Whitney or Diana, what would you do?

[LinkToTheWorld]

I have Whitney in my town now, I was very lucky as she is an original dreamie and a kind persons on here was giving her away for free.
I do love her and her design, but I've found I also really want Diana. She's in a friends town currently as a permanent and I just think she's so lovely.
I do enjoy changing my villagers up now and then, seeing as I have so many dreamies I'd like to experience. I just don't want to end up regretting letting her go, I'm just wondering what people think. Preferably somebody who has experienced both of these villagers to say who they prefer.

My villagers are all in my signature and I was also wondering if Diana would fit in with them. Or if she's too pretty/elegant.

Any help with this decision would be appreciated. My son would love Whitney in his town so it wouldn't be like I would never be able to see her again....I don't know

 

[Sdj4148]

You should try Diana! If you still be able to see Whitney, then having Diana would be the best of both worlds. Also, in my opinion, Whitney is kind of fancy as well, so I think that Diana would fit in your town.

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

You should try Diana! If you still be able to see Whitney, then having Diana would be the best of both worlds. Also, in my opinion, Whitney is kind of fancy as well, so I think that Diana would fit in your town.

That's what I'm leaning towards at the minute, especially seeing as I won't lose her entirely. Plus if I wanted her in my other town I'm sure I could bribe my son to give her back to me

 

[HungryForCereal]

why not have both? i have diana in my second town and i love seeing her everyday because i love the pastel color on her. i would replace whitney with diana if i were you. whitney is plain imo.

 

[tae]

i'd keep whitney, but that's because i don't like diana and i think she's boring and overrater.

 

[Tikikata]

I'm pretty biased because I love AC wolves, but I think if you really want to try Diana, go for it!

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

I also love the wolves the octopi are my favourite, then wolves then deer....I wish I had an extra space for both of them I did think about that, but I wouldn't know who else I could let go. All my current villagers are my original dreamies (except Zell who I lost accidently ).
Although Marina has been with me a while so maybe I could let her go to my sons town instead and keep both. I would have 2 octopi, 4 deer and 4 wolves then....which I guess isn't such a bad ratio.
I'd really love to get her in my town one way or another. Think I've decided that much now at least
Thank you for all your replies by the way! I appreciate them

 

[survivorfan111100]

Hard decision but I would choose Diana since her house is perfect for her and she plays Stale Cupcakes <3

 

[Belle of Pripyat]

i'd keep whitney, but that's because i don't like diana and i think she's boring and overrater.

I feel the same way. Diana was in my campsite a week or two ago and I don't see what all the fuss is about. Whitney is beautiful, though.

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

She is beautiful with those blue eyes and white fur....and she fits in so well! I'm thinking I'll probably let Marina go for Diana, since she's been with me for quite a while, longer than anybody else I've got. And she might be easier to let go of than Whitney. Plus I still have Skye as my normal villager....
Then I could have both Diana and Whitney !
Thanks for all your opinions!