What’s the best villager you’ve turned down on a mystery island?

[moonbox]

Ketchup and Lucky at my campsite I was especially tortured by not getting Lucky since I loved him in WW....... I just don't have the space >____<

 

[miraxe]

I passed on Kyle (not a fan), Skye (I have her Amiibo anyway, but she's one of those villagers I'm kind of just indifferent on), and Vivian (same thing) before finally ending up with Wolfgang. My last villager run REALLY wanted me to end up with a wolf apparently. I just moved Maple out, so it's time to pass on more of other people's dreamies before finally getting to villagers I like. Sometimes I consider just moving in villagers for the sake of cycling them out, but with my luck, they'd be on my island for months before I'd finally get them to move. :d

 

[Miele]

Passed on Judy, Kyle, and Bunnie. They just weren’t my style at all. Although, I lowkey regret not inviting Kyle ;;

 

[Lavamaize]

First it was Cryano then Pierce, and a few days later I went island hoping again and saw pierce so I took him.

 

[Minimasher]

I guess Apollo is the most popular villager I've passed. Maybe Merengue actually and I have passed her multiple times. I've also passed Fang, Lolly and Blanche who I think are kind of popular

 

[Munyo]

Stitches, probably.

 

[dragonair]

I passed on Marshal which kind of hurt inside a lil but the worst was Bunnie. I already decided that I really wanted Audie when I saw her but it still hurt a lil.

 

[Ananas Dragon]

Passed on Cyd and Fauna,

Fauna hurt me internally

 

[Sharksheep]

For other people or myself? I turned down Pietro and got Phil. I don't care for either.

The next time I island hop, the first one was Marina. Easy pass for me but I know she is a lot of people's dreamy.

Next villager was Kyle and I was debating on taking him cause I had him previously and I like him more than my two current smugs. Ran into Flip that a lot of people like as their jock. Couple more island later I took home Apollo.

 

[Noctis]

Merengue. Had her in new leaf. She's nice and all but she wasn't for me but I was in the island for a long time thinking back and forth to take her or not and I just turned and walked away.

 

[Balverine]

for my it's Vivian, but I ended up getting her from someone else <3

I've seen a lot of top tier villagers, but I don't really care about them, so

 

[SarahsNY]

I found Lucky which was hard to turn down. Walker is one of my favorites already and the two are so similar, but man was I tempted!

 

[telliebelle]

i passed on judy and still regret it

 

[Damniel]

one day I used 40 tickets ran into Fauna twice. She's super cute but I already had 2 normals and couldn't handle more than that. don't regret it but she certainly was cute. I also ran into Chief twice and that was rough

 

[Garrett]

Zucker. I know he's popular but I find him so bland compared to my other lazies.

 

[Fluuffy]

Ankha. It was also on my first ticket of the day but I already had 3 snooties in my island, Blanche, Diana and Judy. Considering the game picks species first, it was super lucky to even see her.

 

[Lokidoki]

Chief, Marina, Zucker, Dobie then Poppy, i hate myself...

 

[kasane]

beau. i actually made him join, but then afterwards i quit the game without saving and he never ended up moving here since it didn't save after that interaction

i was on the hunt for zucker, i wanted to call it quits at beau but i was thinking what if the next ticket will be zucker sunk cost fallacy ugh

 

[Alicia]

I passed on a few including Sherb. Sherb is cute and I considered moving him onto my island. I already had two lazy villagers and I didn't really need a third.
Now I just have one lazy villager so Sherb probably would have been moved out either way.

Also passed on Marina and Octavian multiple times, Julian, Fang, Kyle, Freya, Molly and Merengue.

 

[senbeiiscool]

Tier wise I left Judy. I had no idea at the time that she was so popular and sought after.

Personally, it would be Kyle and Lobo