Who was your first Harvest Moon wife/husband?

[Mephisto Pheles]

I found out that Calvin is apparently a lot older than your character and that put me off lol

Meh. If you're old enough to marry, I don't think that sort of thing is a problem. (Muffy was like 30 in HM:AWL, if I recall..)

- - - Post Merge - - -

I don't even remember giving Muffy anything. I just went in the bar to talk to her everyday and she asked me to marry her within like a month I think.

I'll have to try that with her and Celia to see who proposes first. (I'm not even sure if my HM:AWL is even in playable condition anymore, though... It's been in storage for a few years now)

 

[n64king]

LOL @ Calvin is nasty. i like Calvin ok.

 

[Sanaki]

I liked him too but just can't anymore ya feel lol

 

[n64king]

Lol you grew apart, these things happen.

 

[debinoresu]

I love p much every hm girl but I cant deny my first love

marrying in a/wl was easy as hell tho. u could literally give the girl you want one gift then sleep through the courting season and theyd come ask you to marry them

I also married celia in DS, then flora after her, and I tried nami but saved over that file

I think I maried muffy in WL once, too. I really like muffy, I think shes one of the saddest bachelorettes there is which just makes marrying her and making her happy and **** so much better yo

ahh, a/wl. I can remember the music so clearly, it was my first hm game (tho my fav remains mfomt a/wl is close behind)

tbh magical melody had my favorite marriage candidates out of all of them tho

 

[n64king]

yuh?

 

[Mephisto Pheles]

yuh?

"Moi."​

(aside from that track, this dude is one of the things that stood out about the game for me, for some reason hahaha)

 

[RayOfHope]

Why do so many people hate Muffy for acting/looking promiscuous? lol she's pretty and she works in a bar? Or is it the red dress [that's actually pretty modest]? She's so sweet, but her story is so sad. :<

Anyway, I'm lame so I never got far enough to marry anyone yet. The closest I've ever gotten was getting all but one or two of the girls in Harvest Moon 64 to pink heart, and buying the blue feather. But I ragequit because I didn't get Karen's heart level up fast enough to get her cutscene on Fall 7. Haven't played since...

Now I have Neil up to pink in A New Beginning... but he's not my choice. Just the easiest guy to woo. He'll fall in love with you just for giving him fodder every day.

 

[Mephisto Pheles]

Why do so many people hate Muffy for acting/looking promiscuous? lol she's pretty and she works in a bar? Or is it the red dress [that's actually pretty modest]? She's so sweet, but her story is so sad. :<

Anyway, I'm lame so I never got far enough to marry anyone yet. The closest I've ever gotten was getting all but one or two of the girls in Harvest Moon 64 to pink heart, and buying the blue feather. But I ragequit because I didn't get Karen's heart level up fast enough to get her cutscene on Fall 7. Haven't played since...

Now I have Neil up to pink in A New Beginning... but he's not my choice. Just the easiest guy to woo. He'll fall in love with you just for giving him fodder every day.

Muffy being "promiscuous" isn't the problem, for me - she just acts really spoiled and... Well, let's just say that if she was an AC villager, her personality would be Snooty

As for ANB.. I had a file that I played for quite awhile (considering how long I normally play, that is. lol. I didn't even get to year 2), and was going for Tina, but.. I'm just not a big fan of the bachelors/bachelorettes in that game, for some reason. :/ They're all kinda "meh".

 

[puppy]

my first game was magical melody and it still has the best bachelors imo haha
i married kurt but i got like all the guys to max heart because i liked to keep my options open u v u

 

[Beary]

In Harvest Moon: A New Beginning, I married Neil.

 

[Hot]

Popuri in HM:FoMT. Can't really explain my thinking process because that was literally 10-11 years ago.

 

[RayOfHope]

Muffy being "promiscuous" isn't the problem, for me - she just acts really spoiled and... Well, let's just say that if she was an AC villager, her personality would be Snooty

As for ANB.. I had a file that I played for quite awhile (considering how long I normally play, that is. lol. I didn't even get to year 2), and was going for Tina, but.. I'm just not a big fan of the bachelors/bachelorettes in that game, for some reason. :/ They're all kinda "meh".

Most of the people I've seen who hate Muffy call her a whore. It gets a little tiring. :/ But spoiled, haha I can understand that.

I've barely inched my way towards Year 2. Just a few days left but it feels like such an eternity. At the same time the days feel too short to do everything that needs to be done. Really weird. The marriage candidates are pretty lackluster, honestly, I like them but they just feel like they're missing something. like maybe a deep personality They're either boringly nice or snooty.

 

[Mephisto Pheles]

Most of the people I've seen who hate Muffy call her a whore. It gets a little tiring. :/ But spoiled, haha I can understand that.

I've barely inched my way towards Year 2. Just a few days left but it feels like such an eternity. At the same time the days feel too short to do everything that needs to be done. Really weird. The marriage candidates are pretty lackluster, honestly, I like them but they just feel like they're missing something. like maybe a deep personality They're either boringly nice or snooty.

They probably only say that because of how she dresses, and how she's basically designed to be the "sexy blonde" type lol. (though imo, that doesn't make someone a "whore")

And I agree about the marriage candidates personalities in ANB.. The time thing, too.
I feel like I don't have enough time to do all my "chores" + talk to everyone before the day is over - but at the same time, the days seem to take too long to end.. I guess maybe it's due to my impatience, and wanting to "hurry up and get to a point where something new happens". lol

 

[RayOfHope]

They probably only say that because of how she dresses, and how she's basically designed to be the "sexy blonde" type lol. (though imo, that doesn't make someone a "whore")

And I agree about the marriage candidates personalities in ANB.. The time thing, too.
I feel like I don't have enough time to do all my "chores" + talk to everyone before the day is over - but at the same time, the days seem to take too long to end.. I guess maybe it's due to my impatience, and wanting to "hurry up and get to a point where something new happens". lol

Haha yeah that's usually why. I mean in that case she's nowhere near Eve from the original HM, it's weird that Muffy would be so targeted. (agreed!)

ANB is simultaneously too slow and too fast. lol it's so weird. Too much stuff to do, barely enough time to do it, and rarely anything interesting in between. That whole month before the blueprints are even unlocked? Ugghh. x_x

 

[puppy]

ANB is simultaneously too slow and too fast. lol it's so weird. Too much stuff to do, barely enough time to do it, and rarely anything interesting in between. That whole month before the blueprints are even unlocked? Ugghh. x_x

i hate waiting for someone to get done eating so i can give them a gift. who eats dinner for 4 HOURS

 

[Saylor]

Haha yeah that's usually why. I mean in that case she's nowhere near Eve from the original HM, it's weird that Muffy would be so targeted. (agreed!)

ANB is simultaneously too slow and too fast. lol it's so weird. Too much stuff to do, barely enough time to do it, and rarely anything interesting in between. That whole month before the blueprints are even unlocked? Ugghh. x_x

I felt the same way but on some days I'd go to sleep after like 4 in-game hours and others I wouldn't have enough time to do everything I wanted. I played when I was younger so I hardly paid any attention to harvesting or the animals, I just liked to walk around and talk to everyone usually haha

 

[aetherene]

I had Harvest Moon 3 GBC first so I married your farmer partner. However, as the girl, the game ends prematurely and then with the boy, it keeps going. I have yet to marry the girl super fast and in time to see the baby born. (Apparently you can have two kids.)

In FoMT, I married Mary.

And then in AnWL, I married Marlin. On another file, it was Rock. I do think Gustav's baby was the cutest though!

In Magical Melody, I married Kurt. He was pretty cute.

 

[Mephisto Pheles]

I had Harvest Moon 3 GBC first so I married your farmer partner. However, as the girl, the game ends prematurely and then with the boy, it keeps going. I have yet to marry the girl super fast and in time to see the baby born. (Apparently you can have two kids.)

In FoMT, I married Mary.

And then in AnWL, I married Marlin. On another file, it was Rock. I do think Gustav's baby was the cutest though!

In Magical Melody, I married Kurt. He was pretty cute.

Really?? Why's that?

 

[Dewy]

My first HM game was Another Wonderful Life <3
The bachelor choices pretty much sucked. There was Rock, the lazy jerk who you just know wouldn't do any work and would sit on his butt and ask you to make him a sandwich all day. Then there was Gustafa, the hairy, weed-smoking hippie who lived in a tent and never took off his John Lennon sunglasses. And finally there married Marlin, the complainy farm man with a boring personality, a perpetual cold and a serious snot/mucus problem going on.
Man that game was great :'D

I married Marlin because you had to get married otherwise the game would end.