Which of these are best?

[100]

Help, please?

I made these by myself, no tuts.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

:gyroidsideways:

 

[[Nook]]

they're um..... nice.

 

[Jas0n]

They all suck :S

 

[Pear]

4.
Great job.

 

[technoxmaniac]

I like 1 and 3

 

[[Nook]]

no, they look fine.

 

[Ricano]

1, 3, and 4 are good

 

[100]

They all suck :S

Reason? you should give a reason before you go off saying things suck.. :gyroidconfused:

 

[[Nook]]

yeah guy. you can't just go up to a person and say they suck without a reason.

 

[Jas0n]

They all suck :S

Reason? you should give a reason before you go off saying things suck.. :gyroidconfused:

I didn't give a reason because I thought it was obvious. If you honestly can't see why they suck for yourself then you shouldn't be making signatures.

 

[Pear]

They all suck :S

Reason? you should give a reason before you go off saying things suck.. :gyroidconfused:

They don't suck. (they're better than mine, although that's not saying much.
The diagonal lines are a bit distracting.

 

[.::PurpleLife::.]

1 3 5 look kinda good
you should make a poll

 

[[Nook]]

you can't just go up to a person and diss them. i'm saying this to Jas0n.

 

[fullofmyself]

I agree with Jas0n... they all suck. Maybe you do need to look at Tutorials.

 

[KingofHearts]

I like #3 the most. ♥

Did you make these?

I'm quite impressed.

 

[[Nook]]

me too.

 

[.::PurpleLife::.]

okay nook you have posted here much already...
jees willies.... u rly need 2 say me 2?
someone's a lil desprest 4 bellz

 

[100]

I agree with Jas0n... they all suck. Maybe you do need to look at Tutorials.

Look at tutorials? thats basically all i do. these were some of the first i made without tuts.

here are some WITH tuts:

And heres my first sig i made without tuts:

And I made like 6 other versions of that sig^^

 

[Pear]

You guys either see a sig as sucking, or being good. There's no gray area. His sigs don't suck. They aren't a masterpiece, but they don't suck.

 

[100]

I'm just saying- if you don't havve a reason of why you dont like them, dont say anything.