Cookie Vs. Maddie

[Blueskyy]

So since collecting Welcome Amiibo cards, I've adopted Maddie. Cookie was always my favorite dog, although she was always a little too...kawaii...for my tastes.

Anyway Maddie seems to really take away all that I didn't like. Smaller yet still blackened eyes, no bright pink fur, etc.

What do you think?

 

[StarUrchin]

Maddie reminds me of Fauna lol

 

[Blueskyy]

Maddie reminds me of Fauna lol

Not me. She's not as bland and boring with a peppy personallity. I like Fauna a lot but she gets really old.

 

[GreenLeaf]

I agree Maddie is much better than Cookie

 

[StarUrchin]

Cookie is so pastel. If you want super SUPER I MEAN SUPER cute villagers, pick her :/

 

[Blueskyy]

Cookie is so pastel. If you want super SUPER I MEAN SUPER cute villagers, pick her :/

That's the problem. super is UPPERCASE. A bit too much for me to love for too long.

 

[Orieii]

I have Cookie, but I also want Maddie.. I'll probably stick with Cookie, because I actually really like her X3

 

[StarUrchin]

Why don't you just adopt Goldie. She is da best

 

[Blueskyy]

Why don't you just adopt Goldie. She is da best

I've had Goldie. I loveeeee her. Actually you're right she was my favorite dog. The problem was she is normal and I love a few other normals more than her. Maddie is just as cute but is peppy so I feel like I can balance with her better and not miss Goldie too much. Probably doesn't make sense. But yeahhh

 

[Lethalia]

I used to think Cookie was WAY too much for me...then I saw her in someone else's town recently, and now I realize...she ain't that bad. So...I guess I like her a bit more than I thought lol. I pick her. Never even seen Maddie in person before, and her pictures don't do much for me.

 

[Blueskyy]

I used to think Cookie was WAY too much for me...then I saw her in someone else's town recently, and now I realize...she ain't that bad. So...I guess I like her a bit more than I thought lol. I pick her. Never even seen Maddie in person before, and her pictures don't do much for me.

I saw Maddie's pics too and didn't really care about her either way but seeing her in my game makes me like her a lot more. One of the best dogs (next to Goldie)

 

[Paperboy012305]

I find Maddie cuter than Cookie. I really want Maddie in my 2nd town.

 

[Blueskyy]

I find Maddie cuter than Cookie. I really want Maddie in my 2nd town.

If you want her I'll move mine out. I have her Welcome Amiibo Card.

 

[sylviabee]

I have Cookie and wouldn't mind swapping her for Maddie since she looks more natural. Peppies annoy me though and I want my peppies out as soon as I get their good PWPs lol.

 

[Paperboy012305]

If you want her I'll move mine out. I have her Welcome Amiibo Card.

Thanks. But I gotta move someone out first. I'll PM you when i'm ready. But probably not today.

 

[Blueskyy]

Thanks. But I gotta move someone out first. I'll PM you when i'm ready. But probably not today.

Ok no problem. The power of amiibo. Get more and push out the ones you don't want

 

[Loriii]

Cookie is the only dog I like but I'm kinda bothered with her eyes so when I saw Maddie the first time, I thought she's similar to Cookie but with toned-down eyes and different color so I begin to like her instantly, so yeah, Maddie.

 

[Blueskyy]

Cookie is the only dog I like but I'm kinda bothered with her eyes so when I saw Maddie the first time, I thought she's similar to Cookie but with toned-down eyes and different color so I begin to like her instantly, so yeah, Maddie.

You think like me. I like this.

 

[Lethalia]

I saw Maddie's pics too and didn't really care about her either way but seeing her in my game makes me like her a lot more. One of the best dogs (next to Goldie)

Yeah, I never thought much of Biskit until I saw him camping in my town one day. I realized he was wayyyyy cuter than I originally thought. So I bet that's the case for Maddie, too. There's a lot of great dogs in this game tbh, they're definitely one of my favorite animals in the series. Goldie's one of my faves, I've had her multiple times in GC version and loved her.

 

[pinkcotton]

I just love Cookie! She's so cute, bright and bubbly! She's definitely the heart of my town :3 Maddie's cute-ish? She looks plain and boring to me. :/