Which makes the better villager?

[Aleigh]

I'm going to be making a new town, kind of a "scary" themed town, and I've got all of my villagers picked out, except for one. I was thinking either Cherry or Octavian, but I can't choose. What do you think?

So far, I have the following:
Lucky
Marcel
Ankha
Tabby
Coco
Pietro
Rasher
Ribbot
Stitches

 

[Rubylena]

Both fit, I voted for octavian because I just think octopuses are creepy in real life and so there should be one in every creepy town xD

 

[leftTBT]

---

 

[MillySoSilly]

I voted for something else because I, personally, don't like either of them. I had both of them in my town and egh, nothing special. Although, I'd lean towards Cherry more. Just slightly. Good luck!

 

[ZebraQueen]

Cherry actually has a 'goth' look to her, so I'd pick her. Octavian just looks like a standard jock to me.

Since when octavian was jock? He cranky

- - - Post Merge - - -

I voted for octavian just because he face look more serious

 

[Chicha]

I picked Cherry because of her goth look she has going on. I would consider Bella because of her skull shirt and she has a pretty scary look to me haha. I think Kiki would also be a good fit as well. Anyway, good luck! Sounds like a pretty neat idea.

 

[Koden]

I feel like neither of them really fit into that kind of theme, try picking someone else? .w.

 

[BuckOfTheFawns]

I picked Cherry. You don't have an uchi villager in that list anywhere.

Also, if your theme is creepy/scary, Stitches honestly wouldn't go well in there.

 

[leftTBT]

---

 

[Aleigh]

I picked Cherry. You don't have an uchi villager in that list anywhere.

Also, if your theme is creepy/scary, Stitches honestly wouldn't go well in there.

I just kinda picked Stitches because of her look, the stitched teddy bear feels creepy in some ways lmao

 

[Soda Fox]

I chose Cherry! I love her goth style and I think she would fit with your town.

 

[xInfiniteStars]

Cherry looks a bit scary, with her spiderweb shirt and gothic look.

 

[Razpup]

neither really fit

 

[ZebraQueen]

Oh, really? hahaha, oops. I assumed he was a jock because of his appearance XP

Your the fist person I know to think that he look jock

- - - Post Merge - - -

kind of a "scary" themed town


Pietro

Please explain how pietro fits into this? He not Creepy At All
and give another reason that it's not a log people think clown are scary

 

[helloxcutiee]

Cherry is perfect for a spooky themed town.

 

[Cascade]

I think you should get Roscoe

 

[vexnir]

Cherry, Octavian doesn't really fit imo.

I've had Cherry in my old town and she can appear quite creepy if she hides behind trees and stuff. And she is really cool. Honestly, she's perfect for that kind of town.

 

[AppleBitterCrumble]

Cherry's whole look sorta makes me think she just murdered someone and never bothered to clean off the blood.

 

[BuckOfTheFawns]

I just kinda picked Stitches because of his look, the stitched teddy bear feels creepy in some ways lmao

Well I guess if you think he looks kinda scary then you can add him to your town. I just think he's the most adorable villager ever.