I'm cheering so hard for Papi because he was the first lazy villager in my second New Leaf town (the one I had for longest, which I started around the time I joined this forum!)
That said, if Buck wins I will gladly vote him if he ends up going against Roscoe.
I'm curious how that vote would look anyhow, as Roscoe is clearly a VERY popular horse (looking at the Roscoe vs Ed poll), but there ARE a lot of Buck fans here