Whitney or Skye! Who will be voted off the island?

[Squinish]

Well, the votes won't dictate but it might help me decided.

Ok, I currently have 3 wolves on my island. Whitney, Skye and Audie. Audie is definitely going. I am not fan of her, but I will get her photo. I treat all my villagers good now that I want there pictures. ;P

Still, I have to make room for others that I do want. I decided I only want 1 wolf. It's just so hard to decide between the two though.

Skye! I have had Skye longer and she is adorable. She is fun and quirky. I have noticed that Skye likes to sing more then Whitney (but Whitney is still new). Skye is the younger of the two, that is for sure. Always wide eyed at the wonders of the world. Dancing and singing and always happy.

Whitney! What can I say. She is elegant. I feel Whitney is possibly the most pure representation of elegance and grace in this game. There are a lot of characters with her personality or a lot of the same qualities, but I think Whitney personifies the classy sophisticated woman.

Why would I choose Skye over Whitney? Skye's youthful energy is infectious. Just watching her bounce to the beat of some music playing or starring wide eyed at a passing butterfly. She is like a child, curious at everything. Very Cute!

Why would I choose Whitney over Skye? Skye is cute, but not unique at all. There are a plethora of cute, youthful villagers to choose from. While Whitney, you are hard pressed to find another villager with the same level of elegant beauty and class.

It's so hard to choose but I will choose one of them. There is no sudden, "Why not keep both since you like them both so much." This will happen.


So, if you had to choose between the two of them. Who would you choose?

Thanks for voting.

 

[seularin]

for preference i'd go with skye ; i think she suits your villagers well--and i always see whitney around ajsdjh

 

[Cosmic-chan]

*insert total drama Island music* I vote whitney

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

I personally prefer Whitney, but they're both super cute!

 

[Squinish]

for preference i'd go with skye ; i think she suits your villagers well--and i always see whitney around ajsdjh

Aww but would you change that if you knew that I plan to get rid of 4 of the villagers from the group. Sky/Whiney is one of them. Audie, Dom and Lolly are the other 3.

While I absolutely love Lolly Kitten. She is not part of the master plan... yet. She might be the last to leave. I plan to eventually add Coco and Ruby to the island. I also plan to get back Tangy (lost to get Raymond but also so I could get her original house). This will leave 1 spot open that is yet decided. It might be Lolly but I plan to get the picture of everyone of my favorite villagers. All 63 of them. So I will need at least 1 empty house for a while.

Just for kicks. Here is my Favorite Villagers List.

Favorite Villagers by squinish | Animal Crossing Item and Villager Database - VillagerDB

View Favorite Villagers, a list by squinish containing 65 items

villagerdb.com

 

[BalloonFight]

Whitney gets my vote. I'm biased though as she's my favorite wolf. I love Skye's color, but her eyes just have something slightly off.

 

[Blueskyy]

I had Skye and she was forgettable, but cute. Whitney is just bland. Vivian and Freya are more appealing to me, and there are way more appealing snooties out there.

 

[Squinish]

I had Skye and she was forgettable, but cute. Whitney is just bland. Vivian and Freya are more appealing to me, and there are way more appealing snooties out there.

Oh, I agree that there are better snooty. My favorite villagers is Ankha. So that proves that statement right there. ;P I do like Freya, but I still find Whitney to be a better under what I view she represents. That's why there are so many villagers to choose from. Cause there are so many likes and styles to meet almost everyone's needs.

 

[brangein]

Skye, sounds to me you just like her more.

 

[Clock]

This so hard, but I pick Skye since you had her for the longest. But Whitney is a second option I pick since there is also more nicer snootys even though I like her.

 

[Fye]

I like Whitney better so I votes for Skye, but if you're looking for other similar snooties I'd recommend Diana and Blanche. They both give me the same elegant vibes Whitney does. Good luck with your decision!

 

[aloherna]

I think Skye is a better fit, she looks more unique.

 

[moon_child]

Whitney for me because Skye is a normal personality and that personality pool has like 20 other cute ones that I like better than Skye whereas Whitney is on my top snooty list along with Judy (my nebula baby) and Diana.

 

[Insulaire]

I reject this choice. Keep both and leave your own island

 

[Alicia]

I have Whitney on my island and I really like her, so I voted for Skye.

 

[Squinish]

I reject this choice. Keep both and leave your own island

I can't argue with this logic. Oh well, goodbye everyone. Off I the island I go. *SPLOOSH*

~Futures Sight~ Soon the island falls into disarray and ruin as everyone comes to realize the only person that earned money, built anything and kept the island in good shape. Had jumped into the sea and swam away. The Villagers, Nook and Issabella surround and tie Whitney and Skye to boats and push them out to see in hopes to what ever gods they pray in that I will return and save them. ;P

Or.... they will be perfectly fine with out me. Hmmm, probably that. ;P

Post automatically merged: May 30, 2020

I have Whitney on my island and I really like her, so I voted for Skye.

I love this. "Oh I have Whitney. Ya she's great. Best pup. Makes me breakfast in the morning. A real pillar of the community and everyone loves her. Ya, no one better..... I vote for Skye!" ;P

I may have exaggerated a little there.

 

[samticore]

skye has the cuter snoot

 

[Xara]

i love them both but i’d choose skye ;w;

 

[AccfSally]

Ahh, I read the broad wrong and voted off poor Skye.
I don't even like Whitney (all the other female wolves are better than her)....

 

[EmperorGandhi]

If you're looking for a snooty that really radiates "elegance", I have Julia on my island currently and she fits that bill very well. I agree that Whitney embodies it, but Julia might be the next best thing. Diana's also a great option in that regard, but I've never had her.

I'd vote out Whitney because I think there's plenty of snooties out there that could at least come close to giving you the same vibe, plus Skye is incredibly cute and one of my favorite normal villagers.