Which villager messed up my bridge? DEVELOPMENTS

[Leebles]

I've been replacing my old cobblestone bridges with brick ones lately. I demolished the one in front of town hall yesterday, and this morning I tried to tell Isabelle to build the new one. She said she couldn't do that, even though a bridge had been there for months, because it was too close to a villager's house.

That bridge is in such an important spot that I probably have to kick out whoever moved in too close to it. Do you guys think it's Skye, or Marshal?



I can't remember if I already had the bridge when Marshal moved in - probably not - but I know Skye definitely moved in after construction. I really don't want to get rid of either of them, though.

EDIT: I moved Skye out (accidentally losing wonderful Baabara in trying to do so) and Isabelle still wouldn't let me build the damn bridge. I'm reaching a despair point here because the next to have to move out would be Marshal, then Cally. I really don't want to trade Marshal away, but if I didn't move him and get the bridge built, it would be like I lost Skye for nothing. I'm considering rebooting my town and getting a fresh start, but the idea of losing all those bugs and fish I caught, all those PWP suggestions...That seems really upsetting too. What would you guys do in my shoes?

 

[Zanessa]

Might be Skye.

 

[Leebles]

Might be Skye.

I guess it's better having to replace her than Cally because people would want to do a trade.

 

[Nelly]

I think it might be Skye, her house looks closer to the water.

 

[Itachi]

Def Skye, but Marshals could be a problem too :x very bad luck when it comes to the villagers you have to let go..

 

[Tanyana]

Based on the photo, it looks to me like Skye lives closer to the river than the other, but I might be wrong.

If you decide that Skye needs a new home, I would love to give him an everlasting home at my town

 

[Leebles]

Based on the photo, it looks to me like Skye lives closer to the river than the other, but I might be wrong.

If you decide that Skye needs a new home, I would love to give him an everlasting home at my town

I appreciate the offer, but if I did move her out I'd probably want a trade to help stabilize my town. I want to keep random move-ins at bay.

 

[beffa]

Looks like Skye's the problem.

 

[Mary]

I'm almost positive it's Skye.

 

[FireNinja1]

Skye. Marshal's too far out.

 

[Lurrdoc]

I would need an actual picture or video of the distances from their house to the bridge location you wish to put it at. On the map, both look like they could be in the way.

 

[NightFlame750]

has to be skye. sorry....

 

[Frozen]

It could be both. Marshal might look like he's not as close, but sometimes it can still be too close.

 

[Summ3rain]

I agree it may be both it would be awful if you moved Skye out and still couldn't build your bridge
I'm stuck with ugly bridges and dare not demolish anything stupid rule

 

[Leebles]

Sorry if resurrecting this thread wasn't okay but there are new developments I put in the first post and ugh. So sad.

 

[Static Spark]

My personal advice would be to just ignore building a third bridge back altogether. Your middle bridge is pretty close to where you want to build the bridge, I wouldn't say it's a huge loss. Shame that you lost Skye in the process, though :< I would never restart my file for anything, let alone one tiny PWP, haha.