Are there any villager you had more than once?

Fernweh

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2014
Posts
1,072
Bells
502
Winter Mittens
I have currently 4 villager in my town which I had before :)
Phoebe is the third time in my town. She always moved without telling me?
Having her for a third time in my town was more of a coincidence but now she is staying! :)
Ankha is the second time in my town. She didn?t tell me either. I even cycled 16 villager for her.
Diana is the second time in my town as well. My sister accidentally voided her instead of TT-ing her into boxes because I wanted to trade her ^^
The same with Whitney. She moved in and I traded her for another villager. I accidentally picked her up after I had visited my sister who had her in her void ^^

Villager that I had more than once but are not currently in my town are Marina (twice), Goldie (twice), Fuchsia (twice), Rocco (three times, my sister and I always picked him up from one another ^^ getting rid of him was so stressful :D) and a lot more I cannot remember right now :)

Just curious which villager you had more than once and why ^^
 
Nope, I haven't. I don't time travel in my main town, and since I have a set list of dreamies I don't think it will happen. :,3
For some reason though, villagers I have or have once had always seem to show up in my cycling town for some reason. I've never gotten an unobtained dreamie through it, sadly, but I've had Rudy, Daisy, Rocco and Cherry all pop up at one point in both of my towns.
 
I've had Zell twice in my town before. The first time I got him, I absolutely adored him. Then a TT'ing accident occured where he moved out. I worked very hard to cycle 16 while collecting other dreamies and I finally got him back. I missed having him in my town so much. He's one of my absolute favorites. If he were to ever move out, I'd reset my town just for him. I just like him too much to lose him again. Teehee~
 
I had Zucker in my main town twice, both times he moved into awful spots, then I got another Zucker in my second town, which I got from the tent for my brother, otherwise, I don't like Zucker that much, I voided him twice in my main town
 
Bluebear.

She was in my old town, but she was the first to go, because I FOOLISHLY thought that she was going to spread the news about my town. (I was new to the Animal Crossing series at that point) And basically regretted that decision ever since.

I got her in my new town, but she moved out again....just because I forgot to play for a few days...

Ugh...
 
Chief I cycled to get him back ;u; man I hated it. But he's back and he's here to stay. I also had him in city folk which is were I grew to love him haha. The rest I've only had once and have held onto (luckily I might add)
 
Not in the same town, but Deirdre was my random uchi move-in in my first town. Then, she was my random uchi move-in in my second town. Then, I missed her and got her in my third town!
 
Not in the same game but, I got Goose randomly in Wild World and sort of liked him. Now he's my starter in my ACNL and I liked him enough to make him a permanent villager :D He's just so cheerful!
 
I got new versions of Curly,Bubbles,Kidd,Ozzie and Jambette for different reasons.Curly,Ozzie and Kidd have been much better the second time around but Bubbles and Jambette not so much(I'm still keeping them,though).I have repeats in New Leaf from my Gamecube town:Pinky,Olivia,Kiki,Octavian and Gaston.
 
Rasher he was in my WW town
and also I destroyed my NL town so much and he was a resident of 3 of those towns
and now he is living in my current town.

kinda makes me happy I know it's just a game but I like to imagine that he's following My character
because he doesn't want to leave them because they are good friends uwu

also this made Rasher one of my favorite villagers
 
Last edited:
I almost had Rosie in my town for a second time when cycling villagers, but I went with another instead.
 
I moved Diana into my town from one of my other towns but she moved in a bad spot so months later I found her in my cycle town and moved her over, only this time I plot reset her. I originally had Flora but I moved her out because she was in a terrible spot then moved her back but she left me without warning v.v
 
Nope. Usually when villagers I love move away I just replace them with another favorite. I don't want to have to go through all of that for a villager. Plus a new villager feels refreshing for me.
 
Last edited:
Yup. Willow.
She practically followed me into every town that I have/had XD
First it was my cycling town, then my main town, and then my second town (but I had to move her out of both of my towns sadly...)
 
No, though I wish somehow I could get Poppy and Francine again. It's too tedious to cycle through villagers for me anyways ^^"

Though if you don't mean just New Leaf, then for me it's Mint and Anchovy. I had them both in WW and I grew to like them a lot. Sadly Mint moved away and idk about Anchovy since I lost my WW cartridge. They're both safely in my town now :'3
 
Last edited:
I've had Tom and Apollo in every version of AC I've played. I've had Ozzie in the GC version and in NL. I intend to have both Apollo and Ozzie in the next installment as well, as they are both my dreamies.
 
Back
Top