Early on I gave Kitt a sleeping mask which sat on her nose She hasn't been on my island in a while but I still think about it when I give stuff to villagers trying not to make the same mistake. And then my villagers asked to buy fish and bugs from me and I couldn't say no to them... Now Raymond has a citrus beetle, Wolfgang and Marshal have a sea bass as a sign of our friendship... Thankfully I didn't let Ankha buy a flea from me but still....
I had two cycling caps in my pocket. The yellow and green one and a red one. I thought I gave Buck the green and yellow one which would look decent on him
No
He's sporting a bright red hat that looks awful on him and he won't take it off xD
Speaking of fleas, one time Broccolo asked for a flea that was in my pocket and I hate saying no so I gave it to him and he put it in his house. The next day he had a flea on him, and the next time I went in his house the flea I sold him was gone.
I gave Vivian a shirt and I assumed it would be a little longer on her like her default clothes and it cuts off right above the end of the darker brown spot on her belly and it looks so bad lol
I had two cycling caps in my pocket. The yellow and green one and a red one. I thought I gave Buck the green and yellow one which would look decent on him
No
He's sporting a bright red hat that looks awful on him and he won't take it off xD
Speaking of fleas, one time Broccolo asked for a flea that was in my pocket and I hate saying no so I gave it to him and he put it in his house. The next day he had a flea on him, and the next time I went in his house the flea I sold him was gone.
It wasn‘t a gift but one day Mira asked to buy a Darner dragonfly off me. I said sure bc she offered more than the Nooklings pay but I didn’t realize she would put it on display in her house. The cage looks hideous and doesn’t match her interior at all, so wish I had said no.
I thought I had a fruit in my inventory when I chose to gift Judy, but I didn’t. Instead, I had to give her a jewel beetle because I didn’t have anything else. Not a terrible gift, but it’s kinda out of place in her home.
I gave Vivian a shirt and I assumed it would be a little longer on her like her default clothes and it cuts off right above the end of the darker brown spot on her belly and it looks so bad lol
I hope so! She hasn't worn it since I bought it for her so I hope she just doesn't like it and it's not the same style she likes. The shirt looked longer too so I was really surprised when she put it on
It wasn‘t a gift but one day Mira asked to buy a Darner dragonfly off me. I said sure bc she offered more than the Nooklings pay but I didn’t realize she would put it on display in her house. The cage looks hideous and doesn’t match her interior at all, so wish I had said no.
Erik literally asked me for the same dragonfly and after the experience with my other villagers there was NO WAY I was saying yes. ;__; It hurts to turn them down, but I have to!
I thought I had a fruit in my inventory when I chose to gift Judy, but I didn’t. Instead, I had to give her a jewel beetle because I didn’t have anything else. Not a terrible gift, but it’s kinda out of place in her home.
Yeah when they display clothes in their houses it kinda sucks. Whitney's house is full of clothes that are hung up... guess she didn't love what I gave her...
I hope so! She hasn't worn it since I bought it for her so I hope she just doesn't like it and it's not the same style she likes. The shirt looked longer too so I was really surprised when she put it on
She hasn't been on my island in a while but I still think about it when I give stuff to villagers trying not to make the same mistake. And then my villagers asked to buy fish and bugs from me and I couldn't say no to them... Now Raymond has a citrus beetle, Wolfgang and Marshal have a sea bass as a sign of our friendship... 
Thankfully I didn't let Ankha buy a flea from me but still....
Especially if they put it on display in their house, yuck.
I gave Apollo a pedal board and it's sideways on his diner table
