Do you always?

[CozyKitsune]

I am such a sucker for my villagers... If they ask my for ANYTHING I always give it to them! Want a rare fish?I fish ALL day trying to catch it! Is anyone else like this?

Spoiler

 

[XIII]

I used to, but not anymore. They have a habit of asking for something that's nearly impossible (ie. a bug that went out of season a few days ago).

 

[HoennMaster]

Ain't nobody got time for that lol

I don't fish or catch bugs for them because I don't want them to end up in their house. Made that mistake once and now Bluebear's house is a disaster.

 

[SoSu]

I was like this for a long time. I finally finished my catalog and realized that my villagers homes looked terrible. Now my obsession is to get as much of their original furniture back into their homes as I can. It's a relief, really, not to get every fish and bug. But I do feel guilty every time!

 

[Camillion]

They seem to have a habit in my town of asking for butterflies when it's storming and Coelacanths when it ain't so I only do things when it's nonspecific and easy tasks

 

[DoctorGallifrey]

I'd try my best to fulfill their wants, but when it comes to going to other towns I had to deny it.

 

[Coach]

If it is a bug I can get on the island, I make the trip specially!

 

[Gracelia]

I usually reject them all. Except if they want to buy an ore or something. No bugs/fish/other to mess up their homes. I will occasionally let them buy furniture from me if I feel it'll go well into their home.

I accidentally gave Lucky an ocean sunfish once. I was continuously poking at screen without looking at the dialogue and when I looked back, I was giving him the fish. His home looked pretty damn hilarious after that. I would have exited the game but had just gotten a PWP I've been waiting around forever for.

 

[Puffy]

If I'm time traveling alot (like asking villagers if anyones moving) and they request something I usually say no
But if I'm playing normally then hell yeah I'll do it

 

[Ankhes]

I feel bad if I don't at least give them the old college try. I do my best to get them whatever they want or else I'll end up feeling guilty.

But later I know I'll probably regret it when I see their houses.

 

[ellabella12345]

I always do this dw xD

 

[hulaburger]

I'll get them something if it's easy but if they want me to get something rare for them, they're on their own.
Usually they just ask me to catch a butterfly or a dragonfly so I'm fine with it.

I never do the petition thing either.

 

[stitchmaker]

Yes I'm a sucker for their requests. Spent a lot of time trying to get rare items early on.
When summer rolled around this time I made sure to collect rare bugs and fish for any requests.
Stored them in my museum. When they do request one I try to still get the bug before running to my supply.
Noticed that you get a lower item from them when you get it from your stash.

 

[Tessie]

lol no. I fail like 99% of my villagers request, I just say yes I'll do it cause they get happy but I don't ever do it

 

[rosabelle]

I used to since I wanted to see what furniture they might give me in exchange for it but now, since I'm keeping them original I don't do those favors anymore.