Who are your favorite non-mainstream villagers?

[Figment]

Does Midge count? I can't believe she isn't more popular. I guess that's a testament to how cute the Normal villagers are.

Also, Sprinkles. I feel like I see more people who have her than I see who have Midge, but she deserves all the love.

As far as villagers who I NEVER see mentioned, I had Gloria and Jay in New Leaf and I really miss them.

 

[condor]

Annalise or Kitty as a snooty villager. Papi as a lazy. Bill or Poncho for jocks.

Seconding Kitty!

 

[Blueskyy]

Dr.Raddle deserves more love!

My sister’s roommate just found Raddle on and island and she texted me saying, LOOK AT THIS VILLAGER WITH A MASK ON ITS MOUTH!” Except it wasn’t in all caps. I dunno why I did that.

 

[peachp1t]

hmm,,, does ketchup count??? i love her but idk how popular she is

 

[soomi]

I love love love Boomer

He is the cutest little sweetie pie and I wish I could get a hug from him IRL. Lol. I’m honestly surprised he’s not popular. He’s my lil puffy penguin!

 

[Unserioes]

Purrl!!!
She was one of my starter Villagers in Wild World. At first I kinda hated her because she was always super mean to me, like one time i remember showing my IRL friend one of her letters that said something among the lines of: "Do you really think i care about the stuff you're blabbering?" and me and my friend just sat there with open mouthes hahaha

Over time she became more and more friendly tho and she was the first one to give me her photo frame!

This made me actually buy her amiibo and now shes on my island, happy to have her back

 

[Le Ham]

Guess I can't say Melba anymore, she used to be more hidden, but she is normal anyway and she's basically koala Maple

Billy is a great jock. He's this funny old-looking goat and I wonder if he's the reason I'm not as annoyed of the jock personality type as many other people are.

Yknow, I've never had Astrid and for all I know she could come off as mean, but she does have an interesting appearance ngl. Walt is another kangaroo I think could use a little more appreciation. The kangaroos in general aren't very loved lol

As far as cats go, I'm a little perplexed why I don't see Felicity up there often, she's one of the cuter ones imo. But maybe I'm not paying attention

 

[Mattician]

Iggly

He was one of my starting five in New Leaf. Then he was one of my starting two in New Horizons. I'm keeping him.

 

[chainosaur]

Guess I can't say Melba anymore, she used to be more hidden, but she is normal anyway and she's basically koala Maple

Billy is a great jock. He's this funny old-looking goat and I wonder if he's the reason I'm not as annoyed of the jock personality type as many other people are.

Yknow, I've never had Astrid and for all I know she could come off as mean, but she does have an interesting appearance ngl. Walt is another kangaroo I think could use a little more appreciation. The kangaroos in general aren't very loved lol

As far as cats go, I'm a little perplexed why I don't see Felicity up there often, she's one of the cuter ones imo. But maybe I'm not paying attention

Felicity is adorable, I had her in my NL town and she was a sweetie pie. Definitely underrated to be sure.

 

[Feferily]

Renee and Melba!

 

[Spunki]

Pretty much all of the Koalas. I love Gonzo and Yuka. Why are they most of the time avoided? I don’t have any problems with their Nose.

Otherwise Anabelle, Benjamin, some underrated Penguins like Wade, Boris, Cranston, Del, Drake, Elvis or any of the Lions at all (yeah I know, they have weird flat faces, but I wouldn’t consider them that bad), Frank, any of the bigger Bears (Grizzly, Groucho, Curt, Ike, Pinky etc.), Hamphrey.

Just to many Villagers and only 1 Island.

wondering if you guys like any dog villagers besides lucky, cherry, goldie who seem to be the most popular?

Butch, Bones, Walker, Benjamin, Bea are all cute.

 

[lieryl]

Klaus literally has the cutest grumpy face and he’s a gladiator T^T he needs love

 

[naranjita]

He's a lazy, but Papi is just absolutely adorable and he's hardly ever mentioned. He's super unique too! Definitely far from mainstream (though he should be )

It still boggles my mind that Colton is relatively low on tier lists. He's one of the cutest Smugs? Hello? Mitzi being lower also surprises me, I always thought she was one of the best Normals. I love her color scheme and her face.

Papi I think it also an underrated Lazy, I had him for a time in NL and he was great. Cousteau and Mott are also great Jocks that people sleep on, but I guess that's just me.

came here to say Papi and Colton! I have Papi on my island and I'm hoping to get Colton eventually. they're both so unique and it's such a shame that people don't talk about them more often!

 

[chainosaur]

came here to say Papi and Colton! I have Papi on my island and I'm hoping to get Colton eventually. they're both so unique and it's such a shame that people don't talk about them more often!

I will talk about Colton all day everyday if someone lets me, hahaha. And okapis are just naturally cute, so Papi is, as expected, mega cute! I'm glad other people appreciate them ~

 

[lana.]

I like Melba, I think she is really cute and underrated!

 

[chriss]

Hamphrey was one of my top 3 favorite villagers in new leaf. In this game I think he's become my favorite. He is one of the funniest villagers. I love that face.

 

[cheezu]

Peggy is my gem and I don't see her mentioned AT ALL.
I also really like Henry, Tad, Maddie, Mac (he looks like a pug which is my favorite dog breed), Bea and Monique.

 

[Spunki]

Tad

Speaking of Frogs, I like his squiggly Mouth a lot. But being a Jock is sometimes such a Pain. I wished he was lazy. Lol

 

[Envy]

Cleo
Annalise
Vivian
Purrl
Colton
Bea
Butch
Jay
Ed (really doesn't deserve the hate he gets)
Queenie
Fuschia

 

[hikaricities]

Klaus literally has the cutest grumpy face and he’s a gladiator T^T he needs love

some love for Klaus!!! finally ; ^ ; he is so underrated he's my favorite smug! love his gladiator concept and his house is beautiful!
Also want to mention Flip, Willow, Felicity, and Ketchup! Although I feel like Willow, Felicity and Ketchup do get a decent amount of love since I've seen some people mention them in this thread Flip (and Klaus) is pretty underrated though. I feel like he deserves a lot more love! All the monkey villagers do imo. But Flip is super cute and a great jock. He loves to sing too! It's adorable.