If the game was forcing you to choose 5 villagers of each personality...

[Magus]

You would have a huge town with 40 villagers. So your villagers will be ?

For me, I think it would be...

Sisterly
1. Deirdre
2. Phoebe
3. Fuchsia
4. Cherry
5. Canberra

Jock
1. Scoot
2. Genji
3. Bam
4. Billy
5. Drift

Lazy
1. Zucker
2. Beau
3. Tucker
4. Lucky
5. Bob

Peppy
1. Audie
2. Flora
3. Ketchup
4. Ruby
5. Bella

Normal
1. Coco
2. Kiki
3. Poppy
4. Merengue
5. Marina

Smug
1. Eugene
2. Raymond
3. Marshal
4. Pietro
5. Jacques

Cranky
1. Cyd
2. Kabuki
3. Octavian
4. Lobo
5. Dobbie

Snooty
1. Tiffany
2. Olivia
3. Freya
4. Diana
5. Ankha


IT'S NOT THE END, surprise !
Now I propose you to count how many villagers you have by species, with this method you will kind of discover your actual species tier list that take variety of personalities in consideration too !

For me this is the result :

6 Cats
5 Deers
4 Rabbits
4 Wolves
3 Octopus
2 Elephants
2 Ostriches
2 Koalas
2 Ducks
2 Squirrels
2 Dogs
1 Sheep
1 Goat
1 Frog
1 Rhino
1 Bird
1 Mouse


Your turn !

 

[sigh]

sisterly:
- pashmina
- muffy
- tammy
- fuchsia
- shari / hazel / cherry

jock:
- tybalt
- rudy
- flip
- genji
- roald

lazy:
- zucker
- jeremiah
- stitches
- bob / punchy
- lucky

peppy:
- bonbon
- audie
- tangy
- cookie
- ketchup

normal:
- lily
- coco
- molly
- marina
- poppy

smug:
- marshal
- raymond
- julian
- pietro
- kyle

cranky:
- chief
- fang
- octavian
- knox
- spike

snooty:
- diana
- judy
- vivian
- pecan
- blanche / whitney / ankha

 

[Sheando]

Interesting question! These are my favorites across all the games:

Sisterly
1. Shari
2. Cherry
3. Pashmina
4. Reneigh
5. Katt

Jock
1. Antonio
2. Rod
3. Drift
4. Snake
5. Genji

Lazy
1. Bones
2. Broccolo
3. Deli
4. Hornsby
5. Erik

Peppy
1. Bubbles
2. Anabelle
3. Cookie
4. Tammi
5. Bluebear

Normal
1. Lolly
2. Sydney
3. Dora
4. Vesta
5. Poppy

Smug
1. Curlos
2. Lionel
3. Huck
4. Kidd
5. Pietro

Cranky
1. Cesar
2. Hopper
3. Octavian
4. Spike
5. Gonzo

Snooty
1. Willow
2. Vivian
3. Cashmere
4. Annalise
5. Snooty

 

[Lethalia]

Uchi:

Tammy
Pashmina
Agnes
Cherry
Charlise

Cranky:

Rolf
Fang
Admiral
Vladimir
Boris

Snooty:

Claudia
Kitty
Olivia
Pancetti
Tasha

Jock:

Tybalt
Teddy
Mott
Kody
Samson

Lazy:

Bones
Cole
Hugh
Nate
Punchy

Peppy:

Sprinkle
Merry
Puddles
Tutu
Truffles

Normal:

Celia
Gala
Deena
Maggie
Mitzi

Smug:

Marshal
Hans
Eugene
Olaf
Beardo

 

[voltairenism]

Jock:
- Mac
- Bam
- Genji
- Snake
- Dom

Smug:
- Kyle
- Marshal
- Pietro
- Raymond
- O'Hare

Cranky:
- Static
- Wolfgang
- Octavian
- Dobie
- Tom

it was so hard to choose i edited like a thousand times I love crankies

Peppy:
- Bangle
- Dotty
- Tangy
- Agent S
- Ketchup

Uchi:
- Frita
- Muffy
- Hazel
- Mira
- Fuschia, i guess? I don't like this personality

Normal:
- Coco
- Marina
- Poppy
- Sylvana
- Celia

Lazy:
- Beau
- Clay
- Lucky
- Bob
- Hugh

Snooty:
- Ankha
- Blaire
- Mint
- Tasha
- Soleil

gosh I'm really biased towards squirrels

 

[Briar]

Sisterly
Cherry
Agnes
Pashmina
Phoebe
Fuchsia

Jock
Roald
Billy
Dom
Genji
Snake

Lazy
Punchy
Lucky
Bob
Beau
Drago

Peppy
Bianca
Flora
Rosie
Ruby
Cheri

Normal
Lily
Marina
Merengue
Eunice
Kiki

Smug
Olaf
Marshal
Julian
Raymond
Kyle

Cranky
Apollo
Curt
Octavian
Fang
Roscoe

Snooty
Ankha
Julia
Whitney
Diana
Yuka

 

[Rosewater]

Sisterly
1. Phoebe
2. Fuchsia
3. Pashmina
4. Agnes
5. Cherry

Jock
1. Woolio
2. Snake
3. Genji
4. Sterling
5. Drift

Lazy
1. Punchy
2. Bob
3. Pierre
4. Biskit
5. Stitches

Peppy
1. Audie
2. Peanut
3. Ketchup
4. Rosie
5. Tangy/Bunnie

Normal
1. Poppy
2. Maple
3. Molly
4. Sunny
5. Marina

Smug
1. Marshal
2. Pietro
3. O'Hare
4. Phil
5. Henry

Cranky
1. Rolf
2. Chief
3. Octavian
4. Apollo
5. Wolfgang

Snooty
1. Olivia
2. Purrl
3. Pecan
4. Whitney
5. Freya

 

[Altarium]

Sisterly:
Deirdre
Reneigh
Phoebe
Pashmina
Muffy

Snooty:
Diana
Whitney
Tasha
Julia
Ankha

Peppy:
Bianca
Flora
Ruby
Sprinkle
Piper

Normal:
Molly
Skye
Lily
Poppy
Fauna

Lazy:
Beau
Erik
Papi
Sherb
Ozzie

Cranky:
Fang
Chief
Apollo
Bruce
Wolfgang

Jock:
Boone
Bill
Rudy
Hamlet
Teddy

Smug:
Julian
Zell
Lopez
Shep
Marshal

 

[Arithmophobia17]

ooo, i am so prepared for this
cranky: apollo, avery, dobie, lobo, and walt
jock: dom, mott, rod, snake, and sprocket
lazy: bob, doc, punchy, sherb, and zucker
smug: colton, julian, kyle, marshal, and raymond (though depending on how i feel i might sub colton out for pietro... i've been having doubts about colton recently)
normal: caroline, gayle, gladys, lolly, and megan (with poppy on the waitlist...)
peppy: audie, bangle, bella, flora, and tangy
snooty: amelia, francine, tasha, mint, and vivian
uchi: fuchsia, reneigh, cherry, hazel, and ursala
this was part of how i decided which villagers i wanted on my island

 

[Ananas Dragon]

Sisterly
Agnes
Mira
Fuchsia
Cherry
Muffy
Jock
Sparro
Dom
Kid cat
genji
roald
lazy
bob
zucker
hopkins
lucky
papi
peppy
Rosie
piper
francine's sister I forgot her name nvm i just remembered her name is chrissy
cookie
tangy
Normal
marina
goldie
maple
merengue
coco
Smug
Marshal
no not raymond he suk instead Shep
chadder
julian
pietro
cranky
Apollo
Octavian
butch
fang
chief
snooty
judy
diana
francine
ankha
becky

 

[nekob13]

• Cranky:
Bruce
Groucho
Static
Tom
Gonzo

• Jock:
Bam
Rudy
Dom
Ribbot
Antonio

• Lazy:
Beau
Erik
Sherb
Punchy
Stitches

• Normal:
Kiki
Nan
Fauna
Coco
Lolly

• Peppy:
Flora
Dotty
Ruby
Sprinkle
Bluebear

• Smug:
Kidd
Raymond
Eugene
Julian
Jacques

• Snooty:
Olivia
Purrl
Ankha
Julia
Tasha

• Uchi:
Pashmina
Diva
Phoebe
Muffy
Ursala

 

[Tasuot]

Sisterly
1. Agnes
2. Muffy
3. Katt
4. Reneigh
5. Shari

Jock
1. Dom
2. Bam
3. Rudy
4. Kody
5. Flip

Lazy
1. Beau
2. Stitches
3. Punchy
4. Erik
5. Sherb

Peppy
1. Audie
2. Rosie
3. Tangy
4. Bianca
5. Maddie

Normal
1. Molly
2. Lolly
3. Flurry
4. Fauna
5. Melba

Smug
1. Marshal
2. Raymond
3. Julian
4. Zell
5. Kyle

Cranky
1. Apollo
2. Tom
3. Hamphrey
4. Bruce
5. Octavian

Snooty
1. Judy
2. Whitney
3. Ankha
4. Diana
5. Vivian

 

[Xara]

i’d cry if i had 40 villagers. but uh

normal
lolly
skye
gayle
goldie
maggie

peppy
sprinkle
audie
felicity
bonbon
cheri

snooty
diana
whitney
julia
vivian
freya

uchi
fuchsia
katt
pashmina
deirdre
cherry

lazy
zucker
punchy
beau
moe
erik

jock
kid cat
bam
rudy
drift
iggly

cranky
dobie
lobo
fang
bruce
murphy

smug
zell
lopez
marshal
phil
chadder

 

[cloudmask]

god i wish....

uchi:
reneigh
fuchsia
muffy
pashmina
phoebe

normal:
merengue
poppy
skye
pekoe
lily

peppy:
audie
rosie
bunnie
chrissy
flora

snooty:
whitney
ankha
vivian
pecan
purrl

smug:
lopez
jacques
kyle
marshal
zell

lazy:
beau
punchy
sherb
stitches
bob

cranky:
lobo
wolfgang
wart jr.
apollo
dobie

jock:
rudy
genji
bam
dom
sprocket

 

[Nunnafinga]

Uchi:
Mira
Katt
Pashmina
Hazel
Plucky

Snooty:
Tipper
Bree
Mallary
Pecan
Claudia

Peppy:
Tutu
Pinky
Tangy
Winnie
Merry

Normal:
Pekoe
Gala
Nan
Kiki
Maple

Lazy:
Joey
Dizzy
Filbert
Nate
Benjamin

Cranky:
Gaston
Wart Jr.
Static
Grizzly
Octavian

Jock:
Goose
Curly
Scoot
Drift
Sheldon

Smug:
Colton
Marshal
Quillson
Henry
Hans

 

[Mink777]

Normal-
1. Daisy
2. Goldie
3. Bea
4. June
5. Poppy

Peppy-
1. Maddie
2. Cookie
3. Bluebear
4. Dotty
5. Cheri

Snooty-
1. Portia
2. Tasha
3. Freya
4. Whitney
5. Vivian

Uchi-
1. Cheri
2. Fuchsia
3. Deirdre
4. Reneigh
5. Mira

Lazy-
1. Biskit
2. Walker
3. Bones
4. Lucky
5. Benjamin/Marcel

Jock-
1. Mac
2. Kody
3. Jitters
4. Scoot
5. Poncho

Cranky-
1. Butch
2. Cyd
3. Octavian
4. Chief
5. Buzz

Smug-
1. Shep
2. Jacques
3. Chadder
4. Lopez
5. Henry

 

[kyrynbunni]

Sisterly:
Hazel
Muffy
Pashmina
Tammi
Agnes

Normal:
Flurry
Lily
Coco
Sylvana
Etoile

Peppy:
Ruby
Bunni
Apple
Wendy
Dotty

Snooty:
Freya
Francine
Ankha
Julia
Pecan

Smug:
Marshall
Pietro
Kyle
Julian
Zell

Lazy:
Lucky
Raddle
Cole
Pierre
Stitches

Cranky:
Fang
Chief
Hamphrey
Static
Wolfgang

Jock:
Bam
Woolio
Dom
Ribbot
Kid Cat

(Nintendo would make me the happiest if they'd bring back Pierre ;w; )

 

[Rori]

This is kinda hard, but I'll try!

Sisterly
-Frita
-Reneigh
-Canberra
-Plucky
-Flo

Jock
-Kid Cat
-Dom
-Drift
-Pierce
-Rudy

Lazy
-Bob
-Punchy
-Zucker
-Erik
-Ozzie

Peppy
-Tangy
-Rosie
-Flora
-Victoria
-Pompom

Normal
-Lolly
-Lily
-Melba
-Alice
-Vesta

Smug
-Raymond
-Marshal
-Julian
-Pietro
-Henry

Cranky
-Rolf
-Roscoe
-Vic
-Apollo
-Fang

Snooty
-Purrl
-Bree
-Blanche
-Baabara
-Mint

Don't think I could handle that many villagers, though...

 

[Ace Marvel]

Sisterly
1. Reneigh
2. Phoebe
3. Hazel
4. Renee
5. Muffy

Jock
1. Dom
2. Genji
3. Sheldon
4. Billy
5. Teddy

Lazy
1. Sherb
2. Beau
3. Erick
4. Filbert
5. Bob

Peppy
1. Peanut
2. Flora
3. Audie
4. Carmen
5. Cookie

Normal
1. Poppy
2. Sylvana
3. Goldie
4. Merengue
5. Rosie

Smug
1. Julian
2. Raymond
3. Marshal
4. Colton
5. Kyle

Cranky
1. Chief
2. Fang
3. Octavian
4. Static
5. Walt

Snooty
1. Whiney
2. Pecan
3. Blanche
4. Diana
5. Judy

 

[Braixen]

ohhh fun! I love listing my favs lol

sisterly;
1. Cherry
2. Fuchsia
3. Pashmina
4. Phoebe (was my starter!)
5. Reneigh

jock;
1. Dom
2. Rod
3. Rudy
4. Bam
5. Tybalt

lazy;
1. Sherb
2. Zucker
3. Beau
4. Alfonzo
5. Erik

peppy;
1. Audie
2. Wendy
3. Flora
4. Bianca
4. Rosie

normal;
1. Lolly
2. Marina
3. Fauna
4. Maple
5. Poppy

smug;
1. Julian
2. Raymond
3. Marshal
4. Kidd
5. Kyle

cranky;
1. Rolf
2. Chief
3. Fang
4. Wolfgang
5. Butch

snooty;
1. Diana
2. Whitney
3. Vivian
4. Ankha
5. Blanche