Help me pick a Snooty?

[abby10]

So I am currently out searching for a new villager. NMTs are not an issue because I traded Raymond earlier. I have been trying to decide which Snooty villager I want on my island when suddenly, one of the two I am torn between has shown up on the current island I'm on: Diana.

The question is if I invite Diana or if I should wait and get Julia. I love them both and I am so torn.

My planned final island is:
Roald
Bob
Pietro
Wolfgang
Fuchsia
Marina
Rosie or Audie or Flora (also torn on Peppy lol)
Merengue
Biskit

+this Snooty

I am not totally sure if I want more than one deer on my island, and I am going to have Fuchsia... but I am not committed to that....

One final facet is that my sister does have Diana's amiibo card. She won't be home until the end of May but I could get her later? But I could also just get her now....

This is all just very tough and I need help lol

 

[moonolotl]

deer are the best! definitely go diana, shes such a cutie and her house is a pretty spa lol

 

[Jared:3]

Oh Diana is amazing as I have her in my island, her house is stunning and she's so elegant!

 

[meggtheegg]

oooooo okay with all your bright colored residents, i reallyyyy think julia would be chefs kiss on your island, she'd fit in with all the vibrant colors and also she's based off a peafowl which is sick!! i also think there's always something to be said (for me) about not repeating species too much, and you already have fuschia (who is a much cooler deer imo)

 

[Arckaniel]

My #1 snooty so far is Diana so I'd say her, Julia's pretty cute tho, I feel like whomever fits your island and villagers more should be your pick

 

[Luella]

Get them both!

- Someone running with 2 snooty villagers.

(I like Julia though. She's fun to look at. But I do like both.)

 

[Alicia]

I like Diana, but Julia is so cute. I would go with Julia!

 

[abby10]

oooooo okay with all your bright colored residents, i reallyyyy think julia would be chefs kiss on your island, she'd fit in with all the vibrant colors and also she's based off a peafowl which is sick!! i also think there's always something to be said (for me) about not repeating species too much, and you already have fuschia (who is a much cooler deer imo)

Ooh this is such a good point.... I am drawn to a lot of bright villagers and I didn't even realize lol

 

[elo-chan]

I love Diana. I've had her for like 6 hours and she already gave me medicine after she saw wasps sting me.

 

[Strong Badam]

I probably would have gone with Diana had I not already had Beau as a villager!

 

[raqball]

As soon as Judy leaves (please be soon!), Diana is going to replace her as my snooty so I vote Diana...

 

[Venn]

I have Julia on my island and she's amazing! Her house is amazing as well!

 

[edsett]

Julia does fit color-wise in your island way more than Diana imo. But it depends on your others like if you’re getting Flora, I would probably say get Diana. Or if you pick another Uchi (or maybe get two Snooties instead? lol)

 

[abby10]

I'll say I am committed to having 2 normal (Marina and Merengue) and 2 lazy (Bob and Biskit). I wish I could have a second island so I could have both snooty!! But I only have room for one

Thank you all for the feedback so far!!

 

[Santana]

Julia goes really well with your other villagers. Both are great picks tho

 

[abby10]

Thanks for the feedback everyone! I think I have decided to go for Julia for now because of the very good points made about how well she meshes with my other villagers! And if I end up wanting Diana, I can always use my sister's amiibo later

 

[Xara]

while i love diana, you can’t go wrong with julia, either! diana is one of my dreamies but i currently have julia on my island and she’s lovely! she’s so pretty and has a great house interior so you can’t really go wrong with either of them ;w;

 

[Selky]

I don't think there's a bad choice overall. Tickets aren't an issue as you stated and your sister has the card. I think a lot of us need to remember it's okay to take a villager and just enjoy them for a bit..nothing has to be permanent or set in stone asap. So, if you had taken Diana that would have been fine because you can enjoy her for however long and save the tickets for another day. Likewise, you can use more tickets now and find Julia hopefully and if you want Diana down the road wait for your sister's card.

No wrong choice. Good luck!

 

[abby10]

I ended up leaving Diana and FOUND AUDIE THE VERY NEXT ISLAND SO IF THAT WASN'T A SIGN Y'ALL!!!

 

[petrichr]

I love Diana and am very biased towards her haha. In terms of your peppy, I would lean Audie or Flora. Flora if you want species variation. But I had Rosie in NL and Audie in NH and I lean Audie only cause she is new I guess. I love her appearance too.