First three mystery island villagers?

[maddycha]

rosie, beau, and merengue!! i got super lucky since theyre all my faves

 

[Heartcore]

On my new island:
1. Cookie
2. Sherb
3. Skye

I mainly wanted Sherb and used up a majority of my tickets to find him. Skye and Cookie were cute and I found them relatively quickly so I took both of them knowing I was going to replace them later on.

 

[Hsn97]

I didn’t know you could revisit islands back than to get different villagers so ended up inviting the very first three I came across; Marina, Twiggy and BigTop.

 

[Jas]

i got audie, ozzie, and gayle!!!

 

[Maenarak]

Renee, Buck and Spork

 

[Tinkeringbell]

Alfonso and Patty were my first mystery island villagers. They're also both still in my town, though I'm planning on moving Patty out someday soon.

Besides them, Hopper moved in randomly. I hated the looks of him at first, but now he's grown on me and I may never let him go.

 

[Sefyre]

Beau, Merengue, and Sprinkle were my invites.

I kind of regret inviting Merengue and Sprinkle since I later discovered they have very unique houses, but I love them both too much to let them go and try again.

 

[Garrett]

Beau and Merengue. I ran out of tickets so I got a Nook villager after that, Wendy. I think the next one I chose myself was Fauna.

 

[Seelie]

Fauna and Beau! They're definitely permanent villagers on my island, although I've moved Beau out and back in for his real house and am planning to do the same for Fauna (and Deirdre, who was my starter uchi).

My third slot was auto-filled by Nibbles. She's pretty cute, but I'm going for natural(ish) colored villagers, so unfortunately she was just too teal to stay.

 

[Pikabun]

I have got Pongo Sherb and Merengue I thought I have to invite Pongo when I started playing the game. But felt pretty lucky with the rest!

 

[deerteeth]

One of them was random, and the others were Skye and Drago. I have since let them both go in favour of some other villagers, but it was nice to have Skye since I never had her before, and Drago is just cute in general! I think my random was Twiggy, who I also enjoyed having. I miss her sometimes, but she moved to my boyfriend’s island so I still get to see her

 

[Sander]

Mine were Erik, Audie & Mitzi.

Only Erik stays in the long run, but I just let him go in order to invite him back in his upgraded interior. As soon as a new plot comes free the hunt will begin (although this might take a while since Fauna asked to move out 3 times in a row and I’m not letting her go lol).

 

[Skandranon]

Whitney was my first and I'm so glad she was, is definitely my favorite villager. funny thing she might not of been my first, encountered others before her, but didn't know if you talked to them a second time they would move to your island >.<

 

[skarmoury]

My first two mystery island villagers were Sherb and Nan! These were for the first 3 houses so they had to be lazy, normal, and peppy. I was absolutely thrilled to have Sherb as my first, since I knew I wanted him the moment the new villagers were announced for ACNH! I took in Nan too because she was really cute. I eventually had to let Nan go to make room for other villagers, but she was definitely a wonderful villager to have met and bonded with for some time <33

(sadly I don't remember my third mystery island villager since I started skipping villagers afterwards, but the third one I did invite to my island was Judy!! She was my 5th mystery island villager I think!)

 

[Candy83]

On my island Óhana, the Mystery Island adventure resulted in two move-ins: Normal goat Nan and Lazy deer Erik. I did not select a Peppy. So, I was assigned a random: the rabbit Bonbon.

 

[Aurita]

My first 3 were Bones, Flora, & Chevre!

Bones was literally my first NMT, saw him and immediately brought him over I initially just took Flora & Chevre bc I was running out of tickets and I didn’t want random move-ins. I ended up loving both Flora & Chevre so much

I still have Bones & Flora and they’re still in their starter homes but considering moving them out & back for their houses.. Chevre moved out bc I needed a jock and I had 3 normals she was the only one I had a pic of so she was let go

 

[TheSillyPuppy]

I didn't bother going Mystery Island hopping for the three villagers. I lucked out, though, and ended up with Goldie (normal dog), Bone (lazy dog), and Pango (peppy anteater). :> I still have Bones, though I am looking to move him out if he ever asks so I can experience more lazy villagers; I recently got his Amiibo, so I'm not worried about losing him forever.

I've already moved out Goldie and Pango, the former of which I have an Amiibo for as well. There are too many cutie patooties in this game!

 

[meggiewes]

My first three were Sherb. Marina, and Bianca.

 

[Snek]

My first 3 were Norma, Benedict, and Tangy. I got Norma's and Tangy's photos. All 3 are now gone because I like themed houses and the interiors were so dull all full of Diy and generic furniture

 

[Halloqueen]

The Nook Miles Islanders I decided to pursue were Annalisa (Normal), Bella (Peppy), and Tucker (Lazy). Annalisa and Bella were easily found, but it took actual weeks of visits to Nook Miles Islands to find Tucker. Kind of a shame that I decided to go with Tucker from the Nook Miles Island since I didn't know those first three had personality-dependent houses and not the unique personal ones, as I was under the impression that the basic houses were in reference to just the two starting Jock and Sisterly villagers. I think his personal house looks neat, but it's whatever at this point. Saved me from having to get his amiibo card or otherwise go through more effort to acquire him. They all tie into my island's theme and are permanent residents, unless I change my mind for some reason, so it all works out in the end.