I'm creating a full frog island, and one of my random villagers in the first three was Puddles, also first mystery island I went to ws Skye, I know she is popular but not frog.... She is on my island currently but will be replaced at some point..
On my first island which I no longer have, I had Zucker randomly move in and found Raymond on an island tour very early on. I didn't like my island though so I reset my town. I was a little bummed that I would possibly never have those guys again. But after I reset, I found Zucker on an island tour by chance, and Raymond was my first camper! Feels like destiny to have these cute boys in my town!
-Getting Audie on one of my first mystery islands
-Getting Marshal as my first camper
-Getting a hybrid island once (not that good ik)
-Getting Flurry on a mystery island
-Getting Punchy on a mystery island
-Getting Zucker on a mystery island
Yesterday my luck was insane. I was looking for Raymond or Judy (who I didn't get) but ran into Marina who I'm currently amiiboing in, Sherb AND Audie. ...Moved Audie in lmao.
Last night I found my first good mystery islands, two in a row. It was 3am, and I found the money rock island. After that, I put on my dodo shirt just to see if that rumor helped any, and I got a tarantula island. The best mystery islands I've ever gotten before this were only hybrid flower islands, so to get two new and really profitable islands in a row was really great. I don't know if it has anything to do with the dodo shirt, though.
i found audie really easily! also, managed to catch 3 stringfish in a day back when they were in season - two at my island and then one randomly at a mystery island - and a lot of coelacanths and oarfish! it was a really lucky day
My best luck was the first time I found a money island. I have tried not to look into things too much so didn't know what it was. I actually said "why is there a stone circle in my game, what is this witchcraft?"... thankfully I had presence of mind to get across to the island and smack the rocks. Once I realised it was all money I was pretty happy!
Actually have a photo of it too
My worst stroke of luck was when I saw Erik upset, and noticed an egg balloon above. I thought I'd give Erik the egg to cheer him up, and popped the balloon, breaking my slingshot.... just as the gold balloon also floated overhead