Clay is my favorite, but I also have Ozzie and Sherb and they're pretty cute too. But Clay and his fat little belly and his markings make him cute AND unique.
I'm partial to Derwin because he was in my NL town, and I think he's adorable, but he's not necessarily like designed cute if that makes sense- I chose Sherb though because Sherb is a cute QuQ and he's my favorite other than Derwin UuU
I'm going to give it to Beau. The bug talk is a little weird but since his house is literally a meadow, I think it actually fits really well! Also he's adorable!
I needed to vote for 3 - Beau, Bob and Punchy, but since I could only vote for 2 I cut Bob out. But that hurt my heart because Bob, like Punchy, is one of my earliest memories of AC, but I have Beau in my town right now and love him to death. Lucky is not my cup of tea and Sherb, while adorable, turned out to just never click with me (we won't talk about the ugly clothes I was tricked into giving him). I've also never really liked Stitches, but I do like Zucker a lot! I had him in my New Leaf town and he was adorable. I kind of miss his old shirt, though. I thought it fit his design better than the one he has now.