Lily or Goldie?

[cheezu]

I happen to have amiibo cards for both (recently got Lily in a pack that I managed to find for a really good price) and I'll be soon replacing Norma with either one.
I think both of them are super adorable to be honest, but I already have two crankies (Wolfgang and Boyd) and two permanent lazies (Zucker and Sherb). I could potentially see myself getting rid of one of my crankies down the line but I don't think I'm ready yet.

Lily: She's a frog and I love frogs irl. I recently lost two of my pet frogs (male and female) due to an illness so I invited Henry who was my NL bud. I have always wanted Lily but never actually got her in NL so thought it would be cool to have two froggy villagers and I couldn't believe my luck when I got her in a pack of amiibo cards I opened yesterday.

Goldie: I initially wanted to go for a dog-species Normal but I also see so many people that have her on their Island. I do think she's adorable though and definitely a classic.

Who would you go for?

 

[jokk]

i vote lily!

 

[Jared:3]

Lily she's a cutie, I miss her but I liked Lolly better

 

[Dewy]

You sound more attached to Lily, so I vote Lily

 

[absol]

I think you'd love Lily.

 

[SCORPA15]

Goldie, throw a dog a bone.

 

[Shinjukuwu]

Lily!

 

[raqball]

Lily.. I have her and she is such a little sweetheart...

 

[Aliya]

Lily for sure!

 

[Briar]

Lily! She's one of my favorite villagers~

 

[Sander]

Lily. I think she's one of the best frog villagers. Had her in NL, she's so cute.
I don't like dogs in both AC & real life, so consider me biased.

 

[wearebap]

LILY!
shes a total favorite!

 

[thegunpowderincident]

Lily! I had her in NL and she's so cute!

 

[Loriii]

Lily. Obvious answer haha but I like Goldie as well! Lily's interior is better though. Also, you love frogs in real life (I honestly don't, but she's literally cute) so there's that.

 

[Arithmophobia17]

my personal preference says goldie, but based on the story you mentioned, i think you'd like lily more in this case. i hope you enjoy whichever one you do end up choosing!

 

[kojuuro]

Lily!! She's so cute and her house is gorgeous!

 

[Zane]

In terms of design it’s no contest for me, Lily is super adorable. Definitely my favorite frog and I just love blue villagers in general.

 

[wolfie1]

Lily is such a cutie but I'm definitely biased towards Goldie. She was my first villager back in Wild World, so of course I'll always vote for her before anyone else lol.