My first two, Billy and Tammy, are still on my island although I am planning on letting them go. Out of Merengue, Wendy, and Rex, who were 3-5, Merengue is the only still at my island. I'll probably keep her longer but she may end up going as well.
I have Hamlet who was my starter jock villager. I was resetting the game because the first island I got had a green airport and I wanted a blue or yellow one. The second island had a yellow airport so I was like "Okay good start" then I saw Hamlet and I SCREAMED since he is probably my favorite villager (hard to say for sure since I like so many). I also have Melba who was the first villager I moved in and was the first villager I ever saw on an island tour.
I'm definitely keeping Hamlet but I'm considering seeing if a friend will let me move him to their island so I can get rid of his blah starter house. I haven't decided if I'm going to keep Melba forever but I'm happy with her for now (except her boring starter interior).
My first 3 island finds: Ketchup, Bones, and Norma. Only one I have left is Ketchup. I already have her picture but I don't want her to leave. Would love to have someone foster her so she can have her real house...
On another note I have Fauna, who was my fifth villager, and she's still staying strong. I've decided I'm keeping her, especially since her normal house isn't terribly different and nothing worth re-obtaining her for
I have both of my starters (Antonio and Phoebe) and 2/3 of my second villager move-in set. The only one I’ve let leave so far is Pango. Spork is on the list to move out at some point, but I’ve kinda grown fond of him so it’s tough to say when this will happen.
Norma, Antonio, and Phoebe are all staying permanently. Even with their less-than-perfect houses I can’t imagine my island without them
Yes. I think my starters were... Diva and Goose. I will never let my boy Goose go. Diva got yeeted ASAP.
I lowkey have no clue what Goose's house normally looks like, but his current one is pretty sweet. I gifted him every exercise DIY i could make. He sports all of it.
I still have all of my original villagers, and I still like them, except for one - Boris was my 10th villager, and he got the boot because he didn't DO anything, he just stayed in his house day after day. He was replaced by Kitty, who's far more entertaining with her overwhelming smugness.
My starters were Rowan and Tammy. Rowan is my best friend on the island, so he’s still around. And to me, Rowan has always seemed like a chill/non-materialistic guy that enjoys being outside, so in my head cannon, it makes senese for him to have a minimalist log cabin interior
I still have my two starters, Dom and Reneigh. Dom is not allowed to ever leave, but I'd let Reneigh leave if she ever asked, which she hasn't done once since the start of the game.