I need help in deciding some of my villagers

[Rasha]

This will be an unnecessarily long post, apologies in advance.

Back new in leaf days I always wanted to have an all wolf town but at the time there were only 8 wolves so I added two deer to the mix (Bruce and Beau) then the welcome amiibo update added another 3 (Vivian, Dobie and Wolf Link) so I had to to replace the deer with two of them, believe I actually got the three and removed another wolf I had, can't remember who.

Anyway something else happened, I realized later that I actually like my deer villager Bruce more than most of the wolves in my town, I missed having him when I actually had an all wolf town so I decided that he has to be in my NH island and I decided to bring back Beau to balance things a bit since every other villager I have is a wolf, except I realized that I probably don't like Beau as much as I'm trying to convince my self that I do and I'm just keeping him as "the other deer", I used to love him more in NL because the food talk was adorable and now the personality change with the bug talk is just not it, also I never liked his house, he is still very cute though.

My sisters started to actually play ACNH with me and they don't like Beau and want him replaced with Whitney, I told them that Whitney is probably my least favorite wolf (she is very pretty though) but that talk got me thinking, I'm not that attached to either Whitney or Beau but since my sisters want her I could replace Beau with her. However, if I do it means Bruce will be a lone deer in a sea of wolves, I do like most of the other deer but Beau seemed the most fitting since he's my only Lazy.

What do I do? do I replace Beau with Whitney, I'm afraid I'd regret it.

 

[Jam86]

oooh this one's tough because i prefer whitney to beau

it seems like you would rather have beau instead of whitney and if you don't pick her, you'll still have 8 other wolves and most of them are really cute ♡
but are there no wolves you could replace with whitney?

 

[R. Planet]

All deer and wolf island would be cool...

 

[Cadbberry]

It would be kinda funny to have a single deer on a wolf island!

 

[absol]

Aww i had Bruce in ACNL too and I loved him there!
I think having a deer friend + a lazy villager is nice
You probably have quite a lot of crankies now right? might be good to keep the lazy one so you have more variety in the conversations

 

[Xara]

if you feel you’ll regret it, there’s your answer ;u;

 

[JKDOS]

If you like Beau, and it's your town, keep him. I know it's harsh, but it's not your sister's town.

If the Switch and town are co-owned, you're going to have to compromise.

 

[edsett]

Might you consider another villager? Because it seems you don’t really vibe with Beau or Whitney lol. But between those two, I’d say stick with Beau. You weren’t considering Whitney until your sisters brought her up so perhaps you won’t really like if she’s on your island...

 

[Rasha]

Thank you for the responses, I think in the end I decided to keep Beau and add Whitney to the spot that was preserved from Audie because I don't think I can afford Audie now, I don't know what'll happened later when I'm actually able to obtain her guess I have to wait and see