Morrowind. The combat system was a total turnoff at the beginning, but it ended up being one of the best aspects of the game. The magic is so complex and fun. I really liked levitating and creating my own spells and enchantments.
Animal Crossing New Leaf. Me and a friend when we were like, 7 would play on our 3DS' together in a community center after a kids theater class. When mine had died I would watch her play Yo-Kai Watch and I was obsessed, so then one day she said "I'm going to play Animal Crossing". I thought the name sounded stupid and I was all like "that game sounds boring" and then I watched her play it and after a while I started to like it. I got the game soon after and I'm glad I did.