Simcity vs City XL

[NewBell98]

I really want a city simulator. So the question for you guys is which is better cities xl or simcity. I probably can't afford 10 dollars a month or 120 dollars a year for online on cities xl so the real question is should I get simcity or cities xl offline. If simcity, which one?(I'm thinking about the box)

 

[beehdaubs]

SimCity 4 Complete Edition is great. Rush Hour is a decent expansion if you're a traffic nut.


As long as it isn't Cities XL. That game isn't all that great.

 

[NewBell98]

SimCity 4 Complete Edition is great. Rush Hour is a decent expansion if you're a traffic nut.


As long as it isn't Cities XL. That game isn't all that great.

Well what about simcity creator, what's the good things about that version?

 

[beehdaubs]

SimCity 4 Complete Edition is great. Rush Hour is a decent expansion if you're a traffic nut.


As long as it isn't Cities XL. That game isn't all that great.

Well what about simcity creator, what's the good things about that version?

The Wii SimCity game? It isn't that great from what I've heard. If you're looking for casual fun and you're not too picky about game mechanics, then just get that. If you enjoy a nice and well crafted game that requires some form of thinking and planning, then get SimCity 4 Complete Edition.