my rankings are not based on looks or cuteness.. but by personality. i'm indifferent to their looks, as long as they are nice and/or don't annoy me i like them.
Freya, Cookie, and Lolly are my current favorite villagers. The rest more or less just take up space. Marcie was one of my favorites, but she moved away ( time traveling hijinks that I deeply regret and have since sworn off time traveling all together). As god as my witness, I will get her back in my town.