Most overrated/underrated villagers?

[Xara]

me seeing people mentioning raymond even though this is a new leaf thread: 👁👁

snxjsnzjms jokes aside, katt is so, so underrated and i know it’s because a lot of people find her ugly but i personally think she’s adorable and that she deserves way more love ;u;

 

[Koi Fishe]

I think Rosie and Roald are really overrated but I think Butch and Rod are super underrated. They're both in my NL town and I love them sm!

 

[acnl2605]

why is no one talking about my bby tammy? :< she's soo cute. willow and bree are so underrated too.

 

[fluttershy300]

Overrated: As much as I love him, Marshal is pretty overrated. But I feel he rightfully deserves to be popular. He’s a little bundle of joy despite him looking like he’s annoyed by your existence. Sweet guy. At least to me he is.

Underrated: I don’t have him but Joey is one of the cutest freaking thing I’ve ever seen in my life. He’s like a baby duckie in a diaper and not many talk about him which is cool. More Joey for me. I sometimes consider switching Bones out for Joey but I also really like Bones which whom is also underrated. lmao

Post automatically merged: Aug 19, 2020

Totally agree on Bill! He is one of my favorites, and makes the jock personality cute instead of annoying for me. I think as far as underrated goes for Kabuki the cat and Dizzy the elephant. Both are just so adorable I love them. I've seen a lot of people rave about Pietro, but I find him kind of creepy.

Kabuki is awesome. His design is well thought out. Dizzy is adorable, I love the elephant villagers. One of my fav species.

Post automatically merged: Aug 19, 2020

me seeing people mentioning raymond even though this is a new leaf thread: 👁👁

snxjsnzjms jokes aside, katt is so, so underrated and i know it’s because a lot of people find her ugly but i personally think she’s adorable and that she deserves way more love ;u;

Oop didn’t see it as a new leaf thread lmao

 

[WalceDony]

Carmen is underrated, the eyes and mouth on her are so cute but most people that I ask about her think they are derpy and horrible
I'm not sure about who is overrated; maybe Raymond? It feels like the only reason he gets so much love is because of the different coloured eyes but that kinda thing just really isn't for me...

 

[toxapex]

I think Rosie and Roald are really overrated but I think Butch and Rod are super underrated. They're both in my NL town and I love them sm!

Omg YES!!!! I had butch AND rod in my last New Leaf town as dreamies, I love them!

 

[hakutaku]

Deena is underrated! I have both her and Molly in my town and I prefer her over Molly tbh. I like Molly don't get me wrong, but Deena is really sweet and pretty cute in her own right.

 

[silk.feather]

Most overrated would be Marshal, but underrated would be Quillson and Derwin. They are both so cute and i can’t understand why people hate them so much. When you talk to them, they are so cute and they always give me gifts and they hardly ever be mean to me.

 

[Juliet7466]

I don't get the hype about marshal and fauna honestly. Wendy and willow are very underrated in my opinion, they're both adorable!

 

[AssassinVicz]

I’m a really big Nate supporter. He’s a big teddy bear with a green monobrow which could easily put people off but, for some reason it looks like a leaf crown? I love him sm.

Honestly I think Bob is highly over-rated, like I don’t see his appeal? Especially with other characters with more interesting designs. He’s kinda just.. a cat who’s purple?

Then again I never understood Merry’s hype either. I see a lot of people with her on their island but, she looks slightly creepy to me? Probably just how her face is placed.

 

[SirOctopie]

I'm going to get so much hate for this, but I do not understand the appeal of Raymond. Everyone wants him so bad, there was even a black market for him--I just do not understand. Sometimes when I see people posting photos/videos with him on places like reddit, I wonder if they're humble bragging because he's so sought after (they're probably not, but you can't help but wonder). To each their own I guess...

I think a few of the less popular eagle villagers are pretty cool. Pierce is definitely one of my favs, even though I dislike jock personalities. Hopper and Clay are awesome too.

 

[joey ^_^]

when "underrated" villagers are brought up i immediately think about my girl tabby. sure she's got a different face from the other peppy cats but she's just such a cute lil weird gal!! she's friends with kabuki in my town and i love hearing them talk about each other :>

aside from tabby, there's also bertha and gladys? i don't see a lot of people talking about them but they're so sweet! 11/10 and also i love their houses!! bertha's dentist theme? so unique!! you go girl!!

also,,,,,,,,,, not sure if she's overrated or if i'm just holding a grudge because she moved her house somewhere i didn't like but ,,, merengue............ but i do accept that her house is adorable and she's nice and gives gifts but.................. her house............. i want to move it.......................

 

[letisbloom]

Hampfrey, she is a kittle grumpy old guy, bit I love him so much