If the game was forcing you to choose 5 villagers of each personality...

[Selky]

Lazy:
Zucker
Punchy
Moe
Alfonso
Erik

Cranky:
Octavian
Kabuki
Lobo
Apollo
Gonzo

Jock:
Genji
Bill
Buck
Boots
Rowan

Normal:
Stella
Coco
Skye
Marina
Molly

Peppy:
Tabby
Wendy
Carmen
Ruby
Ketchup

Snooty:
Ankha
Naomi
Blanche
Amelia
Purrl

Uchi:
Katt
Agnes
Plucky
Fuchsia
Dierdre

Smug:
Hans
Curlos
Zell
Tex
Kyle

 

[twisty]

Oh this is a tough one!!!! These are in no particular order:

Sisterly
1. Ursula
2. Hazel
3. Shari
4. Reneé
5. Pashmina

Jock
1. Iggly
2. Teddy
3. Sterling
4. Billy
5. Drift

Lazy
1. Zucker
2. Cole
3. Papi
4. Benjamin
5. Sherb

Peppy
1. Bianca
2. Victoria
3. Flora
4. Ruby
5. Pango

Normal
1. Nan
2. Kiki
3. Sylvana
4. Bea
5. Marina

Smug
1. Colton
2. Raymond
3. Marshal
4. Kyle
5. Lionel

Cranky
1. Grizzly
2. Kabuki
3. Chief
4. Lobo
5. Dobie

Snooty
1. Blaire
2. Monique
3. Whitney
4. Tipper
5. Ankha

 

[hikaricities]

interesting question!!!
normal:
molly / tia / sylvana / melba / pekoe

uchi:
frita / agnes / charlise / shari / hazel

peppy:
felicity / ketchup / pompom / wendy / peanut

jock:
flip / bill / bam / genji / teddy

lazy:
sherb / beau / clay / chester / hopkins

cranky:
apollo / rolf / fang / wolfgang / butch

smug:
klaus / marshal / julian / colton / kidd

snooty:
willow / pecan / gloria / miranda / vivian

made me realize that i like a lot of the villagers designs especially cranky, jock, and normal designs while I'm not the biggest fan of lazy!

 

[thisisausername]

this was so hardd lol it took awhile for me to think of 5 lazies, normals and peppies

uchi:
1. Shari
2. Frita
3. Reneigh
4. Pashmina
5. Cherry

normal:
1. Coco
2. Nana
3. Marina
4. Bea
5. Nan

lazy:
1. Cole
2. Egbert
3. Erik
4. Zucker
5. Tucker

cranky:
1. Chief
2. Apollo
3. Gonzo
4. Cyd
5. Butch

jock:
1. Teddy
2. Samson
3. Jay
4. Genji
5. Biff

smug:
1. Julian
2. Pietro
3. Raymond
4. Hans
5. Eugene

peppy:
1. Wendy
2. Cookie
3. Victoria
4. Audie
5. Winnie

snooty:
1. Portia
2. Naomi
3. Freya
4. Olivia
5. Ankha

 

[Piroshi]

Jock:
Bam
Rowan
Genji
Rod
Flip

Smug:
Colton
Julian
Pietro
Marshal
Raymond

Lazy:
Zucker
Beau
Puck
Cole
Big Top

Cranky:
Bruce
Del
Walt
Rooney
Rasher

Peppy:
Ruby
Bunnie
Freckles
Penelope
Sprinkle

Snooty:
Velma
Ankha
Bree
Diana
Tiffany

Normal:
Poppy
Fauna
Marina
Coco
Tia

Uchi:
Frita
Mira
Muffy
Agnes
Phoebe

 

[Crash]

-

 

[Aliya]

This was hard since I like a lot of villagers within some personality types and some personalities I can't stand a majority of them haha

Sisterly
1. Pashmina
2. Phoebe
3. Fuchsia
4. Cherry
5. Reneigh

Jock
1. Dom
2. Bam
3. Bill
4. Pierce
5. Roald

Lazy
1. Sherb
2. Beau
3. Stitches
4. Punchy
5. Erik

Peppy
1. Audie
2. Sprinkle
3. Ketchup
4. Dotty
5. Wendy

Normal
1. Chevre
2. Nan
3. Vesta
4. Molly
5. Marina

Smug
1. Raymond
2. Zell
3. Lopez
4. Kidd
5. Kyle

Cranky
1. Apollo
2. Avery
3. Chief
4. Fang
5. Hopper

Snooty
1. Vivian
2. Freya
3. Willow
4. Julia
5. Friga

 

[Junee]

Uchi
Frita
Muffy
Agnes
Deirdre
Katt

Jock
Antonio
Boone
Drift
Bam
Lyman

Lazy
Tucker
Drago
Zucker
Hugh
Erik

Peppy
Anabelle
Pango
Flora
Ketchup
Tammi

Normal
Annalisa
Kiki
Savannah
Tia
Coco

Smug
Hans
Olaf
Shep
Raymond
Julian

Cranky
Kabuki
Cyrano
Butch
Static
Del

Snooty
Snooty
Ankha
Mathilda
Julia
Yuka

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Sisterly: Phoebe, Fuchsia, Cherry, Reneigh, and Muffy

Normal: Fauna, June, Etoile, Chelsea, and Merengue

Peppy: Ketchup, Audie, Rosie, Sprinkle, and Chai

Snooty: Diana, Judy, Ankha, Whitney, and Francine

Jock: Kid Cat, Dom, Inkwell, Tad, and Roald

Cranky: Fang, Wolfgang, Lobo, Cyd, and Octavian

Smug: Marshal, Julian, Raymond, Toby, and W. Link

Lazy: Stitches, Sherb, Marty, Felyne, and Lucky

 

[Verecund]

This was really hard! I had so many that I wanted to include in here.

Peppy:
1. Gabi
2. Merry
3. Bluebear
4. Audie
5. Carmen

Normal:
1. Poppy
2. Caroline
3. Megan
4. Kiki
5. Chevre

Snooty:
1. Francine
2. Mint
3. Pecan
4. Judy
5. Portia

Uchi:
1. Canberra
2. Flo
3. Agnes
4. Fuchsia
5. Tammy

Lazy:
1. Filbert
2. Bob
3. Walker
4. Wade
5. Sherb

Jock:
1. Bam
2. Rudy
3. Sheldon
4. Genji
5. Kid Cat

Cranky:
1. Bruce
2. Lobo
3. Roscoe
4. Apollo
5. Cyd

Smug:
1. Marshal
2. Colton
3. Zell
4. Raymond
5. Kyle

EDIT: Number of villagers by species:

Squirrel: 7
Cat: 6
Deer: 4
Rabbit: 4
Cub: 3
Wolf: 3
Dog: 2
Goat: 2
Horse: 2
Penguin: 2
Bear: 1
Eagle: 1
Elephant: 1
Koala: 1
Pig: 1

 

[fuzzynumber9]

Sisterly
1. Cherry
2. Phoebe
3. Deirdre
4. Diva
5. Pashmina

Jock
1. Antonio
2. Mac
3. Pierce
4. Leonardo
5. Hamlet

Lazy
1. Walker
2. Bones
3. Papi
4. Drake
5. Tucker

Peppy
1. Audie
2. Bunnie
3. Cookie
4. Maddie
5. Annabelle

Normal
1. Lolly
2. Mitzi
3. Aurora
4. Gladys
5. Poppy

Smug
1. Shep
2. Zell
3. Tex
4. Hans
5. Raymond

Cranky
1. Hopper
2. Wolfgang
3. Bruce
4. Octavian
5. Rasher

Snooty
1. Whitney
2. Vivian
3. Amelia
4. Julia
5. Velma

Some of these were really hard to narrow down to five, others I really had to stretch my preferences for aha

 

[zato]

Sisterly
mira
reneigh
pashmina
cherry
fuchsia

Jock
snake
kid cat
genji
rowan
tybalt

Lazy
walker
lucky
biskit
sherb
marcel

Peppy
ruby
chrissy
dotty
audie
cookie

Normal
molly
coco
skye
maple
lolly

Smug
raymond
o'hare
marshal
colton
julian

Cranky
fang
bruce
apollo
chief
roscoe

Snooty
whitney
freya
vivian
franchine
portia

 

[Alicia]

Smug:
1.Kyle
2.Shep
3.Marshal
4.Zell
5.Raymond

Cranky:
1.Tom
2.Static
3.Butch
4.Lobo
5.Gonzo

Lazy:
1.Moe
2.Beau
3.Benjamin
4.Deli
5.Alfonso

Jock:
1.Coach
2.Sheldon
3.Sparro
4.Bill
5.Ribbot

Normal:
1.Fauna
2.Poppy
3.Maple
4.Goldie
5.Sylvana

Snooty:
1.Olivia
2.Kitty
3.Purrl
4.Pecan
5.Ankha

Sisterly:
1.Fuchsia
2.Katt
3.Shari
4.Agnes
5. Pashmina

Peppy:
1.Peanut
2.Bella
3.Merry
4.Nibbles
5.Puddles

 

[MyLifeIsCake]

Normal: Kiki, Lily, Coco, Daisy, Merangue
Peppy: Carmen, Nibbles, Bella, Cheri,
Snooty: Vivian, Monique, Queenie, Willow, Astrid
Uchi: Pheobe, Pashima, Muffy, Cherry, Deirdre

Lazy: Walker, Alfonso, Cole, Tucker, Moe
Jock: Hamlet, Mac, Rudy, Snake, Sterling
Cranky: Static, Apollo, Rolf, Octavian, Monty
Smug: Eugene, Ed, Klaus, Kidd, Beardo

 

[RooftopsRevolution]

Normal:
1. Lolly
2. Maple
3. Chevre
4. Merengue
5. Molly


Sisterly: (Least fave lmao)
1. Fuchsia
2. Phoebe
3. Cherry
4. Reneigh
5. Tammy

Peppy:
1. Bangle
2. Bianca
3. Audie
4. Tangy
5. Bonbon

Snooty:
1. Whitney
2. Diana
3. Pecan
4. Vivian
5. Friga

Smug:
1. Marshal
2. Kyle
3. Lopez
4. Raymond (I guess??? I'm not buying into his hype lol)
5. Phil

Cranky:
1. Chief
2. Wolfgang
3. Fang
4. Lobo
5. Rolf

Lazy:
1. Stitches
2. Zucker
3. Beau
4. Lucky
5. Punchy

Jock:
1. Tybalt
2. Rowan
3. Sheldon
4. Genji
5. Leonardo

 

[Minimasher]

Ooooh this seems fun!

Uchi:
1. Frita
2. Hazel
3. Reneigh
4. Fuchsia
5. Muffy

Jock:
1. Rudy
2. Kody
3. Lyman
4. Poncho
5. Tybalt

Snooty:
1. Amelia
2. Whitney
3. Willow
4. Pecan
5. Mallary

Cranky:
1. Static
2. Murphy
3. Hamphrey
4. Buzz
5. Octavian

Peppy:
1. Wendy
2. Bluebear
3. Pompom
4. Piper
5. Twiggy

Lazy:
1. Moe
2. Ozzie
3. Zucker
4. Jeremiah
5. Jacob

Normal:
1. Marina
2. Sally
3. Goldie
4. Vesta
5. Celia

Smug:
1. Zell
2. Julian
3. Curlos
4. Lucha
5. Shep

 

[Kalle]

I've maintained a "top villagers list" for a long time in a doc, so this is the perfect post to share it. Here's a link to download my last update. I'd attach it, but docs are not allowed. Feel free to copy the format to keep your own updated.

 

[milotics]

sisterly:
1. muffy
2. phoebe
3. katt
4. hazel
5. reneigh

jock:
1. genji
2. tybalt
3. dom
4. teddy
5. bam

peppy:
1. audie
2. flora
3. tangy
4. bunnie
5. rosie

normal:
1. aurora
2. merengue
3. lily
4. skye
5. tia

lazy:
1. zucker
2. lucky
3. punchy
4. bob
5. wade

smug:
1. raymond
2. marshal
3. kyle
4. zell
5. julian

snooty:
1. diana
2. judy
3. ankha
4. blanche
5. pecan

cranky:
1. fang
2. wolfgang
3. chief
4. kabuki
5. static

whew that was actually harder than i thought it'd be.

 

[5cm/s]

oh gosh it'd be so busy:

peppy: ruby, bangle, maddie, ketchup, merry

normal: lolly, maple, melba, molly, skye

uchi: deirdre, fuschia, pashmina, agnes, ursala

snooty: blaire, blanche, portia, vivian, pecan

lazy: sherb, erik, joey, chester, dizzy

smug: marshal, henry, o'hare, shep, zell

cranky: dobie, fang, apollo, rolf, butch

jock: teddy, bill, kid cat, rudy, roald

 

[The Hidden Owl]

Uchi
1. Fuchsia
2. Agnes
3. Shari
4. Cherry
5. Tammy

Jock
1. Goose
2. Roald
3. Tank
4. Scoot
5. Dom

Lazy
1. Zucker
2. Beau
3. Stu
4. Erik
5. Bob

Peppy
1. Tammi
2. Rosie
3. Puddles
4. Bluebear
5. Peanut

Normal
1. Marina
2. Chevre
3. Lily
4. Lolly
5. Molly

Smug
1. Marshal
2. Lopez
3. Phil
4. Keaton
5. Jacques

Cranky
1. Bruce
2. Avery
3. Groucho
4. Chief
5. Rolf

Snooty
1. Mint
2. Annalise
3. Pancetti
4. Queenie
5. Yuka

This sounds so fun! and so incredibly terrible at the same time lol