Most overrated/underrated villagers?

me seeing people mentioning raymond even though this is a new leaf thread: 👁👄👁

snxjsnzjms jokes aside, katt is so, so underrated and i know it’s because a lot of people find her ugly but i personally think she’s adorable and that she deserves way more love ;u;
 
I think Rosie and Roald are really overrated but I think Butch and Rod are super underrated. They're both in my NL town and I love them sm!
 
why is no one talking about my bby tammy? :< she's soo cute. willow and bree are so underrated too.
 
Overrated: As much as I love him, Marshal is pretty overrated. But I feel he rightfully deserves to be popular. He’s a little bundle of joy despite him looking like he’s annoyed by your existence. Sweet guy. At least to me he is.

Underrated: I don’t have him but Joey is one of the cutest freaking thing I’ve ever seen in my life. He’s like a baby duckie in a diaper and not many talk about him which is cool. More Joey for me. I sometimes consider switching Bones out for Joey but I also really like Bones which whom is also underrated. lmao
Post automatically merged:

Totally agree on Bill! He is one of my favorites, and makes the jock personality cute instead of annoying for me. I think as far as underrated goes for Kabuki the cat and Dizzy the elephant. Both are just so adorable I love them. I've seen a lot of people rave about Pietro, but I find him kind of creepy.
Kabuki is awesome. His design is well thought out. Dizzy is adorable, I love the elephant villagers. One of my fav species.
Post automatically merged:

me seeing people mentioning raymond even though this is a new leaf thread: 👁👄👁

snxjsnzjms jokes aside, katt is so, so underrated and i know it’s because a lot of people find her ugly but i personally think she’s adorable and that she deserves way more love ;u;
Oop didn’t see it as a new leaf thread lmao
 
Last edited:
Carmen is underrated, the eyes and mouth on her are so cute but most people that I ask about her think they are derpy and horrible :(
I'm not sure about who is overrated; maybe Raymond? It feels like the only reason he gets so much love is because of the different coloured eyes but that kinda thing just really isn't for me...
 
I think Rosie and Roald are really overrated but I think Butch and Rod are super underrated. They're both in my NL town and I love them sm!

Omg YES!!!! I had butch AND rod in my last New Leaf town as dreamies, I love them!
 
Deena is underrated! I have both her and Molly in my town and I prefer her over Molly tbh. I like Molly don't get me wrong, but Deena is really sweet and pretty cute in her own right.
 
Most overrated would be Marshal, but underrated would be Quillson and Derwin. They are both so cute and i can’t understand why people hate them so much. When you talk to them, they are so cute and they always give me gifts and they hardly ever be mean to me.
 
I don't get the hype about marshal and fauna honestly. Wendy and willow are very underrated in my opinion, they're both adorable!
 
I’m a really big Nate supporter. He’s a big teddy bear with a green monobrow which could easily put people off but, for some reason it looks like a leaf crown? I love him sm.

Honestly I think Bob is highly over-rated, like I don’t see his appeal? Especially with other characters with more interesting designs. He’s kinda just.. a cat who’s purple?

Then again I never understood Merry’s hype either. I see a lot of people with her on their island but, she looks slightly creepy to me? Probably just how her face is placed.
 
I'm going to get so much hate for this, but I do not understand the appeal of Raymond. Everyone wants him so bad, there was even a black market for him--I just do not understand. Sometimes when I see people posting photos/videos with him on places like reddit, I wonder if they're humble bragging because he's so sought after (they're probably not, but you can't help but wonder). To each their own I guess...

I think a few of the less popular eagle villagers are pretty cool. Pierce is definitely one of my favs, even though I dislike jock personalities. Hopper and Clay are awesome too. :)
 
when "underrated" villagers are brought up i immediately think about my girl tabby. sure she's got a different face from the other peppy cats but she's just such a cute lil weird gal!! she's friends with kabuki in my town and i love hearing them talk about each other :>

aside from tabby, there's also bertha and gladys? i don't see a lot of people talking about them but they're so sweet! 11/10 and also i love their houses!! bertha's dentist theme? so unique!! you go girl!!

also,,,,,,,,,, not sure if she's overrated or if i'm just holding a grudge because she moved her house somewhere i didn't like but ,,, merengue............ but i do accept that her house is adorable and she's nice and gives gifts but.................. her house............. i want to move it.......................
 
Back
Top