• Guest, have you picked up a fortunate cookie from the shop? You must have the "Fortune Cookie (2026)" item in your inventory to receive a collectible from The Luck of the Dragon raffle. Time is running out and the raffle results will be randomized soon!

need help figuring out my villagers!!

FritzyFry

Carefree Flower
Joined
May 4, 2020
Posts
39
Bells
45
Lucky Coins
0
Gems
0
Switch
3030-7099-4047
Island
Leunus
Tasty Cake
im in a bit of a dilemma rn about which villagers i should try to get on my island, and just now i hit a complete stop and i pretty much have no idea what to decide on xnx
-my first plan was to have raymond, marshal, avery, genji, sherb, coco, marina, judy, muffy and peanut
-but then i decided i wanted to have all unique villager species and changed coco to annalisa and peanut to cookie
-then a day or two ago i found stitches on an island and after leaving him behind i started considering actually getting him, and as i hadnt had any luck finding judy i decided to replace sherb with him and judy with whitney
-then skip forward to right now and... i actually managed to find judy, and this is where im in a dilemma, both her and stitches would fit my island really well, but theres also the fact that i want all different species of villagers...
-so really i just... want to get some input on this, or heck if anyone wants to give me a completely different list of villagers they think would fit go ahead! im all ears!
-ill also leave a little description of my island plans to help you get an idea of what im looking for! and also forgot to mention i do want one villager of each personality type aa,,

-current dreamie islanders i have: genji, raymond, merengue (have considered her), whitney, judy, marshal, avery, marina
-general island theme: magic, night, stars, moon, mystery, blue, purple, pink, white, black, cool colors
-areas with villagers:
hills: home to the local observatory, library and museum, blue, white, 2 villagers, raymond and judy were planned
falls: a dreamy paradise filled with joy and dreams, has a diner, pink, white, pastel, childish, 3 villagers, marina, peanut/cookie and stitches/sherb were planned
forest: a forest with a more earthy and cottagecore vibe than the rest of the island, also where the campsite is located, orange, green, black, 2 villagers, marshal and genji were planned
witch's hut + graveyard: pretty self explanatory... purple, black, white, blue, 3 villagers, muffy, avery and annalisa/coco were planned

thank you for reading! hope its not too confusing quq
 
Last edited:
As someone who plans to have 6 villager slots taken up by only 2 species, I don't know if I'm the best to give advice, but if you like both Stitches and Judy there's nothing wrong with keeping them both even if you get an overlapped species.
 
As someone who plans to have 6 villager slots taken up by only 2 species, I don't know if I'm the best to give advice, but if you like both Stitches and Judy there's nothing wrong with keeping them both even if you get an overlapped species.

aa im thinking hard on this rn!! and i think i may be figuring something out but we'll have to see qwq
 
Back
Top