anyone else disagree with a villager's personality?

[Jam86]

so i've been thinking about this for a while and i just don't think judy suits being a snooty villager
it's mainly becaise of her look:
☆her pastel design
☆glittery eyes
☆fairytale dress
☆toy-like furniture
it just seems pretty childish, don't get me wrong i love judy and i can't wait to get her on my island, but i just feel she would have been better as a normal or even peppy ☆

another one is lucha
he was my brother's first campsite villager and i thought he must be a jock
he is designed like a wrestler AND his house is literally sport themed
i was legit shocked when i found out he was a smug

does anyone else have that one villager they just don't think their personality suits them??

 

[lieryl]

idk why dom is a jock but honestly with him i can finally have a jock that matches my aesthetic so i don’t mind lol

 

[pinkfawn]

I came here to say Judy too. When I bring her to my island, I'll have a total of 3 snooty villagers I'm keeping. I wish she had been peppy because I still need to decide on which peppy I want. There's a lot of good ones, it just would have worked better if Judy was peppy I suppose.

 

[edsett]

I really like Judy as snooty because she’s calm and sweet which matches the pastel vibes more than a hyperactive personality would. I don’t think I would like as much if she was peppy aha.

 

[Aubrey895]

I agree Judy should be peppy. Also I think Dom should be lazy. But I’m glad he’s jock lol.

 

[Jam86]

I really like Judy as snooty because she’s calm and sweet which matches the pastel vibes more than a hyperactive personality would. I don’t think I would like as much if she was peppy aha.

i might change my mind when i get her but at the moment i just don't see it lol

 

[lieryl]

honestly i like that some villagers don’t look their personality type ^_^ i gravitate towards cute villagers and if they’re all normal i can’t have them all on my island lol. would love a cute cranky tbh

 

[Jam86]

honestly i like that some villagers don’t look their personality type ^_^ i gravitate towards cute villagers and if they’re all normal i can’t have them all on my island lol. would love a cute cranky tbh

i like to think of apollo as a cute cranky aha
jk but i think fang is a cranky and he's adorable imo ♡

 

[lieryl]

i like to think of apollo as a cute cranky aha
jk but i think fang is a cranky and he's adorable imo ♡

i do find the more popular crankies adorable (wolfgang has my heart istg) but i meant like the more traditionally cute designs. i want a pastel cranky

 

[edsett]

i might change my mind when i get her but at the moment i just don't see it lol

Maybe! I do have her and she’s a sweet-snooty instead of a snooty-snooty if you know what I mean. For me it would jarring for her to act like Audie who’s really peppy aha.

honestly i like that some villagers don’t look their personality type ^_^ i gravitate towards cute villagers and if they’re all normal i can’t have them all on my island lol. would love a cute cranky tbh

Yesss. This is why I like Dom so much! He’s so cute for a jock which makes him funnier lol. I really want a cute Uchi or at least a more neutral-looking Uchi? Like I wish Bea was uchi.

 

[lieryl]

Maybe! I do have her and she’s a sweet-snooty instead of a snooty-snooty if you know what I mean. For me it would jarring for her to act like Audie who’s really peppy aha.


Yesss. This is why I like Dom so much! He’s so cute for a jock which makes him funnier lol. I really want a cute Uchi or at least a more neutral-looking Uchi? Like I wish Bea was uchi.

hearing him talking about his muscles while he’s just this fluffy sheep has me in stitches lmao

 

[Dormire]

I think Judy fits her snooty-type well. She's based on the typical shoujo manga antagonist (called an ojou) who laughs a la "O HO HO HO"
and literally has the WORST temper. If you don't believe me, look at her expressions.

Do you think this murderous smile look Peppy to you? I don't think so. (I think this is the bewildered emotion.)

She's also possibly based after Dahlia Hawthorne (from Phoenix Wright series). A literal angel on the outside, an absolute demon on the inside.

Edit: Also, her Japanese catchphrase is "あらら" (My, my.) something ojou-type characters would say.

Dom is something I do think doesn't fit the jock personality. He looks like he's a lazy villager, imo.

 

[lieryl]

I think Judy fits her snooty-type well. She's based on the typical shoujo manga antagonist (called an ojou) who laughs a la "O HO HO HO"
and literally has the WORST temper. If you don't believe me, look at her expressions.

Do you think this murderous smile look Peppy to you? I don't think so. (I think this is the bewildered emotion.)

View attachment 254311

She's also possibly based after Dahlia Hawthorne. A literal angel on the outside, an absolute demon on the inside.

Dom is something I do think doesn't fit the jock personality. He looks like he's a lazy villager, imo.

i’ve seen her make this face but i got so scared looking at that picture lmao

i also think judy looks the part of a snooty, her long lashes could cut me i swear

 

[Hedgehugs]

My friend was shocked to find out Muffy was an Uchi... And at first glance, I thought she would be a Snooty when I saw her in New Leaf.
Kinda sad because I can't afford to have 2 Uchi's in my town and I love Muffy. Shame.

I would argue Judy should've been a Normal but these posts are changing my mind.

Dom definitely is not a jock tho lmao. That was an out of nowhere personality pick.

 

[Dormire]

i’ve seen her make this face but i got so scared looking at that picture lmao

i also think judy looks the part of a snooty, her long lashes could cut me i swear

The first time I saw her upset emotion (like her eyes shrinking and her mouth wide open (like in disbelief)) I knew Judy isn't exactly how she looks LMAO. Then I saw her bewildered emotion NOW that's how I knew I was right. TBH. I found it weird she was in the Snooty too. But after looking at her face sets and dialog, this is totally something based off of the typical shoujo manga antagonists. She's downright scary and pretty much possibly the carbon copy of Dahlia Hawthorne LMAO.

 

[lieryl]

My friend was shocked to find out Muffy was an Uchi... And at first glance, I thought she would be a Snooty when I saw her in New Leaf.
Kinda sad because I can't afford to have 2 Uchi's in my town and I love Muffy. Shame.

I would argue Judy should've been a Normal but these posts are changing my mind.

Dom definitely is not a jock tho lmao. That was an out of nowhere personality pick.

no other new villagers could’ve been a passable jock either lmao imagine sherb talking about his awesome pecs, or cyd asking you to be patrol buddies. whoever they chose would’ve had me rolling either way

 

[Jam86]

tbh honest, i didn't actually know anyone liked dom
no offence to him lol but he was one of my starters and i couldn't wait to get him off my island haha

 

[Xara]

olaf - he looks more cranky than he does smug aha

 

[lieryl]

The first time I saw her upset emotion (like her eyes shrinking and her mouth wide open (like in disbelief)) I knew Judy isn't exactly how she looks LMAO. Then I saw her bewildered emotion NOW that's how I knew I was right. TBH. I found it weird she was in the Snooty too. But after looking at her face sets and dialog, this is totally something based off of the typical shoujo manga antagonists. She's downright scary and pretty much possibly the carbon copy of Dahlia Hawthorne LMAO.

her soft voice also fits her so well! i love the attention they put into her and all the other snooties. judy won’t react to any of my emotions (unless i repeated the crying one like three times) and i think it fits with her personality. i was not expecting her bewildered face when she moved in and honestly i just loved her more T^T

Post automatically merged: May 7, 2020

tbh honest, i didn't actually know anyone liked dom
no offence to him lol but he was one of my starters and i couldn't wait to get him off my island haha

my friend said they want to iron his chin to smooth it out and i never noticed how much it wrinkled until then lol

 

[Jam86]

olaf - he looks more cranky than he does smug aha

olaf is smug?!?!?!?!?!?