Lunar Legends: Roscoe vs. Ed (Round 2, Match 4)

[~Kilza~]

Welcome to Round 2, Match 4 of Lunar Legends, a showdown of the horses to see who will be named The Bell Tree's representative for the Year of the Horse and become our next character collectible!

In this poll, you will vote between Roscoe & Ed to see who will advance to the Semi-Finals! Roscoe cruised to victory against Clyde in the most lopsided result of round 1, while Ed is coming off a first round bye!

This poll closes at Monday, February 23, 2026 at 7 PM EST. May the best horse win!

 

[-Apples-]

Looks like Roscoe is going to crush another competition like what he did to Clyde.

 

[Dunquixote]

Easy vote for me: Roscoe! Ed has grown on me a little though since I’ve used him for a few harv’s studio’s designs and designed a house for him in HHP . I’m bias towards Roscoe since I’ve had him in New Leaf and in NH and am really fond of him (just not his singing lol).

 

[toxapex]

Hit the button to vote for Ed and I feel like I got hit by a train. That difference is Crazy LOL

 

[Airysuit]

Roscoe is too cool

 

[Giddy]

Not my poor Ed DX

 

[lasagne_of_death]

Hit the button to vote for Ed and I feel like I got hit by a train. That difference is Crazy LOL

True, I voted for Ed too, but I kind of expected it to be honest. People like Roscoe A Lot, and after the soul shattering loss of Clyde I prepared myself for another sad outcome

 

[Snek]

I voted for Roscoe. The Dark Horse. He's the only one that stands a chance against Buck if I'm honest

 

[corlee1289]

Oh wow, the difference is quite stark!

 

[DaCoSim]

Roscoe’s my boy. I’ll put in my vote tomorrow.

 

[-Blue-]

I expected it to be way off, but I voted for Ed. He did grow on me over time and was once one of my NL villagers.

 

[Dim]

Such a tough one since Ed was literally one of my very first villagers all the way back in my gamecube town and Roscoe just has that awesome modern aesthetic. Think I'll choose Ed.

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

Ed seems suspicious. Like it's just Julian in a wig and he's opening his eyes (and somehow took his horn off)

 

[toxapex]

Ed seems suspicious. Like it's just Julian in a wig and he's opening his eyes (and somehow took his horn off)

Lol, when New Leaf first came out I always got Ed, Colton and Julian confused w/ each other

 

[-Blue-]

Lol, when New Leaf first came out I always got Ed, Colton and Julian confused w/ each other

lol! Same! I still sometimes mix up the three! Them all being smug doesn't help the matters

 

[themysterybidder]

Poor Ed.

 

[lasagne_of_death]

You know what, at least Ed's doing marginally better than Clyde, with eleven votes instead of seven orz

 

[-Mars-]

I do like Ed he's a nice villager but I seriously think we need much more black collectables. We have numerous blue collectables and not too many black ones, sorry.

 

[Dim]

Ed seems suspicious. Like it's just Julian in a wig and he's opening his eyes (and somehow took his horn off)

Ed was around way before Julian so maybe Julian is the one who is actually Ed with a wig and horn glued to him.

 

[Randy Jade]

That was an easy win for my boy Roscoe!