I like the hat better, not really sure why but I don't haave anything with the wig to be honest. I also find hats overall nice looking, and I think it fits really well with this outfit.
I also vote for the hat. I wasn't aware that wig was so popular Mine's been gathering dust since I bought it. I prefer the Tiara wig or Braided Wig.
But on a more technical note, I feel it just balances better with the outfit. The wig makes it look too...stickish up top. The width of the hat helps everything come together in a balanced fashion.
I also vote for the hat; I think it goes really well with the outfit. If you're going for a more casual look, I'd go with the floppy hat. The bow hair wig seems to go better with a more formal look than casual; though, it does look good with the outfit your character is wearing.
The floppy hat looks best. Think the hair bow wig was popular when it first came out.
I bought a lot of them for my perfect fruit town only. It helps hide all the players bed head hair from not playing a lot.