What's your favorite mystery island?

[Xara]

i loved hybrid island! it was such a nice feeling to arrive there and see all of the pink, orange and purple tulips aha. i’m lowkey still sad that nintendo removed it

but as for islands that are still available, “other fruit” island is always fun! my native fruit is peaches and so on this island, i have access to pears. pears are what i gift to my villagers while trying to get their pics and so i always like stocking up whenever i can c:

 

[John Wick]

I don't really like them as I find them redundant, apart from bamboo island.

I never would have found a scorpion if it wasn't for that island.

 

[Paperboy012305]

I have mentioned that I liked the regular 4 islands, but the ones I really love the most out of the 4 are the two that has a river with a waterfall flowing to the right (Which you can have a small pond or not) And the other that looks like a fidget spinner.

I like the first two due to the aforementioned reasonings with my first post here, but I love the fidget spinner pond island when Crawfish are gone, because that way you can fish up lots of Ranchu Goldfish which sell for 4.5k. (6.7k if sold to C.J.) You will fish up more cans than those fish however because they have been made to be rare fish, but if you have about 36 of them (Because the other stuff you’ll carry are your ladder, vaulting pole, fishing rod and NMTs if you’re looking for that specific island to hunt Sturgeon) you’ll earn 162k if sold at Nooks. But if sold by C.J. you’ll earn 243k! Now I know they’re not the best moneymaker, but it’s one of the best if you don’t do turnips.