was your first painting real or fake?

[brockbrock]

Like a lot of people have already mentioned, the first painting is always real. I'm curious what paintings everyone got, though. I got the twinkling painting! Since the one I got is always authentic, I didn't even have to worry about it being a fake.

I got the scary painting. I'm lucky too that it has a counterfeit I now don't have to be worried about.

 

[Fantasyland]

I got ol veggie nose as my first! I actually followed the ACNL guide, assuming it'd be around the same... I caution anyone else doing that. I got the... Egyptian lady with a big hat? And her hat was the right shape, not the fake shape like in ACNL, but it turned out to be fake! I think her earring was wrong? I can't even tell!!! Sorry to get a little off topic but I'm stressed!

 

[Lazaros]

first painting was genuine, then i tt'ed a bit and stormed his treasure trawler.
finding the fake is A PAIN this time around because the changes are so subtle - but i guessed right in the end and ended up with a genuine one too. take that, cousin.

 

[Xane_MM]

Redd gave me a Dynamic Painting, which was real!

 

[EvilTheCat6600]

My first was the Perfect Painting. Got it today...and as an added bonus, I'm pretty sure (at least if I'm remember all those guides I read correctly) it's also one of those paintings without a forgery. So I got a painting that can never be a fake to begin with ^.^

Also, when I saw his original price tag for the painting I just about died. I figured that was going to be the permanent pricing to buy artwork.

 

[Imbri]

I’m pretty sure having the first art you obtain being fake would cause some issues.

But it would be very much like Redd to do that.


I got the quaint painting, which can be fake, so that was good.

 

[Selky]

Everyone's first one is real. After that, when he visits, you board his ship and there will be the four to choose from (that you have to inspect for the real one).

 

[jenikinz]

Mine was the glowing painting.

 

[Sweetley]

Got a Famous painting from him and it was real.

 

[Dormire]

I think the first painting is always real. It's a prerequisite to expand the museum, after all.

 

[niconii]

I got the dynamic painting! And like everyone who's posted, it was genuine.

 

[Shinjukuwu]

I got the Serene Painting, reaaaaal!

 

[ElliotAdoresYou]

I got the real perfect painting as my first one, and bought the real glowing painting the next day- it's kinda funny because I actually have a copy of the fighting temeraire in my house so getting the acnh version of it was really cool lmao

 

[JacquesZeBird]

Even though the first painting is a guaranteed genuine painting, I didn't know about this when he showed up. I almost didn't buy it, but I changed my mind quickly and bought it anyways. Had I not, I know I would've felt silly reading all of this now lol
Also I got the quaint painting for my first painting

 

[Flunkifera]

I got a real glowing painting. He first wanted like 500k for it but because we are like cousins he only charged me 5k lmao

 

[R. Planet]

Common painting.

 

[Spooky.]

Real. I got the starry night painting (I think it's called famous painting in game?)