Right now I've got two, they were both starting villagers (the ones you get for the first three plots you build). One is Merry and I've grown to really like her, I think she fits the peppy personality so well and she's cute without being too cute. The other one is Bob but he's just a temporary villager. I'm not a big fan of his design because he's just so purple and I tend to aim for more natural-looking villagers, plus his eyes kind of weird me out.
I really want to get Katt in the long run because she was one of my first NL villagers and I loved her so much I had someone hold her when I reset. I really miss having her around. There are also other cat villagers I had or wanted to have in NL, like Tabby. I really, really wanted Tabby back then but ended up never being able to get her because people just voided her all the time.
I love cats in real life but there are so many of the cat designs in AC that I'm just not a fan of. The cats who wear make-up are a cool concept in theory but villagers with lots of make-up kind of weird me out. Plus there are some I like in theory because they're cute/cartoonish, but would look really out of place among the villagers I tend to like.