Animal Crossing popularity tier list tournament 1

[Mekan1]

So i had an idea that the fans of tbt villager popularity tier list should vote in an out villagers into the list. This is unofficial currently but i will try to make this official. I will take the bottom and top 3 of every tier and see who gets votes to stay or be promoted. You can vote for 1 of each matchup
Tier 2 Promos:
Marina or Erik
Kid Cat or Poppy
Marshal or Whitney
Tier 3 Promos:
Freya or Cherry
Kiki or Fuschia
Flora or Drago
Tier 4 Promos:
Ribbot or Lobo
Poncho or Goldie
Butch or Felicity
Tier 5 Promos:
These work differently. You have to vote someone out of tier 4, nobody into the tier since there is no definitive ranking.
Margie: In or Out
Frita: In or Out
Mint: In or Out

This is not official voting, but I thought it would be interesting to see what other tbt users think of the tier list.

 

[dudeabides]

Tier 2 Promos:
Erik
Kid Cat
Whitney
Tier 3 Promos:
Cherry
Fuschia
Drago
Tier 4 Promos:
Lobo
Poncho
Butch
Tier 5 Promos:
Margie: Out
Frita: In
Mint: In

 

[The Blood Countess]

Eh, why not?

Tier 2 Promos:
Erik
Kid Cat
Whitney

Tier 3 Promos:
Freya
Kiki
Drago

Tier 4 Promos:
Lobo
Poncho
Butch

Tier 5 Promos:
Margie: In
Frita: Out
Mint: In

 

[nue]

Tier 2 Promos:
Marina
Kid Cat
Marshal

Tier 3 Promos:
Freya
Kiki
Drago!!

Tier 4 Promos:
Lobo
Goldie (this one hurt to choose)
Butch

Tier 5 Promos:
Margie: in
Frita: in
Mint: out

 

[Eve]

Tier 2 Promos:
Marina
Poppy
Whitney (this was a hard one for me)

Tier 3 Promos:
Cherry
Kiki
Flora

Tier 4 Promos:
Lobo
Goldie
Felicity

Tier 5 Promos:
Margie: in
Frita: out
Mint: in

 

[LinDUNguin]

Something like this would 't be a bad idea. Rather than analysis of weekly trends, the community could vote on popularity. They already get a say, but this would be more direct and would require less administration and probably relieve Hound00med of being the sole responsibility of the tier list.

 

[jaxxipoo]

Tier 2 Promos:
Erik
Poppy
Marshal
Tier 3 Promos:
Cherry
Kiki
Flora
Tier 4 Promos:
Lobo
Goldie
Felicity
Tier 5 Promos:
These work differently. You have to vote someone out of tier 4, nobody into the tier since there is no definitive ranking.
Margie: Out
Frita: Out
Mint: In

 

[kuseiro]

Tier 2 Promos:
Marina or Erik
Kid Cat or Poppy
Marshal or Whitney *whispers... no i love whitney tho*
Tier 3 Promos:
Freya or Cherry
Kiki or Fuschia
Flora or Drago
Tier 4 Promos:
Ribbot or Lobo
Poncho or Goldie
Butch or Felicity
Tier 5 Promos:
These work differently. You have to vote someone out of tier 4, nobody into the tier since there is no definitive ranking.
Margie: In or Out
Frita: In or Out
Mint: In or Out

 

[PaperCat]

Tier 2 Promos:
Erik
Poppy
Whitney

Tier 3 Promos:
Freya
Kiki
Flora

Tier 4 Promos:
Lobo
Goldie
Butch

Tier 5 Promos:
Margie: In
Frita: Out
Mint: Out

 

[kwhomp]

Marina
Kid Cat
Whitney
Tier 3 Promos:
Cherry
Kiki
Drago
Tier 4 Promos:
Ribbot
Goldie
Felicity
Tier 5 Promos:
Margie: In
Frita: Out
Mint: Out

 

[Awesomeness1230]

Tier two promos:

Erik
Poppy
Marshal

Tier three promos:

Freya
Kiki
Drago

Tier four promos:

Lobo
Poncho
Felicity

Tier five promos:

Margie: In
Frita: Out
Mint: In

 

[HHoney]

Marina or Erik - Erik!!!!!
Kid Cat or Poppy - Kid Cat
Marshal or Whitney - Whitney
Tier 3 Promos:
Freya or Cherry - Cherry (she made me! Sorry Freya!)
Kiki or Fuschia - Fuschia!!!!!!!
Flora or Drago - Flora
Tier 4 Promos:
Ribbot or Lobo: RIBBOT!!!
Poncho or Goldie Goldie
Butch or Felicity - Felicity
Tier 5 Promos:
These work differently. You have to vote someone out of tier 4, nobody into the tier since there is no definitive ranking.
Margie: In - Go Margie!