Who gets the boot?

[Clock]

Marshal since you might have 3 smugs.
If you don’t care about balance, then Genji.

 

[Arckaniel]

I voted for Marshal because you already have a lot of smugs in your island (and O'hare is another smug) and I care about having at least one villager for each personality so I'm kinda biased on my choice lol, but it seems like you don't really care about having every personality type as you're missing an uchi atm so just choose whomever you'd like to kick out the most I guess, and in that case, just kick Genji out

 

[InstantNoodles]

Tbh I chose Kiki because I'm not a huge fan of the normal personality. Also I'm biased because I love Marshal and Genji. However, Genji doesn't really fit the theme as much - maybe you could consider getting a different jock?

 

[Squinish]

I voted for Genji. Nothing against them just that I felt they fit less among who you already have and are getting. To me Marshal has to stay because of Raymond. Maybe it's the fandom or just that I thing they are perfect best buds. Don't know. Raymond, Marshal and Sherb are my Rat Pack boys. So, it could be that as well. ;P

Kiki is right there with Punchy. They are classics and fit very well together. Your avatar's name is also Kiki. So, it's a given there. ;P Just like Coco and my avatar, Coco. I just have to get her one day. Coco needs her Coco. ;P

----------------

I love all these "I might be bios" thoughts. I say to them, "Don't be ashamed of being bias." I mean really. The OP is asking this to see others views on this. I did the same thing about who to get rid of, Whitney or Skye. It's nice to see others prospective on why they would choose the way they did.

In the end. Alway.... ALWAYS, pick who you really want. Who you like. No matter if it's 10 Smug or a well balanced village. Design it the way you want. You live on this island. No one else does (well unless you let others live on your island. Still, you be you and get who you want. ;P

 

[Toasties]

I'd personally keep Genji if he is your only jock and you want all of the personality types, including if you're still missing emotes and diys. But that is up to you! It's hard picking who you want. I voted out Kiki personally but probably Marshal to avoid having 3 smugs.

 

[Koi Fishe]

Kiki's eyes have always haunted me o_o

 

[JeffreyAC]

I vote for non-cat Kiki

 

[Rosie977]

Thanks for the votes everyone! Ive chosen to move out Genji!

 

[AntiJupiter]

I really never understood the hype around Marshal, he's just a white squirrel lmao. I'd keep the other 2, they seem much more interesting - design wise.