Which snooty should go?

[Dewy]

Yep, it's another one of these threads hah

My snooties are Diana, Vivian, and as of today JUDY! I'm am super excited about Judy and she is definitely staying. A very kind person gave her to me for free and she has been my #1 dreamie since this game released.

Now I have to decide if I want to keep Diana and/or Vivian. Or get rid of them both.
I just found Vivian on a Nook island the other day and I was pretty excited about it because I think she's a cutie and I've never seen her in-game before. I'm getting to know her and so far the I like her a lot!
Diana I found on a Nook island about a month ago. I had her in my New Leaf town and I wasn't planning on having her in New Horizons... But when I saw her on that island I knew I had to take her. I think she is so so beautiful and I love her pastel, gentle design. Plus she's a deer villager, and I'm so in love with the deer villagers.
I also think she looks pretty good with Judy, in terms of color and design (not that I'm really going for a theme with my villagers or anything).

What would you do in my shoes? Keep Diana, Vivian, or neither?

I definitely don't want to keep all three. That's a little too much sass on one island for me.



vs.

 

[kojuuro]

Ooooh they're both really cute, so that's a tough choice. I chose Diana though because you had her in NL and didn't plan on having her on your island. They're all amazing tbh, but 3 snooties is a lot!

 

[Hay]

Do you like Faunas design? I like the deer's too so I say find a different deer and kick Diana, sadly :c shes a qt!

 

[Strong Badam]

I think Diana's style/color palette is rather similar to Judy's (at least more similar than Vivian), so if you wanted variety I would get rid of Diana and keep Vivian. But Diana is certainly more popular overall. I'd be curious what the species loadout of your island is too, it helps me make decisions. I only have Freya + Audie as a "doubling up" of species and every other villager is of unique species. Like another commenter stated, Fauna may make a better Deer villager. My deer is Beau.

 

[Dewy]

Do you like Faunas design? I like the deer's too so I say find a different deer and kick Diana, sadly :c shes a qt!

I actually had Fauna in NL as well! And.. now I have her on my island too.. It is exactly the same thing as what happened with Diana. I saw her on a Nook island and couldn't say no lol.
I plan on getting rid of Fauna, though. I might look for Bruce or Zell to get my deer fix haha

 

[tombook]

keep vivi

 

[senbeiiscool]

I've had both Vivian and Diana so I know both are amazing! I feel like you seem to prefer Diana more though so as sad as it is, I would choose to get rid of Vivian. But I think for variety, Vivian is a great choice!

 

[Hay]

I actually had Fauna in NL as well! And.. now I have her on my island too.. It is exactly the same thing as what happened with Diana. I saw her on a Nook island and couldn't say no lol.
I plan on getting rid of her, though. I might look for Bruce or Zell to get my deer fix haha

Omg you gotta control yourself girl!! Haha jk c: Ive had a really time passing up my NL villagers! I ran into Goldie and sat staring at my tv for like 10 minutes deciding if I want her.. Its hard to leave them :c

Anyway, I like Bruce a lot! Ive always had a soft spot for crankies and I love blue

 

[Dewy]

Omg you gotta control yourself girl!! Haha jk c: Ive had a really time passing up my NL villagers! I ran into Goldie and sat staring at my tv for like 10 minutes deciding if I want her.. Its hard to leave them :c

Anyway, I like Bruce a lot! Ive always had a soft spot for crankies and I love blue

LOL you're right, I have no control on Nook Islands

As soon as I see a villager that I evenly remotely like, I think to myself "no, I can't leave them here or no one will love them. I must give them a home"

 

[Hay]

LOL you're right, I have no control on Nook Islands

As soon as I see a villager that I evenly remotely like, I think to myself "no, I can't leave them here or no one will love them. I must give them a home"

I had to leave Bob and it was AWFUL! Hes sooo cute :c I hope you get lucky and find Bruce on your island hopping soon (when you go island hopping haha)! <3

 

[Dewy]

I had to leave Bob and it was AWFUL! Hes sooo cute :c I hope you get lucky and find Bruce on your island hopping soon (when you go island hopping haha)! <3

oh man, I couldn't have done it
and thank you! I wanted him in new leaf but never got him so maybe it's meant to be

 

[Hay]

oh man, I couldn't have done it
and thank you! I wanted him in new leaf but never got him so maybe it's meant to be

Its so meant to be!!! c:

 

[Zura]

Vivian is IMO a boring character and Diana's colors are bleh. Judy is an absolute queen so id say her and nobody else

 

[starlightsong]

Oh man, I love Diana and she looks so cute together with Judy but Vivian is also so underrated and has a gorgeous design! Maybe you could keep both temporarily to decide which one you prefer? Otherwise, I’d say probably keep Diana because you just seem more attached to her!

 

[Aleigh]

I have the exact same situation with Julian as you do Diana. He was in my NL town and I wasn't planning on having him on my island since I didn't wanna carry too many of my NL dreamies into NH, but I found him on an island (I wasn't even island hopping, literally first ticket) and I thought it was fate. I took him home and now he's staying. So I get it if you don't want to let her go. However, my vote goes to kicking Diana. I am biased though. I love Vivian so much. She was Whitney's replacement when that loser left Neveland without telling me, and I grew to love her.

tldr; kick Diana

 

[brockbrock]

I've never been a big fan of Diana, personally. I would either choose a less common snooty or go with Vivian!

 

[Clock]

I would say Diana since you already have her in your NL town.

 

[Xara]

based on the way you talked about diana and vivian, i would boot vivian as you seem to like diana more ;u;

 

[Dewy]

Oh man, I love Diana and she looks so cute together with Judy but Vivian is also so underrated and has a gorgeous design! Maybe you could keep both temporarily to decide which one you prefer? Otherwise, I’d say probably keep Diana because you just seem more attached to her!

yeah, I think I'm going to keep all three snooties for a bit and see which ones I get most attached to.
Thanks everyone!

 

[Blueskyy]

I voted Diana. I am a fan of her colors, but I’ve passed up Vivian twice and would love to give her a chance someday. I just have no room for her now that Ketchup duck is moved in! Therefore, I voted Diana off the island.