First three mystery island villagers?

[misstayleigh]

Which three villagers did you invite to your island from the mystery tours? I recently restarted and just saw Rodeo and Twiggy, who I passed on, but came across Drago and invited him. He's... certainly out there hahah but I'm trying to be more open to villagers I haven't had before! Plus I thought he'd go well with one of my starters, Sly :^)

 

[Dunquixote]

My first mystery island villager that I invited was Lily. I thought she was cute but thought I would be letting her move pretty quick. I let her move fairly recently but it was difficult. If i had more room, I would’ve let her move and moved her back in with a card maybe since she had rhe starter house and a flea.

My second mystery island villager was I think Bluebear and then my third was Merry, who is a dreamie. I had to kick out merry since she had a fish on display and a sweater from a delivery quest that I didn’t want her to have. Bluebear was cute but I didn’t click with her or Sprinkles, who was one of my starters and I did not enjoy having three peppies even though I thought I liked their personality a lot (I did in NL).

 

[Dracule]

The only neighbor I ever invited from mystery island tours was Sherb. I remember being like, "omg I've never seen this cutie." I ended up giving him to my boyfriend, because I Amiibo moved in all my neighbors. I've never invited any other neighbor since. owo

 

[Nunnafinga]

Te first three villagers I invited from the mystery islands were Audie,Octavian and Pekoe.Audie and Octavian were among the first five villagers I saw on the mystery islands so I was a bit lucky.I found Pekoe later not long after I started my second island.

 

[WaileaNoRei]

My first three mystery island villagers were Rex, Vesta, and Bangle. I liked them all. Though I initially liked Vesta the most, I didn’t really click with her, which was too bad, cause she is adorable. I loved
Rex a lot, his freckles are too cute, but he’s moved on as well.
Bangle, I was initially a little unsure about. I’d passed up Audie and then chosen her cause I thought she was cute enough and I was out of tickets. I didn’t know much at the time, but I knew Audie was very popular, so I didn’t know if it had been a mistake to not invite her.

I initially planned for Bangle to be an early move out...but then one day it just hit me that I actually loved her! And she’s since become one of my favorites and i have no plans to let her go, at least for the foreseeable future.

 

[dizzy bone]

Jambette, Freya, and Bianca! Jambette and Freya are both with me, but Bianca was let go Jambette I invited on Day 2. She was the very first villager I ever met on a mystery island. I love her so much and she's never leaving lol.

 

[deana]

I actually only got Biskit from an island who was actually the first villager I ever ran in to. I went to the island only for supplies and didn't know a villager would be there but he was super cute so I was happy to invite him. My other initial villagers I just left the plots open and allowed for random move ins. But for those I got Cookie and Marina. I definitely would not have picked Cookie because I already had her in New Leaf (so I felt like I didn't need to have her again) but I absolutely adore having her now

 

[Miss Misty]

The only island villager I invited was Wade. My other plots (Peaches and Bubbles) were random move-ins. I'm glad I didn't look for actual dream villagers since those first three villagers have the trash starter homes instead of their real homes. I regret inviting Wade way back when after seeing what his real house is supposed to look like.

 

[niko@kamogawa]

I didn't get to invite anyone! I wasn't aware of this being an option when I first started playing.

I ended up with Rex, Celia, and Penelope as a random move in. All of them left my island a long time ago.

 

[Dio]

My first three mystery island villagers were Punchy, Gayle, and Apple. Punchy ended up being the only one who I decided to keep on my island but I did enjoy have gayle and apple. I really liked Gayles catchphrase (Snacky) and I thought her design was really unique, but I wanted to experiment with different villagers. Apple was so fun to have and I thought she fit the peppy personality really well but when Rosie replaces huck, I ended up liking her more and had to let apple go

 

[Fye]

my first (and only) mystery island villagers were:

• Norma the normal cow villager - who I was able to give to a user on reddit who really wanted her
• Papi the lazy horse villager - who I believe I traded to a user here on bell tree forums
• Sprinkle the peppy penguin - I liker her quite a bit but she wasn't a dreamie so when Fang showed up in my campsite and wanted to kick her out I had to let her go

I spent 10 or so tickets trying to get a rabbit villager for my peppy and after failing all 10 times I gave up on mystery islands and looked up ways to trade villagers with other players, and that's how I found this site

 

[Your Local Wild Child]

On my new main I invited Audie, Maple and Erik. I’m only keeping Erik because I’m making a full deer island now, and Maple has already left.

 

[Insulaire]

For the first three lots, I passed on Jeremiah and took Gala, Audie, and Filbert. I only had five tickets and really lucked out with Audie and Filbert. Wasn’t wild about Gala (probably bottom of the list of Normals) and she was the first to get kicked out via Amiibo, but I was damned if I was going to risk another ugly frog or whatever showing up so I took her.

 

[John Wick]

I amiibo'd all of mine in, so I've never actually seen a villager on a Crook Mile island.

 

[CrankyCupcake]

Rosie, Wolfgang and Goldie, in that order.

Rosie and Goldie have long left my island. Rosie and Pompom were peppy, and I moved them out after I invited Tangy (also found on a mystery island) because I try not to have two peppy residents at once. Goldie was my only normal personality. I realized I have trouble bonding with normal residents in this game, so I let her move out when she asked. I don't have a normal on my island right now.

Wolfgang is still with me. I can't say for sure he will be a permanent resident. But I'm very attached to him and have no plans to move him out in the forseeable future.

 

[Mr.Fox]

I have a good chunk of the amiibo cards, so I only invite villagers I would otherwise not be able to have, so my first three invites were:

Reneigh, Maddie, Cyd

 

[Sharksheep]

My first three starters where Rhonda, Papi, and Bianca. I loved Papi and Bianca but not enough to keep them around

 

[annex]

Gayle and Becky. I was thrilled to get these two on my Island. I love chickens and Gayle is adorable. The other was Bertha.

 

[Balverine]

I got Raddle, Sylvana and Audie! Like em all, but Audie is the only one I still have

 

[Xara]

i didn’t invite my first 3 villagers from the island tours; instead, i let the game choose for me and wound up with pekoe, prince and piper! i found it sort of neat that all 3 of their names started with “p” aha.

bUt if i had used the island tours for my first 3, i would’ve been left with celia, al and one other so tbh,, i’m glad that i let the plots fill randomly aha