What’s the best villager you’ve turned down on a mystery island?

[TaylaJade]

Zucker on my second island for the night I still feel so bad about it. I was looking for a cat villager and got Punchy on my fifth island at least.

 

[Hsn97]

Probably Punchy. I really love Punchy, he was one of my originals back in WW. But I already have glasses cat so until he moves out another cat will have to wait to move in.

 

[marea]

Dizzy, when i was looking for the first 3 island invitees. I dont regret it now since i dont like the lazy starter house that much, and i dont want him anymore.

 

[Aliya]

Marshal. I found him a while ago and I was island hopping for someone else so I passed on him.

 

[coffee biscuit]

I turned down Sherb a couple nights ago cause I was looking for Dom. I also saw Merengue, Lolly, Zucker, Punchy, Ketchup, Whitney, Fang, Ankha, etc on the same night. I also saw Coco and again I turned her down cause I wanted to try and find Dom.. I regret it so much cause now I want her on my island ugh

I ended up just buying Dom from someone on the forums so yeah ;w; I took Sylvana home after a few stacks of tickets. She's cute but she's not a keeper.

 

[Jared:3]

People be turning Diana down, POOR SHAME!!!!

 

[Manah]

I honestly have no idea if he's popular, but Lobo. I haven't done a whoke lot of island hopping.

 

[spawnpoint]

To me Vladimir, I love him and was so upset I had to pass him

More popular ones include Dom, Beau, Punchy, Kabuki, and Wolfgang

 

[Sheando]

I kind of regret passing Boris. I love warthogs in real life and I don’t have his amiibo.

 

[Halloqueen]

I had ample opportunity to acquire Sherb and Zucker because they kept showing up on my Nook Miles Islands while I was on my search for Tucker. I could've and probably should've adopted either one of them to sell, but I stuck to my goal and kept searching for weeks until I found who I was looking for. Pretty sure I saw Audie once too. I like Audie, but she didn't fit in with my town theme, and I had no interest in the other two previously mentioned.

As for villagers I like, I passed up Boomer because a friend has him in New Horizons and I decided I'll just scan him into a New Leaf town. I also passed on Raddle because I have him in a New Leaf town.

 

[whimsycreator]

Probably Punchy. I really love Punchy, he was one of my originals back in WW. But I already have glasses cat so until he moves out another cat will have to wait to move in.

Lol reading this actually made me irrationally sad because Punchy is my personal fave... we’ve been best friends since 2011 XD

 

[N a t]

Probably Fauna or Skye. I don't know which one is more popular but I turned down both and then I settled for Sprinkle and already regret taking her in too lol. Not hate on Sprinkle or the other girls. They all cute but they don't fit into my island plans.

 

[metswee]

Sherb and Audie the other night when I was looking to fill a slot....was hoping for Pietro Rolf or Hopkins or something haha

 

[Rosch]

I've passed Dom, Octavian, Skye, Lopez, Diana, and Goldie.

I've had more encounters with high-tiered villagers doing the campsite method though.

 

[michan]

I turned down Biskit and Fauna... Since I already had Diana I wasn't too upset about Fauna. But just the fact that Al moved in randomly instead.... I regretted not getting either of those two.

 

[kojuuro]

The most popular one I've turned down is probably Sherb and Beau. I don't dislike them or anything but I have 2 lazies on my island right now and don't need another one

Other ones that were great that I wish I could've asked to move in was Tia, Fauna, Cherry and Goldie. One day I'll be able to move them all in ;__;

 

[Loriii]

I ignored Audie 3 times (already have her on my main), Judy once, and probably Diana 3 times before I gave in on the fourth time and invited her. Also Coco and Lucky. I always ignore them lol.

I feel like I've already seen most tier 1 and 2 villagers on the island except for Marshal who I've seen twice in the campsite after getting him the first time on my main island. I'm mostly using my second copy of ACNH to hunt villagers.

 

[trashpedia]

Probably Diana. I didn’t invite her because I already had Freya. It’s strange because I originally wanted her to be on my island as the one snooty villager on my island but once I had Freya I liked her more. I was looking for and uchi at the time.

Also I forgot to add that I also turned down Megan (one of the new villagers) and Ruby as well.

 

[samticore]

Stitches! He was the first one I ran into, but it didn't feel right. He's very cute and I think a lot of people like him, but he's just wasn't for me!

 

[Spunki]

Zucker, but I was not really interested and was only on my 4th Ticket, still finding another Uchi.