Kitty Problems

[LoonieToonies]

Moe asked to move, and I told him to go. He's scheduled to leave the day after tomorrow, and I've got him in the 'should I stay or should I go?' conversation. All of a sudden, I've grown rather fond of him, but I was thinking about getting punchy instead and now I don't know what to do... Gah! Any thoughts, suggestions or times you could relate?

 

[snapdragon]

I had this issue early on in my town with Peewee...but then after I told him to stay, I could not get him to move for another month! If you want Punchy, I'd say let Moe move now

 

[LoonieToonies]

I had this issue early on in my town with Peewee...but then after I told him to stay, I could not get him to move for another month! If you want Punchy, I'd say let Moe move now

Problem is I THOUGHT I wanted punchy, but now I'm having second thoughts... But part of me still wants punchy yet I can't let moe go and I can't have them both either or I'll be overrun with lazies.

 

[snapdragon]

Problem is I THOUGHT I wanted punchy, but now I'm having second thoughts... But part of me still wants punchy yet I can't let moe go and I can't have them both either or I'll be overrun with lazies.

Ah, I see...well if you keep Moe you will have an old friend but Punchy can be a new friend!

 

[LoonieToonies]

Ah, I see...well if you keep Moe you will have an old friend but Punchy can be a new friend!

So true. I think I may keep Moe for a little longer... In some ways I think he's a little cuter than punchy and is a tier 5 in need of love!

 

[roseflower]

Moe asked to move, and I told him to go. He's scheduled to leave the day after tomorrow, and I've got him in the 'should I stay or should I go?' conversation. All of a sudden, I've grown rather fond of him, but I was thinking about getting punchy instead and now I don't know what to do... Gah! Any thoughts, suggestions or times you could relate?

I have the same problem, it?s so hard to let the villagers go once you like them, I still have a few starter animals in my town because of that. My solution is to have a second town for more villagers but this will be time consuming, so I put it on hold.

 

[turtlewigs]

The.Same.Thing.Happened.To.Me.

I was all set in the head to let Fang go to take in Chief but as soon as that wolf had that stay/go convo i suddenly felt really guilty and attached. I mean, Fang has been there since the very beginning. He was my starting villager! I ended up letting him go though, and took chief in which I am happy about. He did give me his pic, thats now in my house, but I dont necessarily miss him as much as I thought i would, he was a tad boring in design so Im glad with my decision in the end! But if I where you imo, id keep moe. Idk i just like Moe better than punchy

 

[LoonieToonies]

The.Same.Thing.Happened.To.Me.

I was all set in the head to let Fang go to take in Chief but as soon as that wolf had that stay/go convo i suddenly felt really guilty and attached. I mean, Fang has been there since the very beginning. He was my starting villager! I ended up letting him go though, and took chief in which I am happy about. He did give me his pic, thats now in my house, but I dont necessarily miss him as much as I thought i would, he was a tad boring in design so Im glad with my decision in the end! But if I where you imo, id keep moe. Idk i just like Moe better than punchy

I agree about fang, I had him in my town a while back and he's not the most interesting. I guess minimalist villagers are trending though. And I like moe too... Punchy is cool, but moe has a lovable face XD

 

[littlebabymonster]

I had that happen with Kyle. I debated letting him move for a long time to make room for another villager. It hurt, especially what he said when he was in boxes, but I did let him go. If we were just allowed more villagers, I would've kept him even though I have two other smugs.

If you're really attached, it'll still sting a little bit when you think about him. That doesn't mean you won't get even more attached to Punchy, though. You just have to think about it carefully.

 

[candiedapples]

I wanted Fuchsia to leave so that I could get a cranky like Static or Kabuki. However, the last two times she has pinged me to move, I made her stay. I've decided that she will be a permanent resident here now.

 

[spelling88]

i think I'm a little biased because Punchy is my dreamy, but if you really don't want him to leave, then tell him to stay! and if you ever change your mind he will eventually ask to move again

 

[ellabella12345]

Go for punchy! If you really loved moe you wouldn't of considered punchy! C:

 

[LoonieToonies]

Go for punchy! If you really loved moe you wouldn't of considered punchy! C:

Lol this is like some epic love triangle XD I thought I liked punchy because he looks like my IRL kitty Lenny, but I see Lenny in moe too because he's so goofy and chill. Idk, I think I like moe more now, he was an original villager and I can't let him go yet!

 

[jobby47]

That hasn't happened to me but just pick whichever one you like more.