Who are your favorite non-mainstream villagers?

[Rosewater]

Rolf
Olivia
Kitty
Maddie
Purrl
Snake
Tangy
Bunnie
Phoebe
Bea
Fuchsia
Freya
Chrissy
Maple
Poppy

 

[Pixiebelle]

I'm not sure if these count but Ellie, Margie and Carrie!

 

[Blueskyy]

wondering if you guys like any dog villagers besides lucky, cherry, goldie who seem to be the most popular?

I like Bones. I never remember to move him in but he’s a cute dog.

 

[VelveteenCat]

wondering if you guys like any dog villagers besides lucky, cherry, goldie who seem to be the most popular?

Biskit is pretty cute! If he weren't the same personality as Lucky, he might be a dreamie for me. Recently I had Shep as a random move-in, but I'm not sure about him yet.
I'm one of the people who love Cherry and Lucky.

Otherwise, I like these underrated villagers:
- Annalisa
- Groucho
- Pate
- Tabby
- Olaf
- Chops
- Monique

 

[Bcat]

I love Shep and Mira they’re my besties

 

[Brecht]

I love Maelle She is so lovely and sweet.. Wouldn't harm a fly and she is so involved with you.

 

[otterboi]

Deli (Lazy Monkey) is my favorite villager by far but nobody seems to talk about him. Agnes is also great

 

[issh0mans]

tiffany! she just looks like such a ***** i love her lmao​

 

[pocky]

Mott! Also ugly villagers like Katt, Jambette, and Tabby

 

[SarahsNY]

Alice and Walker! They were the only villagers to give me their pictures in WW, and have been my favorites ever since.

 

[moonolotl]

I don't think Lopez is commonly traded? i love him so much!
Pashmina's a little less mainstream too and shes probably my absolute favourite
Honorable mentions are Elvis and Simon since they were in my new leaf town and I like them a lot, even though I don't know if I'd have them on my island.

 

[JKDOS]

Mitzi - Tier C
Graham - Tier D
Al - Tier D

I am working on getting Tybalt in my town as my jock. He isn't too bad. His tier..."Untiered"

I'm guessing people really hate jocks, because I'd rank Tybalt above Al, and maybe Graham.

 

[Master Mage]

Peck

 

[Sudsofsplash]

O'Hare, I don't get how he isn't more popular?? He's definitely one of the better smugs

O'hare is so CUTE!!! I love him! I had him in New Leaf and I have him in New Horizons, when I found him on an island I nearly cried !!

 

[kylie32123]

Hazel! She was one of my first villagers when I started playing New Leaf back in 2013. I was new to the animal crossing scene and didnt know much about it at that time. Hazel was always so nice and sweet to me whenever I talked to her! She was my favorite then and always will be. Sadly, like I said, I didnt know much about animal crossing at that time, so when i stopped playing for a few weeks and came back, she was gone. I was heartbroken. I havent been able to get her back since and im hoping on either trading to get her or just getting her amiibo

 

[ayeeprill]

SYLVANA

Poppy gets all the normal squirrel love. But Sylvana is absolutely adorable, has such a nice palette, and a gorgeous house! Plus she's stinking ADORABLE.

 

[Megina]

MADDIE!
She is my precious angel ;v;
I was surprised that she's not as high on the tier list as some others...

She's peppy.
But dangit... She is amazing...

 

[mewshine]

Tabby, always! But she seems to be getting a bit more love nowadays (yay!), ones I REALLY don’t see any love for are Limberg, Cashmere, and Caesar... I’ve got big soft spots for those three, I think when people go for crankies or snooties they go for more conventionally cute ones to balance out the personality, but I kinda like them rough around the edges in terms of looks too! Wish I saw more fan content of them!

 

[Loubelle]

I love Derwin owo For a long time in NL i wanted him gone, and he just would never leave, and eventually he grew on me, and he is someone I plan on having as my lazy villager in NH

 

[Arithmophobia17]

Bella, Rod, and Tasha are my smol lil babies... they're so cute and sweet i love them