If the game was forcing you to choose 5 villagers of each personality...

[Bugs]

Normal:

• Coco
• Ellie
• Tia
• Poppy
• Sylvana

Snooty:

• Amelia
• Ankha
• Julia
• Maelle
• Robin

Uchi:

• Agnes
• Flo
• Katt
• Phoebe
• Plucky

Peppy:

• Anabelle
• Flora
• Ruby
• Sprinkle
• Winnie

Cranky:

• Boris
• Dobie
• Knox
• Spike
• Vic

Smug:

• Hans
• Julian
• Keaton
• Klaus
• Shep

Lazy:

• Boomer
• Cube
• Drago
• Tucker
• Wade

Jock:

• Dom
• Mott
• Ribbot
• Sparro
• Sterling

Alligators: 1
Dogs: 1
Lions: 1
Frogs: 1
Bears: 1
Wolves: 1
Bulls: 1
Gorillas: 1
Rhinos: 1
Sheep: 1
Anteaters: 1
Ducks: 1
Bunnies: 2
Cats: 2
Pigs: 2
Horses: 2
Chickens: 2
Squirrels: 2
Birds: 2
Elephants: 3
Eagles: 3
Ostriches: 3
Penguins: 5

 

[Meowria]

Sisterly:
Cherry | Agnes | Muffy | Frita | Pashmina

Snooty:
Blaire | Freya | Mint | Pecan | Whitney

Smug:
Curlos | Julian | Kyle | Marshal | Raymond

Cranky:
Chief | Fang | Dobie | Lobo | Wolfgang

Peppy:
Audie | Apple | Cookie | Peanut | Sprinkle

Normal:
Maple | June | Merengue | Pekoe | Skye

Jock:
Sly | Dom | Genji | Pierce | Sterling

Lazy:
Sherb | Beau | Drago | Lucky | Bones

this was a lot harder than the I thought. Normal, peppy, and cranky all have really good villagers

 

[Rosch]

CRANKY
Rolf / Curt / Elvis / Lobo / Apollo

JOCK
Sterling / Rod / Rudy / Pierce / Tybalt

LAZY
Punchy / Bob / Zucker / Biskit / Hornsby

SMUG
Ken / Jacques / Tex / Zell / Curlos

PEPPY
Dotty / Bianca / Agent S / Rosie / Flora

SWEET/NORMAL
Lily / Mitzi / Olive / Skye / Goldie

SNOOTY
Ankha / Whitney / Blanche / Olivia / Yuka

BIG SISTER/UCHI
Tammy / Frita / Rocket / Phoebe / Charlise

I'm a huge fan of Cranky and Jock so it's a quite hard to pick. On the other hand, Snooty is also hard because the only one I really like is Ankha.

 

[Daisies]

Peppy
Puddles, Pinky, Peanut, Ketchup, Bunnie

Lazy
Bones, Bob, Filbert, Lucky, Sherb

Normal
Kiki, Melba, Flurry, Lily, Maple

Jock
Teddy, Bill, Goose, Hamlet, Roald,

Cranky
Kabuki, Elvis, Fang, Groucho, Static

Snooty
Ankha, Pecan, Opal, Whitney, Portia

Smug
Chadder, Zell, Henry, Lopez, Marshal

Sisterly
Agnes, Flo, Deirdre, Fuchsia, Shari

 

[Pearls]

sisterly
muffy, reneigh, agnes, cherry, phoebe

jock
bam, genji, dom, antonio, kid cat

lazy
punchy, lucky, drago, zucker, sherb

peppy
bluebear, bunnie, ruby, carmen, chrissy

normal
goldie, kiki, coco, poppy, flurry

smug
marshal, zell, shep, kyle, julian

cranky
fang, chief, lobo, static, dobie

snooty
francine, whitney, blaire, purrl, ankha

 

[skylucario]

uchi
agnes, cherry, mira, phoebe, fuchsia

cranky
butch, static, bruce, walt, roscoe

jock
antonio, sheldon, kid cat, bam, teddy

peppy
dotty, ruby, agent s, gabi, chai

lazy
punchy, bob, stitches, bones, papi

normal (this was the HARDEST...i am so sorry kiki)
daisy, molly, sylvana, midge, norma

smug
marshal, ed, eugene, henry, phil

snooty
baabara, amelia, diana, purrl, tipper

 

[Hanif1807]

Gotta bring my best army

Cranky: Tom, Vic, Butch, Apollo, Walt

Jock: Rowan, Lyman, Dom, Kid Cat, Goose

Lazy: Cole, Punchy, Stitches, Rex, Erik

Normal: Chevre, Maple, Lolly, Poppy, Marina

Peppy: Rosie, Bunnie, Chrissy, Dotty, Merry

Smug: Tex, Shep, Klaus, Marshal, Raymond

Snooty: Pecan, Francine, Olivia, Blaire, Opal

Uchi: Mira, Fuchsia, Tammy, Hazel, Paula

 

[Heartcore]

uchi:
1. Deirdre
2. Muffy
3. Fuchsia
4. Pashmina
5. Cherry
peppy:
1. Audie
2. Rosie
3. Cookie
4. Ketchup
5. Bunnie
snooty:
1. Diana
2. Whitney
3. Judy
4. Portia
5. Freya
normal:
1. Goldie
2. Fauna
3. Maple
4. Skye
5. Lolly
jock:
1. Genji
2. Rudy
3. Bam
4. Bill
5. Tybalt
cranky:
1. Lobo
2. Chief
3. Roscoe
4. Dobie
5. Butch
smug:
1. Raymond
2. Julian
3. Colton
4. Marshal
5. Kidd
lazy:
1. Sherb
2. Beau
3. Erik
4. Stitches
5. Walker

 

[Mayor Miraland]

uchi:
1. Muffy
2. Renée
3. Fuchsia
4. Agnes
5. Pashmina

normal:
1. Lolly
2. Tia
3. Marina
4. Molly
5. June

peppy:
1. Merry
2. Felicity
3. Piper
4. Bella
5. Rosie

snooty:
1. Monique <3
2. Olivia
3. Tiffany
4. Annalise
5. Gigi

smug:
1. Colton
2. Olaf
3. Chops
4. Lionel
5. Marshal

lazy:
1. Jeremiah (best friends with him in WW)
2. Rodeo
3. Wade
4. Barold
5. Bob

cranky:
1. Roscoe
2. Dobie
3. Gaston (we were mortal enemies back in WW but I secretly think he's pretty great)
4. Boris
5. Avery

jock:
1. Bud
2. Sterling
3. Kid Cat
4. Ribbot
5. Cousteau

This was fun

 

[Natsumi99]

Cranky: Wolfgang, Chief, Fang, Static, Apollo

Jock: Leonardo, Genji, Bill, Kid Cat, Hamlet (but tbh i dont want no jock on my island ever again D: )

Lazy: Sherb, Punchy, Drago, Bob, Beau

Normal: Pekoe, Maple, Goldie, Fauna, Marina

Peppy: Rosie, Audie, Bianca, Dotty, Merry

Smug: Julian, Colton, Kyle, Marshal, Raymond

Snooty: Whitney, Tasha, Olivia, Blaire, Vivian

Uchi: Pashmina, Fuchsia, Reneigh, Phoebe, Cherry

 

[swifterly]

In no particular order...

Uchi
- Hazel
- Plucky
- Cherry
- Agnes
- Katt

Jock
- Kid Cat
- Ribbot
- Snake
- Sterling
- Scoot

Lazy
- Stitches
- Zucker
- Cube
- Papi
- Lucky

Peppy
- Audie
- Tangy
- Bangle
- Sprinkle
- Twiggy

Normal
- Savannah
- Coco
- Celia
- Lolly
- Tia

Smug
- Marshal
- Raymond
- Kidd
- Julian
- Ken

Cranky
- Fang
- Walt
- Butch
- Roscoe
- Static

Snooty
- Velma
- Diana
- Mathilda
- Julia
- Vivian

This was a fun way to procrastinate, lol

 

[Hikari]

Lazy: Beau, Biskit, Stitches, Zucker, Erik
Jock: Poncho, Boots, Teddy, Rod, Bill
Cranky: Walt, Apollo, Bruce, Roscoe, Dobie
Smug: Eugene, Ken, Olaf, Shep, Pietro

Normal: Maple, Marina, Merengue, Molly, Poppy
Peppy: Maddie, Ketchup, Flora, Rosie, Tangy
Snooty: Diana, Judy, Gloria, Tasha, Blanche
Uchi: Plucky, Muffy, Reneigh, Tammy, Cherry

 

[aericell]

Sisterly

1. Hazel
2. Mira
3. Frita
4. Shari
5. Tammy

Jock

1. Hamlet
2. Scoot
3. Bill
4. Axel
5. Rudy

Lazy

1. Filbert
2. Sherb
3. Joey
4. Broccolo
5. Stitches

Peppy

1. Bluebear
2. Merry
3. Ketchup
4. Chrissy
5. Audie

Normal

1. Bettina
2. Poppy
3. Molly
4. Pekoe
5. Fauna

Smug

1. Shep
2. Marshal
3. Raymond
4. Zell
5. Julian

Cranky

1. Bruce
2. Dobie
3. Fang
4. Apollo
5. Wart Jr.

Snooty

1. Blaire
2. Judy
3. Blanche
4. Diana
5. Whitney

 

[Jared:3]

No order at all
Sisterly:

1. Mira
2. Cherry
3. Muffy
4. Fuchsia
5. Deirdre

Jock:

1. Kid Cat
2. Bam
3. Dom
4. Genji
5. Ribbot

Lazy:

1. Stitches
2. Beau
3. Zucker
4. Erik
5. Filbert

Peppy:

1. Flora
2. Sprinkle
3. Tangy
4. Audie
5. Rosie

Normal:

1. Merengue
2. Lolly
3. Lily
4. Tia
5. Coco

Smug:

1. Marshal
2. Julian
3. Zell
4. Raymond
5. Pietro

Cranky:

1. Fang
2. Wolfgang
3. Static
4. Apollo
5. Chief

Snooty:

1. Diana
2. Ankha
3. Whitney
4. Mathilda
5. Freya

 

[tybalt_cake]

Sisterly
1. Cherry
2. Muffy
3. Fuchsia
4. Charlise
5. Ursala

Jock
1. Tybalt
2. Genji
3. Rowan
4. Snake
5. Bam

Lazy
1. Zucker
2. Beau
3. Punchy
4. Lucky
5. Bob

Peppy
1. Audie
2. Rosie
3. Tangy
4. Margie
5. Chrissy

Normal
1. Daisy
2. Lily
3. Lolly
4. Goldie
5. Marina

Smug
1. Kyle
2. Lopez
3. Marshal
4. Zell
5. Keaton

Cranky
1. Rolf
2. Fang
3. Apollo
4. Curt
5. Chief

Snooty
1. Freya
2. Francine
3. Blaire
4. Diana
5. Ankha

 

[Paperboy012305]

Oh my sounds fun:

Lazy:
1. Raddle 2. Wade
3. Filbert 4. Zucker
5. Sherb

Jock:
1. Sprocket 2. Kid Cat
3. Cousteau 4. Genji
5. Hamlet

Cranky:
1. Boris. 2. Frank
3. Murphy 4. Rooney
5. Dobie

Smug:
1. Eugene 2. Raymond
3. Chadder 4. Jacques
5. Marshal

Normal:
1. Pekoe 2. Skye
3. June 4. Merengue
5. Celia

Peppy:
1. Chrissy 2. Ketchup
3. Sprinkle 4. Bonbon
5. Maddie

Snooty:
1. Diana 2. Cashmere
3. Ankha 4. Julia
5. Tasha

Sisterly:
1. Mira 2. Frita
3. Muffy 4. Hazel
5. Sylvia

Well, that was fun it was.

 

[Psicat]

Sisterly
- Fuchsia
- Phoebe
- Pashmina
- Muffy
- Reneigh

Jock
- Bam
- Ribbot
- Dom
- Sterling
- Bill

Lazy
- Stitches
- Beau
- Bob
- Papi
- Lucky

Peppy
- Audie
- Maddie
- Ruby
- Sprinkle
- Cheri

Normal
- Lolly
- Mitzi
- Goldie
- Lily
- Chevre

Smug
- Kidd
- Raymond
- Shep
- Kyle
- Pietro

Cranky
- Fang
- Roscoe
- Bruce
- Tom
- Rolf

Snooty
- Ankha
- Diana
- Olivia
- Whitney
- Annalise

 

[thundershot]

Sisterly

Phoebe
Deirdre
Pashmina
Renee
Frita


Jock

Rod
Jitters
Ribbot
Sprocket
WOOLIO (I don’t care that he’s not in this game I’m still choosing him)

Lazy

Tucker
Stitches
Sherb
Drago
Bob

Peppy

Anabelle
Flora
Pango
Piper
Audie

Normal

Savannah
Coco
Celia
Pekoe
Caroline

Smug

Hans
Julian
Jacques
Zell
Ken

Cranky

Camofrog
Rocco
Del
Kabuki
Rooney

edit: I’ll count them up tomorrow. This is too hard on my phone.

 

[spawnpoint]

Sisterly:
Fuschia
Cherry
Tammy
Katt
Pashmina

Smug:
O'Hare
Marshal
Raymond
Lopez
Toby (if he doesn't count, then Chadder)

Normal:
Kiki
Lolly
Maple
Mitzi
Melba

Lazy:
Beau
Bob
Sherb
Doc
Punchy

Peppy:
Rosie
Tangy
Chrissy
Carmen
Bunnie

Jock:
Genji
Snake
Kid Cat
Rod
Rudy

Snooty:
Ankha
Diana
Francine
Purrl
Whitney

Cranky:
Wolfgang
Tom
Kabuki
Static
Ricky/Vladimir (can't decide)

Cats: 15 (geez)
Deer: 4
Bear cubs: 2 or 3
Squirrels: 2 or 3
Wolves: 2
Bunnies: 9
Mice: 1
Goats: 2
Dogs: 1

 

[petaI]

sisterly; fuchsia, agnes, shari, phoebe, cherry

smug; marshal, henry, julian, raymond, o'hare

normal; marina, kiki, lily, melba, poppy

lazy; beau, bob, filbert, punchy, sherb

peppy; bianca, audie, bunnie, rosie, pompom

snooty; whitney, diana, francine, blanche, freya

jock; roald, genji, poncho, bill, flip

cranky; wolfgang, apollo, kabuki, rolf, fang

3 deer
1 pig
1 penguin
2 monkeys
1 dog
2 ostrich
3 squirrels
1 eagle
2 tigers
1 koala
6 cats
1 horse
2 frogs
1 goat
4 wolves
2 ducks
3 bunnies