Which smug should I pick?

[CaramelCookie]

Now that Hamphrey is finally moving (yay! ;v; ) I have a space which I need to fill in with a smug so my town has all personalities.
I narrowed down to 4 choices, each having it's pros and cons:

Leopold: I like his design and teacher-like house, which fits my teacher human character. But his house cannot be close to the human, as there's no space available and I already have another Lion, Rex.

Colton: I think he's rather nice and fits my town theme, no strong feeling for him or the horse species though.

Beardo: His design and house are awesome, but I already have 2 other bears (Chow and Pinky) and maybe 3's a bit too much.

O'Hare: I like that he's Brazilian in the Japanese version, also his design is kinda cute. Not a fan of his house or English name though, and I also already have another rabbit, Francine.

So which should I pick?
Thank you!

 

[Tora Olafsdotter]

I would go with Leopold. That way you can have both amiibo Lions together

 

[Alienfish]

I'd say Beardo because he has a quite.. distinct appearance but yeah I agree with species being a bit too much maybe.

And yeah I hate that they changed O'Hare?s name, like wth man lol. So either of those still though. Not a fan of the tiger/leopards and eh, horses can be bland

 

[mitfy]

i'd say choose colton! you might get more of an opinion on him after getting to know him better, and his design is real nice. my next choice would probably be leopold, then beardo, then o'hare.

 

[HappyTails]

I like Colton. He has that boy band look going on. I also like Beardo. He's cute too.

 

[amazonevan19]

I am a fan of O'Hare. He was in my town and I liked his house. A well-designed smug IMO

Beardo would be my second pick from that list

 

[Sweetley]

I would give Colton a chance. He's a nice villager and maybe when you spend some time with
him you start to like him more. As another choice, I would say Beardo.

 

[chibibunnyx]

I had beardo in a previous town, hes alright. But I would probably pick colton! c:

 

[Kalle]

Go with Leopold. I had him as a jock in the original AC on Gamecube and missed him after he moved. Not too many people tend to pick him either, so that might be a bonus for you?

 

[Nunnafinga]

I have Colton,Beardo and O'Hare and I like all three but for your purposes,I'd get Colton.I didn't really like any of the horse villagers until I got Colton and it might turn out the same for you.He's been a lot of fun.

 

[Cascade]

I'd pick O' Hare

 

[5cm/s]

i have o'hare in town and he's a total flirt- i love him
he also has a cute lil hat on, so that's another selling point

 

[CaramelCookie]

Still indecisive! >_<
I have a horse in my second town, Annalise.
Argg... at this point, I might as well write their names on paper and do a draw ;v;

 

[Voldecourt]

I would personally go with Colton. He's so sweet looking! And I feel like he's overshadowed a lot by a certain other smug horse. I really do like Colton's design. Eventually I'll have him in a town.

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

I'm not a huge fan of any of them, but I'd say go with Colton because he's so majestic-looking.

 

[CaramelCookie]

Thanks for the help and opinions, guys! I'll go with the poll result and pick Colton. I did meet him on HHD and liked him there, let's see how he'll fit in town.

 

[Daysie]

I would pick O'Hare, I like his little hat.