If the game was forcing you to choose 5 villagers of each personality...

[Jas]

uchi:
- pashmina
- agnes
- hazel
- katt
- phoebe

jock:
- pierce
- bam
- boots
- rudy
- lyman

lazy:
- zucker
- beau
- stitches
- drago
- erik

peppy:
- audie
- ruby
- tutu
- bluebear
- flora

normal:
- marina
- maple
- poppy
- fauna
- lily
(so so many cute ones !!)

smug:
- marshal
- olaf
- lionel
- lopez
- julian

cranky:
- dobie
- camofrog
- walt
- octavian
- hopper

snooty:
- blanche
- pecan
- friga
- tiffany
- baabara

 

[Loriii]

Oh awesome thread! Let's see if I could name 5 villagers of each personality that I like.

Sisterly
1. Reneigh
2. Fuchsia
3. Muffy
4. Pashmina
5. Phoebe

Jock
1. Dom
2. Bam
3. Genji
4. Roald
5. Poncho

Lazy
1. Sherb
2. Beau
3. Stitches
4. Erik
5. Zucker

Peppy
1. Audie
2. Cookie
3. Chrissy
4. Ketchup
5. Rosie

Normal
1. Merengue
2. Fauna
3. Marina
4. Lily
5. Molly/Poppy/Tia/Ellie/June/Skye (lol I could not choose)

Smug
1. Marshal
2. Raymond
3. Julian
4. Shep
5. Zell

Cranky
1. Apollo
2. Wolfgang
3. Fang
4. Chief
5. Bruce

Snooty
1. Whitney
2. Judy
3. Diana
4. Vivian
5. Francine

 

[ayeeprill]

A giant 40 villager town could be sort of fun lol

Sisterly:
Deirdre
Pashmina
Phoebe
Shari
Fuchsia
(honorable mentions to Agnes and Reneigh)

Snooty:
Diana
Blaire
Blanche
Julia
Mint
(honorable mentions to Annalise and Vivian)

Peppy:
Bianca
Cheri
Audie
Pippy
Flora
(Honorable mentions to Maddie, Ketchup, Felicity, and Cookie)

Normal:
Kiki
Goldie
Sylvana
June
Skye
(Honorable mentions to Merengue, Tia, Gala, Poppy, and Maggie)

Lazy:
Stitches
Biskit
Erik
Cranston
Hugh
(Honorable mentions to Bob, Big Top, Tucker, Bones, and Filbert)

Jock:
Ribbot
Sprocket
Bill
Frobert
either Roald or Boots depending on my mood - I'm not a huge fan of the jocks
(Honorable mention to whichever of the two I didn't pick)

Cranky:
Octavian
Bruce
Apollo
Dobie
Murphy
(Honorable mentions to Butch and Buzz)

Smug:
Kyle
Julian
Zell
O'Hare
Shep
(Honorable mentions to Kidd and Lopez)

 

[MyVisionIsDying]

Uchi:
Reneigh
Charlise
Cherry
Renée
Muffy

Jock:
Bill
Antonio
Genji
Jay
Frobert

Lazy:
Filbert
Lucky
Zucker
Egbert
Drake

Peppy:
Bunnie
Pompom
Bluebear
Audie
Pippy

Normal:
Kiki
Vesta
Marina
Lolly
Melba

Smug:
Pietro
Raymond
Rodney
O'Hare
Marshal

Cranky:
Chow
Static
Octavian
Groucho
Del

Snooty:
Purrl
Robin
Amelia
Yuka
Pecan

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

Uchi:
Urlsala
Agnes
Phoebe
Reneigh
Shari

Snooty:
Purrl
Ankha
Pecan
Portia
Judy

Peppy:
Bunnie
Rosie
Cheri
Dotty
Winnie

Normal:
Savannah
Lolly
Merengue
Skye
Melba

Lazy:
Punchy
Sherb
Beau
Pudge
Rex

Jock:
Tybalt
Leonardo
Rowan
Genji
Tad

Cranky:
Dobie
Bruce
Croque
Ike
Kabuki

Smug:
Zell
Julian
Marshal
Lopez
Jacques

a lot of popular picks but oh well

 

[Lotusblossom]

I'm just wondering do we have to have all the different personalities??

 

[Blueskyy]

Sisterly
1. Shari
2. Cherry
3. Fuchsia
4. Pashmina
5. Reneigh

Jock
1. Ronald
2. Bill
3. Poncho
4. Dom
5. Rudy

Lazy
1. Sherb
2. Papi
3. Filbert
4. Beau
5. Wade

Peppy
1. Audie
2. Flora
3. Peanut
4. Cheri
5. Maddie

Normal
1. Aurora
2. Maple
3. Melba
4. Fauna
5. Skye

Smug
1. Jacques
2. Marshal
3. Raymond
4. Kyle
5. Colton

Cranky
1. Wolfgang
2. Apollo
3. Fang
4. Murphy
5. Static

Snooty
1. Blanche
2. Mallory
3. Kitty
4. Diana
5. Julia

 

[Minimasher]

My little brother wanted to do one so this is his:

Smug:
1. Marshall
2. Keaton
3. Eugene
4. Lucha
5. Raymond

Peppy:
1. Agent S
2. Bangle
3. Flora
4. Nibbles
5. Peanut

Jock:
1. Tybalt
2. Lyman
3. Genji
4. Jay
5. Stinky

Normal:
1. Carrie
2. Caroline
3. Gladys
4. Lolly
5. Poppy

Cranky:
1. Wolfgang
2. Chief
3. Buzz
4. Octavian
5. Walt

Snooty:
1. Astrid
2. Ankha
3. Freya
4. Mathilda
5. Tasha

Lazy:
1. Big Top
2. Filbert
3. Stitches
4. Wade
5. Claude

Uchi:
1. Phoebe
2. Sylvia
3. Reneigh
4. Mira
5. Rocket

 

[Airen]

Sisterly
1. Phoebe
2. Muffy
3. Hazel
4. Pashmina
5. Tammy

Jock
1. Genji
2. Bam
3. Rudy
4. Dom
5. Kody

Lazy
1. Beau
2. Zucker
3. Bob
4. Lucky
5. Stitches

Peppy
1. Audie
2. Rosie
3. Chrissy
4. Peanut
5. Flora

Normal
1. Skye
2. Goldie
3. Coco
4. Dora
5. June

Smug
1. Kyle
2. Raymond
3. Julian
4. Marshal
5. Shep

Cranky
1. Chief
2. Wolfgang
3. Lobo
4. Dobie
5. Fang
(lol)

Snooty
1. Freya
2. Vivian
3. Whitney
4. Diana
5. Judy

If I could have all of the wolves on my island, I definitely would.

 

[cainhurst]

Picking five from each personalty is definitely easier for me to do than pick my favorite one of each, haha.

NORMAL:
Caroline, Merengue, Pekoe, Sally, Sylvana (three squirrels! oof)

SMUG:
Marshal, Lopez, Kidd, Klaus, Raymond

JOCK:
Bam, Kevin, Kid Cat, Rudy, Teddy

CRANKY:
Bruce, Butch, Dobie, Murphy, Static

LAZY:
Beau, Bob, Cole, Filbert, Punchy

PEPPY:
Agent S, Bonbon, Carmen, Rosie, Ruby

UCHI:
Deirdre, Fuchsia, Hazel, Pashmina, Reneigh

SNOOTY:
Claudia, Diana, Miranda, Pecan, Soleil

 

[Edge]

Even though I got to pick 5 it was still hard to choose. There are so many wonderful villagers.
jock

• Genji
• Biff
• Rod
• Tybalt
• Sprocket

sisterly

• Deirdre
• Reneigh
• Katt
• Hazel
• Cherry

lazy

• Stitches
• Beau
• Punchy
• Erik
• Lucky

normal

• Fauna
• Marina
• Merengue
• Molly
• Lolly

peppy

• Bluebear
• Carmen
• Freckles
• Rosie
• Nibbles

smug

• Marshal
• Keaton
• Julian
• O’hare
• Ken

snooty

• Pecan
• Blanche
• Diana
• Tasha
• Whitney

cranky

• Fang
• Octavian
• Spike
• Roscoe
• Cud

 

[nerfeddude]

5 villagers of the same personality in a town of 40 folks would be extremely repetitive but if I had to choose...it's still hard to choose, I have too many villagers of each personality I actually like
Cranky:
1. Wolfgang
2. Apollo
3. Fang
4. Del
5. Kabuki

Jock:
1. Genji
2. Dom
3. Hamlet
4. Kid Cat
5. Roald

Lazy:
1. Sherb
2. Bob
3. Punchy
4. Beau
5. Cranston

Smug:
1. Julian
2. Eugene
3. Pietro
4. Lopez
5. O'Hare

Normal:
1. Goldie
2. Tia
3. Sylvana
4. Vesta
5. Lolly

Peppy:
1. Bunnie
2. Audie
3. Bluebear
4. Flora
5. Sprinkle

Snooty:
1. Purrl
2. Freya
3. Diana
4. Blanche
5. Tasha

Sisterly:
1. Deidre
2. Katt
3. Pheobe
4. Muffy
5. Reneigh

 

[usa-chan]

uchi:
muffy
phoebe
fushia

jock:
genji
roald
snake
bam
poncho

lazy:
stitches
beau
lucky
scoot
zucker

peppy:
audie
apple
bianca
felicity
merry

normal:
maple
molly
fauna
merengue
flurry

smug:
marshal
raymond
julian
kyle
zell

cranky:
fang
chief
rolf
apollo
kabuki

snooty:
whitney
ankha
diana
blanche

 

[biksoka]

hmm this was hard


Sisterly
1. Phoebe
2. Tammy
3. Mira
4. Cherry
5. Agnes

Jock
1. Kid Cat
2. Goose
3. Ribbot
4. Snake
5. Poncho

Lazy
1. Stitches
2. Clay
3. Hopkins
4. Cube
5. Lucky

Peppy
1. Bunnie
2. Dotty
3. Ruby
4. Merry
5. Tangy

Normal
1. Coco
2. Pekoe
3. Carolina
4. Olive
5. Merengue

Smug
1. Lopez
2. Kyle
3. Zell
4. Marshal
5. Raymond

Cranky
1. Wolfgang
2. Murphy
3. Kabuki
4. Croque
5. Bruce

Snooty
1. Judy
2. Tasha
3. Anhka
4. Amelia
5. Whitney

 

[suzume]

Sisterly:
Reneigh
Agnes
Muffy
Shari
Cherry

Jock:
Roald
Rudy
Dom
Champ
Peck

Lazy:
Beau
Punchy
Lucky
Stitches
Zucker

Peppy:
Flora
Sprinkle
Chrissy
Bunnie
Audie

Normal:
Poppy
Merengue
Fauna
Lily
Étoile

Smug:
Raymond
Julian
Marshal
Pietro
Eugene

Cranky:
Fang
Apollo
Wolfgang
Roscoe
Lobo

Snooty:
Judy
Diana
Whitney
Freya
Francine

 

[Jessi]

uchi(least fav):
- Cherry
- Mira
- Muffy
- Tammy
- Anges

jock:
- Snake
- Kid Kat
- Sheldon
- Genji
- Curly

lazy(fav):
- ZUCKER
- Lucky
- Sherb
- Tucker
- Cole

peppy:
- Tutu
- Rosie
- Flora
- Cheri
- Twiggy

normal:
- Goldie
- Maple
- Lolly
- Nan
- Coco


smug:
- Marshal
- Beardo
- Kidd
- Huck
- Eugene

cranky:
- Cyd
- Apollo
- Chief
- Murphy
- Static

snooty:
- MINT(my all time fave)
- Ankha
- Blaire
- Pecan
- Tipper

 

[Magus]

Thanks for all your participations ! It's cool to see the diversity of love for the villagers

So now to make the thread more interesting I propose you to count how many villagers you have by species, with this method you will kind of discover your actual species tier list that take variety of personalities in consideration too !

For me this is the result :

6 Cats
5 Deers
4 Rabbits
4 Wolves
3 Octopus
2 Elephants
2 Ostriches
2 Koalas
2 Ducks
2 Squirrels
2 Dogs
1 Sheep
1 Goat
1 Frog
1 Rhino
1 Bird
1 Mouse

I kind of thought Deers, Rabbits and Wolves would be higher than Cats so this is interesting...

 

[Thanedd]

A good question indeed

Lazy:

1.Drago
2.Punchy
3.Cranston
4.Cube
5.Beau
6.Sherb


Jock:

1.Ribbot
2.Kid Cat
3.Sprocket
4.Sly
5.Tybalt

Cranky:

1.Elvis
2.Apollo
3.Walt
4.Butch
5.Chief

Smug:

1.Julian
2.Lionel
3.Leopold
4.Phil
5.Kyle
6.Colton



Normal:

1.Coco
2.Tia
3.Jeanette
4.Gayle
5.Fauna
6.Celia

Peppy:

1.Twiggy
2.Audie
3.Tabby
4.Bangle
5.Sprinkle
6.Victoria

Snooty:

1.Whitney
2.Amelia
3.Monique
4.Ankha
5.Julia
6.Purrl

Sisterly:

1.Reneigh
2.Phoebe
3.Pashmina
4.Canberra
5.Flo
6.Fuchsia

 

[moon_child]

Normal
Maple
Pekoe
Molly
Marina
Aurora
Runners up : Lily, Lolly, Fauna, Skye ugh there’s so many cuties in this personality pool.

Lazy
Zucker
Stitches
Bob
Sherb
Filbert

Snooty
Diana
Whitney
Judy
Blair
Mint

Jock
Rudy
Dom
Kid Cat
Scoot
Cousteau

Uchi
Fuchsia
Mira
Pashmina
Shari
Reneigh

Peppy
Rosie
Merry
Tangy
Bluebear
Cheri

Cranky
Chief
Fang
Wolfgang
Apollo
Chief (sorry I really don’t like the others)

Smug
Marshal
Marshal
Marshal
Marshal
Marshal (okay, maybe Raymond but all the other smugs are just...yikes)

I didn’t count species wise but I admit to favoring cubs, squirrels, wolves and cats.

 

[epona]

OOOH I LOVE THIS


Sisterly
1. Deirdre
2. Agnes
3. Phoebe
4. Tammy
5. Flo

Jock
1. Roald
2. Poncho
3. Kody
4. Bill
5. Rudy

Lazy
1. Dizzy
2. Beau
3. Hornsby
4. Lucky
5. Ozzie

Peppy
1. Audie
2. Rosie
3. Cheri
4. Peanut
5. Merry

Normal
1. Maple
2. Lolly
3. Molly
4. Daisy
5. Pekoe

Smug
1. Henry
2. Shep
3. Kyle
4. Phil
5. Marshal

Cranky
1. Chief
2. Fang
3. Wolfgang
4. Dobie
5. Gonzo

Snooty
1. Whitney
2. Ankha
3. Vivian
4. Pecan
5. Freya


9 Wolves
6 Cubs
5 Cats
3 Squirrels
3 Dogs
2 Deer
2 Koalas
2 Ostriches
2 Penguins
2 Ducks
1 Elephant
1 Rhino
1 Pig
1 Frog

This was very revealing