island and still struggle with what I want to do cause I honestly have no solid S tier for these ladies. Most of them has some aspect about them that makes them miss the mark for me. Whether it's Flora's lackluster home, Bianca/Bangle's weird snout, Patty's name, or something along those lines.

Getting into D and F tier is some really ugly ladies. I don't think most need explaining besides that cat at the end. I didn't pay much attention to her till a friend made me look at her a bit more. I went from having no strong opinion on her to pretty much disliking her. She looks like a late middle aged woman trying to be 8 again and even comes with that tacky sweater that turned me off Marina. Then suddenly she hit it large in the Tier lists cause some Streamer used their followers to mass vote her, so now this cat's bad fringe face started popping up everywhere which didn't help me just forget about her again.

Also no nose bunnies and cats lose points.

Peppy kind of failed to impress me.

 

[TaylaJade]

Rosie is the best peppy. She’s a celebrity on my island

 

[Psicat]

 

[saucySheep]