I'm just dreading the island. I know it's more fun to do with friends, but is it faster? (And I loved the Fitzgerald books, if that is what your name refers to.)
Yes it is faster, because you get extra medals depending on who did better too. But the number of fish or bugs or whatever you have to catch doubles too, but it's still more worth doing with friends. You can compensate for each other's weaknesses, boost morale, and just make it less tedious.
I got most of the gold badges that don't require a lot of effort just through playing the game too much, still working on Dreamer badge and Diver badge (who is gonna dive that much, seriously .-.)
A lot of the ones that seem impossible, like the dreams, or medals etc....if you do a few a day, it'll add up. For example, if you have 10-15 dreams every day, you'll be surprised how quickly you can get there. You only have to go in and out, unless a town looks interesting and you want to explore it.