who has been in your town the longest? Cole and Bonbon have been in my town since I started my game which is okay I guess, they're not my dreamies or anything but I don't know how I would feel about them moving out at this point.
I just could never let her go. I don't quite remember if she was one of the first villagers or one of the first move ins, but she's been here since I started
Bob and Sly have been in my town since around when I first started my game. I sometimes think it would be nice to see a different villager, but then I feel like I would miss them and I always tell them not to move.
I've had my town from Jan 1st and Clay, Gigi and Goose have been with me from the beginning. Clay's never leaving and I'm thinking of keeping Goose too. Stitches and Wolfgang are the oldest villagers in my other town.
My oldest villager in my main town is Eugene who was the first villager to move in after I made the town. The oldest villagers in my other two towns are Ed and Margie.
I got really lucky with my random move-ins in Feldspar. Walt, Willow, Snake, Lionel, and Benjamin are all random move-ins from the start of the game (or original 5 villagers) that I just couldn't let go.
Deena and Cheri have been around since I first created my town. I'm not letting them go, even though I'm not really fond of the place Cheri plotted her house in. :/